As it is now, it’s quite inconvenient to not be able to see a community’s actual subscriber count from an instance and instead see how many are subscribed to it from the current instance; makes it hard to judge their activity from a search, and is confusing for new users.
A shared user count directly in lemmy would be very useful.
Hiding subscriber counts is intentional at join-Lemmy.org. They were being displayed about 2 weeks ago, but new users saw them, viewed actively as a form of social proof, and only signed up with large instances.
Problem is, those large instances are starting to break now. They can’t scale fast enough to meet demand.
Moreover, if you signup for a small instance, you can still subscribe to communities from another instance. Communities are shared between instances.
IMHO, we should be displaying stats like response time and integration with the federation network. That’s what is actually important for most folks. If you only focus on local activity, you’re going to have a bad time.
People joining those large communities from other instances isn’t a problem though, right?
I meant a shared user count for communities when viewed from any instance; if anything it seems like that would make the less populated instances seem more ‘active’ and attract new users more.
I would even say that instances should not become so disproportionate big.
It somewhat defeats the point if the whole federation is just two major instances ^^
Actually you want to join a medium size to larger community that has some history and is aligned with your interests and geography. This makes content discovery a lot easier. At least medium size and been around awhile suggests too that the admins might know what they are doing and keep it around awhile longer.
Just saying size and history do have value.