• TehPers ( TehPers@beehaw.org ) 
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    51 minutes ago

    In 1865, William Stanley Jevons noticed that as steam engines became more efficient and required less coal to produce a unit of work, more coal was consumed overall. The now cheaper unit of work opened up many new applications, increasing the total volume of work needed.

    Every time a tool makes writing code cheaper, demand for software grows faster than its production cost falls. That is how the number of programmers grew from a few thousand in the early fifties to hundreds of thousands in the nineties, from millions in the two thousands to tens of millions today, despite the fact that a modern developer has a framework, an IDE, a package manager, and search engines…

    What we’ve seen with AI is the opposite. Mass layoffs, lower salaries, lower demand for programmers. We’re seeing the opposite effect now, which leads you to question whether AI is making writing code cheaper at all.

    Logically, the paradox makes sense. When you boost the productivity of your employees, they become more valuable. You want more of these boosted employees because they produce more for their cost than before.

    When coal use becomes more efficient, your costs shift from coal to other parts of your business. The coal becomes more valuable because the value one rock provides is greater for the cost than before. You want to burn coal because each piece burned becomes that much more profit.

    With AI, we’ve seen businesses (supposedly) demand tokens. They melt through them. But tokens aren’t getting cheaper, they’re getting more expensive. They aren’t producing more for their cost like coal did because the price rises with the consumption and over time. Instead, businesses are juggling back-room deals for free credits or discounts that are all temporary. The “token factories” are struggling to turn their sold tokens into revenue that reflects the demand. Many are struggling to turn a profit at all.

    It isn’t sustainable.