You can already guess the third sentence: the servers have been a disaster at launch, with players forced to queue for long periods just to play alone, if they can manage to play at all. It currently sits “Mostly Negative” reviews on Steam - that’s 31% positive after almost 19,000 reviews.
“Online only was a huge mistake,” says one review. “Imagine waiting for an hour and ten minutes and still not being able to get into a private game,” says the one underneath. “this game makes me feel the developers made this game just so they could pull off the biggest heist of all time. robbing us of an offline mode,” says another. There are hundreds more like this.
The official Payday X (formerly Twitter) account has been tracking the issues, noting “slow matchmaking” on September 21st, and an outright “matchmaking outage” yesterday on September 22nd. As of twelve hours ago, the account posted that they’re “seeing players being able to create lobbies again,” but that there “still might have a few issues” that they’re working on. Throughout it all, the account has been getting roasted by players who can’t play, or who simply want an offline mode.
It’s not that they try to reinvent the wheel, it is that they allocate resources for X amount of players that they expect on a daily basis, and on launch they get 5X players. So everything crashes
It’s this. It’s a business decision. You don’t spin servers up in a second and take them down hours later, there’s contracts involved. You spin up enough servers to handle the load you expect normally, not at launch.
Honestly I played Payday 1 A LOT, enough to be in the top 1% of 1% of players. Got invited to the studios after being among the first to complete the ARG.
Then played Payday 2 A LOT.
But I quit halfway through the lifetime of 2 because it was clearly not getting any better, but worse. They stopped innovating and just started looking at player builds and releasing more and more powerful bulldozers. Got boring really fast.
So when 3 was announced? I haven’t even looked at it.