• zurohki ( zurohki@aussie.zone ) 
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      23
      ·
      3 years ago

      Yes. Services like gas and water are natural monopolies - it doesn’t make sense to roll out two or three separate lots of distribution pipes, so you always just have one service available to you. The best option is to have them as government owned services.

        • The Cuuuuube ( Cube6392@beehaw.org ) 
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          8
          ·
          3 years ago

          You’re choosing from vendors to deal with the regional vendor. You’re just paying someone to pay the company in your area. The company you pay in this scenario literally offers you zero value. They simply exist to extract money from you.

          Alternatively, these services could be provided to you at a lower cost as part of your annual tax bill under a collaborative cooperative.

          • BorgDrone ( BorgDrone@lemmy.one ) 
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            2
            ·
            3 years ago

            You’re choosing from vendors to deal with the regional vendor. You’re just paying someone to pay the company in your area.

            That’s not how it works.

            The price you pay has 2 main components: a fixed component for network costs. This part is always the same and only depends on the type of hookup you have (e.g. an industrial power connection would cost more than a residential one). It goes to the owner of the physical power network (this depends on where you live) who uses it for things like maintenance (and of course a little profit). The network operator does not provide power themselves.

            The variable component is based on your usage and goes to the power company. The power companies provide the actual power to the national grid. While it may be true that the power coming out of my outlets wasn’t produced by the company I’m contracted with, that doesn’t really matter. Electricity is electricity. What matters is that each power company has to provide the amount of energy used by their customers to the national grid. Say company A has 100 customers that on average used 1 kilowatt-hour each, and company B has 50 customers that used the same amount on average. Then company A has to provide 100 kilowatt-hours to the national grid and company B has to provide 50 kilowatt-hours.

            How they provide that power is up to them, and usually varies. The larger energy companies have their own power plants, wind and solar farms. Smaller companies may buy energy in bulk from the larger ones and try to sell it at a profit to consumers. Energy companies may also buy or sell to/from other countries, depending on capacity and demand.

            Point is that they don’t just forward you the bill from a local company, they actually have to provide the power and outside of a few small ‘virtual’ energy companies they do produce that power.

        • jaschen ( jaschen@lemm.ee ) 
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          9
          ·
          3 years ago

          Please enlighten me on how I can start a utilities company? Make sure you give me details on how I can maximize profits to my shareholders while fucking over my customers.

          Or maybe I should start a non-profit utilities company, and the cost of your services is subsidized by taxpayers’ money. That way, I don’t have to constantly chase capitalism and make life better for my community instead of my shareholders.

        • Commiunism ( Commiunism@lemmy.wtf ) deleted by creator
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          9
          ·
          3 years ago

          If the government decides to privatize utilities like electricity/gas or whatever, then sure it is freedom for some rich business owners to open up new businesses. However, this also results in those utilities becoming profit driven (as opposed to being for the public), and literally everyone in the country having to pay much more than they were paying previously.

          My country had electricity privatized around 4 years ago, and in result we have to pay a lot more, not to mention about numerous fraud cases that were all over the news during and after the privatization period.

          If you think that rich business owners being able to open up a couple of business at the expense of fucking over the public is a good thing and being against it is some weird hexbear delusion, then I’d advise you to get out of the libertarian bubble and look at the real world instead.

  • Rivalarrival ( Rivalarrival@lemmy.today ) 
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    3 years ago

    Ohio separates distribution from supply. You can’t select the distributor who connects your home to the gas mains, but you can choose from dozens of suppliers who put gas into those mains.

    We do the same with electricity.

    • barsoap ( barsoap@lemm.ee ) 
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      3 years ago

      Same in the EU. Or at least I think so, it’s the case over here and it’s EU-wide for electricity providers. Water, sewage and garbage disposal are municipal responsibility though there’s no network/provider separation there.

      What’s actually missing is a municipal-level telecom monopoly – again, with separate providers. The last-mile network is just as much a natural monopoly for telecom as it is for other wires or pipes.

    • And when government fucked up those management, you as a citizen should held your government liable. People shouldn’t be afraid of their government, the government should be afraid of their people. Also, the government’s main priority is NOT to make a profit but rather serve the people. So there is a (theoretical) obligation for the government to make sure every citizen has access to their service even if at a loss.

        • First world countries tend to not be run for the benefit of all. Not that third world countries are either, mind you, but generally removing the profit motive from basic necessities seems to have very positive results on levels of freedom and social mobility.

          • Except when corrupt officials just pocket the money and invest nothing into infrastructure

            Monopolys aren’t good either but living in a third world country I can tell you you can find worse problems with state controlled systems than with private companies that at least have to keep you as a client somehow

              • In my experience government operated facilities are only accountable to the current government so any political wants or ideologies come first.

                In a for profit situation without a monopoly the company at least has to try to keep you as a client so there’s some give and take.

                Taking a monopoly from a company and putting it in the hands of the state is just as bad in my opinion

                Some problems don’t have a nice for all solution sadly