cross-posted from: https://lemmy.dbzer0.com/post/609404
I mean, exactly how invasive are default operating systems? (Like Windows, Mac, Chrome OS, Android, iOS) Do they log your keystrokes, log passwords, capture screen, upload your photos, videos, or audio? (Assuming you aren’t a target of government) Is it even possible for the average person who doesn’t feel comfortable messing with installing operating systems to have any privacy?
stappern ( @stappern@lemmy.one ) English36•1 year agobtw linux is not a “custom os”
Hazzia ( @Hazzia@discuss.tchncs.de ) English8•1 year agoNot meant as a counterpoint to what you said, but I feel a strong need to make a TempleOS reference
Adanisi ( @Adanisi@lemmy.zip ) English22•1 year agoI’m not sure about mobile stuff, but Windows is very invasive. I remember people talking about how bad Windows 10 was, and it’s just gotten worse.
Some companies sell computers with Linux already on them, so if someone isn’t comfortable with changing their OS, they could try one of them (I think Lenovo does it, but they use Ubuntu so it’s not the best for privacy).
Notnotmike ( @Notnotmike@beehaw.org ) English14•1 year agoAlso worth mentioning that dual booting with windows is easy and will give you some time to transition. Get yourself used to Linux while still having a “fallback” if things get too hairy
- SSUPII ( @SSUPII@sopuli.xyz ) English4•1 year ago
That’s what I did. Windows helped me in some situations. Now its just unused wasted space I am planning on reclaiming.
macallik ( @macallik@kbin.social ) 1•1 year agoI took the same plunge this week. I partitioned 125 GB to Windows and the remaining 350GB to Debian 12. I was making do w/ a 240 GB SSD previously so it’s overkill, but I like the idea of disincentivizing my W11 usage by limiting the space available.
For me, there’s still some workflows that need to be optimized in Debian, but overall I’m slowly transitioning towards it as my main driver.
shortwavesurfer ( @shortwavesurfer@monero.town ) English5•1 year agoNot the best for privacy is still tons and tons better than winblows could ever be.
Veraticus ( @Veraticus@lib.lgbt ) English13•1 year agoBasically the question comes down to: who do you trust and why?
If you didn’t code it yourself or validate every line of code, you’re trusting someone with your privacy. Most of us have no interest in and no capability to code our own operating systems, so at some point you must trust someone else. (And even if you code your own OS, do you manufacture your own hardware?)
Linux obviously is open-source so you can verify code yourself. But there are closed-source packages and even being open-source is no guarantee people will make good privacy decisions. Still, pretty good compared to alternatives.
Google is an ad company who wants your personal information to sell you stuff. I personally don’t trust that with my privacy.
Apple is … okay. They take privacy extremely seriously and have no interest in profiting from your personal data. But they are closed source so you are trusting their implementation.
Microsoft generally sucks and I think personally they would do practically anything for a buck. So, no trust from me.
I consequently run Linux and iOS. But you have to weigh the pros and cons yourself.
kayazere ( @kayazere@feddit.nl ) English3•1 year agoAs Apple has moved from focusing on hardware to services, including ads, they do have an interest on using your data.
There was even a scandal where with the App Tracking permissions added, which reduced third party data collection, but their 1st party apps like Stocks, doesn’t respect it, continuing to collect data even when the user has denied tracking globally.
stappern ( @stappern@lemmy.one ) English11•1 year agobasically yes.
dngray ( @dngray@lemmy.one ) English9•1 year agoI certainly think so.
Even Windows or Chrome OS, provides quite a bit of “control” it’s just that a lot of it is “opt out”. Google does, for example record what YouTube videos you look at against a logged in account by default. Windows does have targeted advertising enabled by default.
I think privacy is really more about what you do on such platforms. If you use products (sites) that clearly have bad policies in regard to privacy then no OS is going to provide really all that much improvement.
