•  Dr. Bob   ( @DrBob@lemmy.ca ) 
    link
    fedilink
    English
    41
    edit-2
    5 months ago

    This is probably the worst of these kind of illustrations that I have seen. Notably the final panel is not the removal of systemic barriers but rather a use of resources to balance out disadvantage so that “equal” remedies are now a solution. There are problems in every panel though.

    •  m0darn   ( @m0darn@lemmy.ca ) 
      link
      fedilink
      English
      225 months ago

      It’s kinda hard to illustrate them taking turns picking the fruit and equitably sharing what they pick each time. What happens if a third person shows up. Or if one of these people is selling the apples for export to a prosperous country and the other is feeding the destitute in their village.

      But you don’t need to know the co-ordinates of perfection to know which direction is better.

  • The thing that gets people up in arms is that you can’t see the shape of tree nearly as easily* as you can see the height of the ladders, so the “equality” solution may just look like giving an advantage to your favorite group.

    *Yes, we have ways to see the shape of the tree, but that’s through studies and trusting experts, whereas you can see the height of the ladders plainly.