• NaibofTabr ( NaibofTabr@infosec.pub ) 
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    69
    ·
    3 years ago

    Even if it were possible to scan the contents of your brain and reproduce them in a digital form, there’s no reason that scan would be anything more than bits of data on the digital system. You could have a database of your brain… but it wouldn’t be conscious.

    No one has any idea how to replicate the activity of the brain. As far as I know there aren’t any practical proposals in this area. All we have are vague theories about what might be going on, and a limited grasp of neurochemistry. It will be a very long time before reproducing the functions of a conscious mind is anything more than fantasy.

    • Counterpoint, from a complex systems perspective:

      We don’t fully know or are able toodel the details of neurochemistry, but we know some essential features which we can model, action potentials in spiking neuron models for example.

      It’s likely that the details don’t actually matter much. Take traffic jams as an example. There is lots of details going on, driver psychology, the physical mechanics of the car etc. but you only need a handful of very rough parameters to reproduce traffic jams in a computer.

      That’s the thing with “emergent” phenomena, they are less complicated than the sum of their parts, which means you can achieve the same dynamics using other parts.

      • intensely_human ( intensely_human@lemm.ee ) BannedBanned
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        2
        ·
        3 years ago

        I’d say the details matter, based on the PEAR laboratory’s findings that consciousness can affect the outcomes of chaotic systems.

        Perhaps the reason evolution selected for enormous brains is that’s the minimum necessary complexity to get a system chaotic enough to be sensitive to and hence swayed by conscious will.

        • PEAR? Where staff participated in trials, rather than doing double blind experiments? Whose results could not be reproduced by independent research groups? Who were found to employ p-hacking and data cherry picking?

          You might as well argue that simulating a human mind is not possible because it wouldn’t have a zodiac sign.

    • Sombyr ( Sombyr@lemmy.zip ) deleted by creator
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      15
      ·
      3 years ago

      We don’t even know what consciousness is, let alone if it’s technically “real” (as in physical in any way.) It’s perfectly possible an uploaded brain would be just as conscious as a real brain because there was no physical thing making us conscious, and rather it was just a result of our ability to think at all.
      Similarly, I’ve heard people argue a machine couldn’t feel emotions because it doesn’t have the physical parts of the brain that allow that, so it could only ever simulate them. That argument has the same hole in that we don’t actually know that we need those to feel emotions, or if the final result is all that matters. If we replaced the whole “this happens, release this hormone to cause these changes in behavior and physical function” with a simple statement that said “this happened, change behavior and function,” maybe there isn’t really enough of a difference to call one simulated and the other real. Just different ways of achieving the same result.

      My point is, we treat all these things, consciousness, emotions, etc, like they’re special things that can’t be replicated, but we have no evidence to suggest this. It’s basically the scientific equivalent of mysticism, like the insistence that free will must exist even though all evidence points to the contrary.

      • let alone if it’s technically “real” (as in physical in any way.)

        This right here might already be a flaw in your argument. Something doesn’t need to be physical to be real. In fact, there’s scientific evidence that physical reality itself is an illusion created through observation. That implies (although it cannot prove) that consciousness may be a higher construct that exists outside of physical reality itself.

        If you’re interested in the philosophical questions this raises, there’s a great summary article that was published in Nature: https://www.nature.com/articles/436029a

        • Sombyr ( Sombyr@lemmy.zip ) deleted by creator
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          8
          ·
          3 years ago

          On the contrary, it’s not a flaw in my argument, it is my argument. I’m saying we can’t be sure a machine could not be conscious because we don’t know that our brain is what makes us conscious. Nor do we know where the threshold is where consciousness arises. It’s perfectly possible all we need is to upload an exact copy of our brain into a machine, and it’d be conscious by default.

          • NaibofTabr ( NaibofTabr@infosec.pub ) 
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            2
            ·
            3 years ago

            The problem with this is that even if a machine is conscious, there’s no reason it would be conscious like us. I fully agree that consciousness could take many forms, probably infinite forms - and there’s no reason to expect that one form would be functionally or technically compatible with another.

            What does the idea “exact copy of our brain” mean to you? Would it involve emulating the physical structure of a human brain? Would it attempt to abstract the brain’s operations from the physical structure? Would it be a collection of electrical potentials? Simulations of the behavior of specific neurochemicals? What would it be in practice, that would not be hand-wavy fantasy?

