For the past 10-15 years they haven’t made any good games
I really don’t like hyperbole like this. AC Valhalla is a good game. Far too big, but it’s really well made and filled with charming details. The educational spin-off/mode in particular is brilliant. It strips out combat and collectathon nonsense and instead tells brief stories in the enormous game world they created in order to communicate history to students and those interested in the setting. Its two predecessors - Origins and Odyssey - also have great historic modes/spin-offs.
There are more good to excellent games from them, like the Anno series, those Indie-style games that they are really good at, like The Rogue Prince of Persia, Valiant Hearts (one of the best historic games of all times), Child of Light (RPG + platformer = fun), various 2D/2.5D Rayman titles, two excellent Southpark RPGs (arguably the first good games this series has ever gotten), Watch Dogs 2 (the first and so far only modern setting open world that can keep up with Rockstar), Grow Home and Grow Up (charming and innovative little 3D platformers). Hell, Far Cry 3 and its spin-off Blood Dragon fall within your date range and I have yet come across anyone who dislikes these clever games. Dislike Ubisoft’s now infamous open world template as much as you like, but these are not just extremely well made, but also dared to experiment with their themes and narrative, far more so than the overwhelming majority of open world titles.
These are just titles that came to mind, that reviewed well, saw very positive player feedback and that I also enjoyed myself a lot.
There were also duds and failed experiments, like Zombi U (Wii U zombie game that uses the controller well, but fails at most other aspects) and I Am Alive (innovative gameplay, fantastic atmosphere, but it’s so rough and cobbled together, it’s only interesting, not enjoyable). Others are clearly made with lots of care but are flawed, like The Division, which is set in a ridiculously detailed New York where every little cupboard saw more effort put into it than many entire games, but the gameplay itself is grindy and clashes with the realistic setting. The Crew 2 has a super innovative vehicle switching and world-bending mechanic, but driving physics are so horrid, they take all of the fun out of the game. The Trials series has been in perpetual decline, Ghost Recon Breakpoint needed years and years of patching to get somewhere near its far superior predecessor Wildlands.
Black Flag resynced isn’t anything other than a cash grab on nostalgia.
They rebuilt the entire game for this. Not a single asset is shared. A cash grab would have just upped the resolution and some textures and called it a day. Gameplay was also significantly improved and there’s added content. Yes, they took the easy route by remaking the most popular game in the series, but I don’t blame them, given their dire financial situation. At least they did an excellent job with this one - and it paid off. Reviews and sales are excellent.
There’s plenty to criticize Ubisoft for, like poor labor practices, harassment, DRM, monetization schemes and other anti-consumer practices, but they have made plenty of games that are at least good and a number that are undeniably excellent. I honestly find it extremely unlikely that there are none among those I named above that you wouldn’t enjoy.
None of this means that their very late AI effort is a good idea, of course. To me at least, it reads like tone-deaf execs jumping on the AI bandwagon without any actual plan, which meshes with what I’ve heard about the company’s internal workings. Many of the truly excellent games this publisher has released ended up successful despite top-down meddling, with the workers pulling off remarkable things, because they cared.
I really don’t like hyperbole like this. AC Valhalla is a good game. Far too big, but it’s really well made and filled with charming details. The educational spin-off/mode in particular is brilliant. It strips out combat and collectathon nonsense and instead tells brief stories in the enormous game world they created in order to communicate history to students and those interested in the setting. Its two predecessors - Origins and Odyssey - also have great historic modes/spin-offs.
There are more good to excellent games from them, like the Anno series, those Indie-style games that they are really good at, like The Rogue Prince of Persia, Valiant Hearts (one of the best historic games of all times), Child of Light (RPG + platformer = fun), various 2D/2.5D Rayman titles, two excellent Southpark RPGs (arguably the first good games this series has ever gotten), Watch Dogs 2 (the first and so far only modern setting open world that can keep up with Rockstar), Grow Home and Grow Up (charming and innovative little 3D platformers). Hell, Far Cry 3 and its spin-off Blood Dragon fall within your date range and I have yet come across anyone who dislikes these clever games. Dislike Ubisoft’s now infamous open world template as much as you like, but these are not just extremely well made, but also dared to experiment with their themes and narrative, far more so than the overwhelming majority of open world titles.
These are just titles that came to mind, that reviewed well, saw very positive player feedback and that I also enjoyed myself a lot.
There were also duds and failed experiments, like Zombi U (Wii U zombie game that uses the controller well, but fails at most other aspects) and I Am Alive (innovative gameplay, fantastic atmosphere, but it’s so rough and cobbled together, it’s only interesting, not enjoyable). Others are clearly made with lots of care but are flawed, like The Division, which is set in a ridiculously detailed New York where every little cupboard saw more effort put into it than many entire games, but the gameplay itself is grindy and clashes with the realistic setting. The Crew 2 has a super innovative vehicle switching and world-bending mechanic, but driving physics are so horrid, they take all of the fun out of the game. The Trials series has been in perpetual decline, Ghost Recon Breakpoint needed years and years of patching to get somewhere near its far superior predecessor Wildlands.
They rebuilt the entire game for this. Not a single asset is shared. A cash grab would have just upped the resolution and some textures and called it a day. Gameplay was also significantly improved and there’s added content. Yes, they took the easy route by remaking the most popular game in the series, but I don’t blame them, given their dire financial situation. At least they did an excellent job with this one - and it paid off. Reviews and sales are excellent.
There’s plenty to criticize Ubisoft for, like poor labor practices, harassment, DRM, monetization schemes and other anti-consumer practices, but they have made plenty of games that are at least good and a number that are undeniably excellent. I honestly find it extremely unlikely that there are none among those I named above that you wouldn’t enjoy.
None of this means that their very late AI effort is a good idea, of course. To me at least, it reads like tone-deaf execs jumping on the AI bandwagon without any actual plan, which meshes with what I’ve heard about the company’s internal workings. Many of the truly excellent games this publisher has released ended up successful despite top-down meddling, with the workers pulling off remarkable things, because they cared.