cross-posted from: https://lemmy.ca/post/72669678
In a paper published in Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems, Dr. Chris Macdonald explored the best sources of protein currently available.
To answer the question, Macdonald had to build a new holistic scoring system that combines measures of environmental impact, health, affordability and availability into a single framework.
Applying the scoring system to 20 commonly consumed protein-rich foods, the analysis found a striking pattern: every product in the highest-scoring quintile was plant-based, while every product in the lowest-scoring quintile was animal-based. Tofu ranked first overall, while cheddar cheese ranked last.
The paper argues that many existing food rating systems focus on only one aspect of a product. While useful, these single-dimension labels can obscure important trade-offs and make it difficult to compare foods comprehensively.
TOFU DOMINATION
Link to open access article https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/sustainable-food-systems/articles/10.3389/fsufs.2026.1677796/full



Its… poore science?
But in all seriousness, explain. What’s the argument against the 2018 study?
poor nemecek 2018 improperly combines disparately methodized LCA studies. if you read the studies that they, themselves, are referencing, they explicitly state that it is bad practice to combine LCA studies.
it’s possible the conclusions are correct, but the method they use to arrive at them cannot produce reliable results.
edit: this, in addition to the fact that an LCA study is very similar to a grand jury indictment: the person designing the grand jury or the person designing the LCA study can pretty much get any result they want by choosing what evidence is included.
combining a one-off study on broccoli grown on a sustainable farm with a one-off study on a luxury cheese production life cycle doesn’t actually tell us how much resources either generally requires, and using them as a paragon of either broccoli or cheese production won’t tell you what resources are required for a bowl of broccoli and cheese.
I made up the broccoli study and the cheese study, but unless you dig into the literally thousands of studies that were scooped up and stirred together here, you won’t know what data is even relevant.
poor and nemecek didn’t even bother doing that. what they did is they looked at other meta studies that similarly violated the guidance on LCA studies. the papers that they were relying on had the dignity to admit the problems with this method. the 2018 paper doesn’t even mention it.
you seem so conflicted about this, is that the one thing keeping you from caring about the climate and the lives of other beings?