            • Sombyr ( Sombyr@lemmy.zip ) deleted by creator
              link
              fedilink
              arrow-up
              4
              ·
              3 years ago

              I suppose I was overly vague about what I meant by “exact copy.” I mean all of the knowledge, memories, and an exact map of the state of our neurons at the time of upload being uploaded to a computer, and then the functions being simulated from there. Many people believe that even if we could simulate it so perfectly that it matched a human brain’s functions exactly, it still wouldn’t be conscious because it’s still not a real human brain. That’s the point I was arguing against. My argument was that if we could mimic human brain functions closely enough, there’s no reason to believe the brain is so special that a simulation could not achieve consciousness too.
              And you’re right, it may not be conscious in the same way. We have no reason to believe either way that it would or wouldn’t be, because the only thing we can actually verify is conscious is ourself. Not humans in general, just you, individually. Therefore, how conscious something is is more of a philosophical debate than a scientific one because we simply cannot test if it’s true. We couldn’t even test if it was conscious at all, and my point wasn’t that it would be, my point is that we have no reason to believe it’s possible or impossible.

              • intensely_human ( intensely_human@lemm.ee ) BannedBanned
                link
                fedilink
                arrow-up
                1
                ·
                3 years ago

                Unfortunately the physics underlying brain function are chaotic systems, meaning infinite (or “maximum”) precision is required to ensure two systems evolve to the same later states.

                That level of precision cannot be achieved in measuring the state, without altering the state into something unknown after the moment of measurement.

                Nothing quantum is necessary for this inability to determine state. Consider the problem of trying to map out where the eight ball is on a pool table, but you can’t see the eight ball. All you can do is throw other balls at it and observe how their velocities change. Now imagine you can’t see those balls either, because the sensing mechanism you’re using is composed of balls of equal or greater size.

                Unsolvable problem. Like a box trying to contain itself.

            • intensely_human ( intensely_human@lemm.ee ) BannedBanned
              link
              fedilink
              arrow-up
              1
              ·
              3 years ago

              We make a giant theme park where people can interact with androids. Then we make a practically infinite number of copies of this theme park. We put androids in the copies and keep providing feedback to alter their behavior until they behave exactly like the people in the theme park.

          • I see that’s certainly a different way of looking at it :) Of course I can’t say with any authority that it must be wrong, but I think it’s a flaw because it seems you’re presuming that consciousness arises from physical properties. If the physical act of copying a brain’s data were to give rise to consciousness, that would imply consciousness is a product of physical reality. But my position (and that of the paper I linked) is that physical reality is a product of mental consciousness.

  • Schmoo ( Schmoo@slrpnk.net ) 
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    36
    ·
    3 years ago

    If anyone’s interested in a hard sci-fi show about uploading consciousness they should watch the animated series Pantheon. Not only does the technology feel realistic, but the way it’s created and used by big tech companies is uncomfortably real.

    The show got kinda screwed over on advertising and fell to obscurity because of streaming service fuck ups and region locking, and I can’t help but wonder if it’s at least partially because of its harsh criticisms of the tech industry.

    • Gnome Kat ( GnomeKat@lemmy.blahaj.zone ) 
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      6
      ·
      3 years ago

      Just FYI content warning for Pantheon there is a seriously disturbing gore/kill scene that is animated too well in the first season. Anyone who has seen the show knows what scene I am talking about, I found the scene pretty upsetting and I almost didn’t finish the show. I am still a little upset that the scene is burned in my memory.

    • Kairos ( LodeMike@lemmy.today ) 
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      4
      ·
      3 years ago

      The show got kinda screwed over on advertising and fell to obscurity because of streaming service fuck ups and region locking, and I can’t help but wonder if it’s at least partially because of its harsh criticisms of the tech industry.

      Okay so I can’t 100% confirm this, but the first season wasn’t popular because it was on whatever the fuck AMC+ is. Amazon bought it because of the writer’s strike to get something out.

    • localme ( localme@lemm.ee ) 
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      3
      ·
      3 years ago

      Yes, I just finished watching Pantheon and absolutely loved it!

      Totally agree that it deserved more attention. At least it got a proper ending with season 2.

      Also, the voice acting talent they got was impressive. Paul Dano was fantastic as one of the leads.

  • Stage Owl ( stage_owl@pawb.social ) 
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    29
    ·
    3 years ago

    Soma is a wonderful game that covers this type of thing. It does make you wonder what consciousness really is… Maybe the ability to perceive and store information, along with retrieving that information, is enough to provide an illusion of consistent self?

    Or maybe it’s some competely strange system, unkown to science. Who knows?

  • wallmenis ( wallmenis@lemmy.one ) 
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    22
    ·
    3 years ago

    What if you do it in a ship of theseus type of way. Like, swapping each part of the brain with an electronic one slowly until there is no brain left.

    Wonder if that will work.

  • Python ( python@programming.dev ) 
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    9
    ·
    3 years ago

    Related book recommendation!!

    Kil’n People by David Brin - it’s a futuristic Murder Mystery Novel about a society where people copy their consciousnesses to temporary clay clones to do mundane tasks for them. Got some really interesting discussions about what constitutes personhood!

    • evranch ( evranch@lemmy.ca ) 
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      3 years ago

      Some of the concepts in this book really stuck with me, but I had no idea what the title was! Thanks!

      “Some days you’re the original, some days you’re the copy” or something like that