- cross-posted to:
- quebec@lemmy.ca
Court rules judge can hear case that alleges appointment of Mary Simon violates constitutional rules for bilingualism
- grte ( @grte@lemmy.ca ) 47•1 year ago
These organizations need to calm down over this one. You’re really going to try to get rid of the first Indigenous governor general because she doesn’t sufficiently represent a settler culture?
- moody ( @moody@lemmings.world ) 7•1 year ago
I’m not gonna weigh in on whether they’re right or wrong for it, but Quebec has almost a quarter of the country’s population. It makes sense to want to be represented properly. I also think it’s important to have the indigenous population represented though. I don’t think it’s all black and white.
I can see why they’re doing it, but I don’t know if they’re right to do it.
- girlfreddy ( @girlfreddy@mastodon.social ) 3•1 year ago
Yup. Historically Quebec was treated as a second-tier province because of the religious sectarianism that migrated with the British/French colonizers. Most of Canada’s PM’s were Protestant and most of Quebecoise were RC.
After the religious aspect began fading into the background Quebecoise still felt disenfranchised (which, in reality, they were) so the focus became language/culture vs religious affiliation. Then the October crisis happened.
- Sir_Osis_of_Liver ( @Sir_Osis_of_Liver@kbin.social ) 2•1 year ago
To be a pedantic, they’re a fifth of the population (approx. 21%), down from 27% in 1971 and about 35% at the time of confederation.
Your point still stands though. The convention for GGs has been to alternate between English and French, though typically bilingual in both to a greater or lesser extent.
- Backspacecentury ( @Backspacecentury@kbin.social ) 6•1 year ago
Yeah, this is so tone deaf. Par for the course with the language police though.
- corsicanguppy ( @corsicanguppy@lemmy.ca ) 1•1 year ago
“settler culture”? I think Oregon Trail was a ways back.
- stillwater ( @stillwater@lemm.ee ) English1•1 year ago
So are some Quebecois language police types.
- Sir_Osis_of_Liver ( @Sir_Osis_of_Liver@kbin.social ) 14•1 year ago
It’s a waste of time on their part. Selection of the GG is a federal power exclusively, and made by the monarch based on the advise of the PM.
Language doesn’t enter into it, beyond the convention of alternating between anglophone and French GGs.Edit: I remember the hoopla when her appointment was made and a number of complaints made to the Commissioner of Official Languages, who investigated the complaints at the time.
Here’s the preliminary response:
https://www.clo-ocol.gc.ca/en/newsroom/2021-11-26/statement-commissioner-official-languages-canada-preliminary-investigation?wbdisable=trueOne of the important bits:
Furthermore, the Prime Minister, who is not a federal institution subject to the Act, has full authority to appoint any person to the position of Governor General and is not bound by any recommendations issued by the Privy Council Office. For all of these reasons, the conclusions in my preliminary investigation report on the process that led to the 2021 appointment of the Governor General are that the complaints are unfounded.
This is the best summary I could come up with:
A group of Quebecers have cleared a major hurdle in their efforts to have Canada’s governor general removed because she does not speak French.
In her June decision, Quebec superior court judge Catherine Piché wrote that the crown is not a federal office, but rather represents the sovereign’s presence in Canada.
The lawsuit was launched by two Quebecers’ rights associations, including Justice pour le Québec, which was led by Frédéric Bastien until his death earlier this year.
That association has previously defended Quebec’s ban on religious symbols, and has called for the closure of the Roxham Road border crossing used primarily by asylum seekers.
In 2020, he filed a complaint after the Canadian Human Rights Commission failed to provide a French version of a federal challenge to Quebec’s secularism law.
The lawyer representing the groups in the governor general case told La Presse on Wednesday that the lawsuit was not an attack on Simon, but rather a “question of principle” and respect for Canada’s constitution, the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
I’m a bot and I’m open source!
- blakcod ( @blakcod@lemmy.ca ) 5•1 year ago
So what about the deaf community? Doesn’t sign language need to be also considered at an national level? Oh right there is someone that helps just like a bilingual translator.
Again making a fuss about something common sense has overruled.
Same issue with bringing in medication from out of country without bilingual instructions. We all have devices and access to something to translate. I’d happily have all French medication if it meant relief of symptoms.
- Pulptastic ( @Pulptastic@midwest.social ) English6•1 year ago
English sign language or French sign language?
- blakcod ( @blakcod@lemmy.ca ) 3•1 year ago
🤌👌👍
- DerisionConsulting ( @DerisionConsulting@lemmy.ca ) English2•1 year ago
For English, are you talking about ASL, or BSL? For French, I assume you’d be talking about LSQ and not LSF?
- Cyborganism ( @cyborganism@lemmy.ca ) 2•1 year ago
I think it’s important that medication has both English and French instructions.
If we imported meds from France instead of the USA and didn’t translate the instructions, I can bet you tried the English community in Canada would understandably not be happy about it.
- blakcod ( @blakcod@lemmy.ca ) 1•1 year ago
If this is your thoughts I would start making a stink about Google translate not being aware and or able to translate French for Quebec vs France/World.
There are enough tools nowadays that a person can get through most of the hurdles of over the counter/publicly available products and services not in their native language. The other thing is those products and services usually come with technical writers in that industry writing the instructions so it’s more plausible that a translation is more likely word for word.
- Cyborganism ( @cyborganism@lemmy.ca ) 5•1 year ago
How about we get rid of that position once and for all and get rid of the monarchy altogether to finally become a truly independent country, and stop wasting millions on this?
- Cyborganism ( @cyborganism@lemmy.ca ) 2•1 year ago
I was really afraid this thread would turn into a typical /r/Canada type Québec bashing thread.
I’m so happy to see some nuanced opinions on the subject instead where people don’t see it as all black and white.
I have good hope for the Lemmy community.
- T (they/she) ( @Templa@beehaw.org ) 3•1 year ago
[…] Bastien filed a human rights complaint for racism after being denied a job opportunity as a white man. The role was only open to women, Indigenous people, people with disabilities and people of colour.
Hard to have a nuanced opinion with things like this. I agree that the position shouldn’t exist and we should be free of the monarchy, but it seems the priorities are extremely wrong and they are just using the bilingual law for their agenda.