Knightfox ( @Knightfox@lemmy.one ) English7•1 year agoI’m a big fan of Shutup10 (https://www.oo-software.com/en/shutup10). It’s an app you can download and run that greatly simplifies the privacy options available in Windows.
Uniquitous ( @Uniquitous@lemmy.one ) English5•1 year agoThe amount of privacy you retain is directly proportional to the level of effort you expend.
s_s ( @s_s@lemmy.one ) English4•1 year agoWindows is such a complete pain in the ass to use anymore I’m not sure Linux is really all that more difficult.
I know people have really been slow-boiled on the windows side the past 15 years or so, and the frustrations you could encounter are unique to each platform, but I really do think we’re at a point that if you can competently admin your own windows system, you can admin a linux system.
And if you can’t be assed to admin either, then you have a few options:
- Hire a nerd to admin your computer
- Only use a work computer (and non-personal stuff)
- resign to using an iPad where Apple is your admin. 😂
costa ( @costa@beehaw.org ) English4•1 year agoIt’s not full privacy or no privacy at all! Everyone has a different threat model which utilizes different practises. Yes, windows is no good for privacy, but limiting what windows can collect, and not using 3rd party software that collects even more info can be a pretty good start for most people. Also not advertising personal information on social media (or using privacy invasive social media at all)!
With just these you’ll have much better privacy than anyone around you and a pretty good level of privacy in general! You can do so much for privacy but you’ll have to face the comprimises the more private you go.
The think is do you need to go that deep for privacy or is something less private a better solution for you?
TheInsane42 ( @TheInsane42@lemmy.ml ) English4•1 year agoDepends where you buy your hardware…
I bought a laptop I could spec the way I want it, which included a choice of OS. I could choose for 32GB of ram and Windows 11 or 64 GB of ram and Ubuntu for the same prize. Ubunto has no clue how to fill all that memory. (I have, kvm is my friend)
To be honest, it’s totally worth it to spend time in messing about with custom OS on a device you can spare. Linux runs nicely on '12 hardware when you have enough memory. Even the '11 Samsung Tab S2 gets Android 13 via Lineage. Those are nice projects to start with, pick an old device and mess about. Worst that can happen is thag you have to throw it away, which you have to do anyway with the original software.
As somebody else already posted, when you don’t control your OS, somebody else will.
Quereller ( @Quereller@kbin.social ) 4•1 year agoYou can already do a lot!. Switch of all the invasive features from google. (Remove advertising ID, switch of any web and app history etc.) Install F-Droid and only use the “good” apps. Put the evil apps in a separate work profile (Shelter app). Look at the configurations of the apps and opt-out of tracking.
Configure your webbrowser to delete cookie and co. … scoobford ( @scoobford@lemmy.one ) English3•1 year agoUnfortunately, no, you don’t. However, you can buy computers with Linux preinstalled. I haven’t looked in a long time, but they were only marginally more expensive when I looked last.
Also, installing Linux isn’t difficult at all, provided that your motherboard isnt weird about booting it (really just luck of the draw, but usually not a problem), and that you’re willing to nuke all your files. Dual boot installations are where things get precarious.
IGuessICan ( @IGuessICan@lemmy.sdf.org ) English3•1 year agoWindows 10 & 11 indeed do log your keystrokes, browsing history, etc. by default, according to the T&C - also the Microsoft swiftkey keyboard for Android does as well. Here is a good guide for making Windows a little more private, although there really is no escaping at least basic telemetry, which is still way too revealing in my opinion:
https://vpnoverview.com/privacy/devices/privacy-settings-windows-10/
mrmojo ( @mrmojo@beehaw.org ) English2•1 year ago flatbield ( @furrowsofar@beehaw.org ) English3•1 year agoYou can even buy them preinstalled. I generally buy my laptops preinstalled but build my workstation myself. You do not need to be technical either as long as you have and idea of how you will work through future issues. No different than Windows in that way.
roo ( @roo@lemmy.one ) English2•1 year agoYou can track telemetry, and then block those domains.