•  dan   ( @dan@upvote.au ) 
    link
    fedilink
    10
    edit-2
    4 months ago

    I’m probably going to be downvoted for saying this, but since the ad supported internet is here to stay, wouldn’t you rather see ads that at least somewhat match your interests, if they use a technique that moves some of the attribution logic that used to run on third-party servers to instead be done in your web browser?

    There’s a few models that have worked well online:

    • You pay for the content/service directly
    • Paid users subsidise the free users (“freemium” services)
    • Someone else covers the cost (which is how a lot of Lemmy servers operate for example)
    • You don’t pay anything and it’s ad-supported

    The last is very common. People expect to get high quality content and services, but don’t want to pay anything for it (or can’t afford it), which is why the ad supported model is so prevalent. It’s not going away any time soon, and advertisers are already tracking you. Wouldn’t you want to use a system that involves less tracking?

    •  makeasnek   ( @makeasnek@lemmy.ml ) OP
      link
      fedilink
      English
      9
      edit-2
      4 months ago

      I’d rather not have ads at all and just pay $5 a month and have all the websites I visit get a portion of that $5. Some people tried this years ago, but the payment infrastructure wasn’t ready for it. Nostr can do it now though, their users “zapped” (tipped) nearly 1M USD (950k) over the past two months alone to content creators on their platform (twitter clone). And there’s a feature to automatically split a set donation among all the posts you’ve liked. No reason that can’t be done for the entire web. All instant, all with incredibly low fees, all payments made directly from you to the site you visited, no middlemen having to manage custody risk.

      Browser extension tracks what sites I visit and then at the end of the month send them all tips. Sites could detect such an extension and automatically not show ads if you have it installed.

      •  dan   ( @dan@upvote.au ) 
        link
        fedilink
        64 months ago

        I like the idea. I used Flattr for a while maybe 10 years ago, which was a similar concept.

        Having said that, for many sites, a portion of $5/month wouldn’t be enough to cover all their expenses, and in some cases they’d make more money via advertising.

      • Wait, so you want a browser extension that tracks you… so you can avoid Mozilla not tracking you??

        I understand wanting the micropayments thing. I want that as well. But you’re literally advocating tracking here.

        •  makeasnek   ( @makeasnek@lemmy.ml ) OP
          link
          fedilink
          English
          1
          edit-2
          4 months ago

          The difference is that such an extension isn’t reporting my traffic to a “trusted third party”. My browser is doing the tracking locally and sending micropayments to sites I visit.

          • You said browser extension. And how do you think those payments go through? Mozilla isn’t a payment provider. And even payment providers use downstream companies to actually move the money around. So either you trust Mozilla to choose a trusted third party……orrrr you trust a third party extension to choose another trusted third party, and that one is now handling your payment information.

            •  makeasnek   ( @makeasnek@lemmy.ml ) OP
              link
              fedilink
              English
              1
              edit-2
              4 months ago

              There’s lots of ways this could be done quickly, easily, and privately. A previous attempt at this (flattr) was promising but before its time. Making Bitcoin micropayments via lightning comes to mind as a way to do this. In the past two months alone, Nostr users (decentralized twitter clone similar to mastodon) have tipped each other around a million dollars for their posts. There have been nearly three million tips in the last two months. Sending funds via lightning takes under a second for pennies or less in fees. No intermediary to report your browsing history to, no need to trust an intermediary to handle payments, no burdensome need for Mozilla to run payment infrastructure, and it all works in every country right out of the box. And there’s plenty of room for this to scale since it’s not limited by blockchain space.

              Nostr already has a feature to automatically split up your tips according to which posts you reacted to. You can say “I want to tip $5 a month, split it up among posts I react with a heart to”. This could easily be extended to which websites you visited, all websites would need to do is put their lightning url in the page source, DNS record, etc.

              Nostr stats: https://stats.nostr.band/

  •  Melody Fwygon   ( @Melody@lemmy.one ) 
    link
    fedilink
    English
    4
    edit-2
    4 months ago

    I can already see how Advertisers AND Websites will collude and break this one.

    • Specifically placed ads; targeted at specific website pages which a majority of their target grouping will visit.
    • Generate an ad that will specifically reside on a page deep inside of the site; think 4+ clicks deep; which is intensely personalized to their target. 1
    • Ad will trigger; register “Impression” and be boxed up into Differential Privacy set by the DAP.
    • Since that’s the only ad targeted for that specific page, any impression is an answer of 1 or ‘True’.
    • Through microtargeting of these deep pages they can learn a lot about what people do online and could potentially break Differential Privacy.

    1 - In this example the URI being targeted could be something like https://www.example.com/zhuli/do/the/* in such a way that when you visit https://example.com/zhuli/do/the/thing/order.php is always recorded.