cross-posted from: https://discuss.tchncs.de/post/45277582

Opening my weather app this morning I was greeted by this warning:

Google has announced that, starting in 2026/2027, all apps on certified Android devices will require the developer to submit personal identity details directly to Google. Since the developers of this app do not agree to this requirement, this app will no longer work on certified Android devices after that time.

It’s the first time I hear about this, seems to be about:

Tech crunch article from august, “google will require developer verification for android apps outside the play store”

Cirrus app: Github

Was this a big thing I somehow missed? I hope more devs will follow suit.

  • lath ( lath@piefed.social ) 
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    22
    ·
    1 year ago

    Technically, this would allow the identification of malware providers in Google’s app store.

    Practically, every us citizen’s personal identification details were taken by doge idiots and are likely by now up for sale at a cheap price, so false identification by malware providers is pretty much guaranteed.

    It’s a “we covered our ass” policy same as any “save the children” that does anything but the implied thing.

    • wizardbeard ( wizardbeard@lemmy.dbzer0.com ) 
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      12
      ·
      1 year ago

      This is about all app makers, not just ones in the Google Play Store. This also applies to third party app devs and hobbiests making open source apps to put up on alternative app stores like the all open source F-Droid.

    • Technically, this would allow the identification of malware providers in Google’s app store.

      play store publishers are already needed to submit (and publish) their name and address. they made it a requirement ~5 years ago.

    • jcarax ( jcarax@beehaw.org ) 
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      9
      ·
      1 year ago

      Unfortunately, I think the vast majority who care are already using one. However, with Google device tree and other shenanigans on Pixel devices, it probably makes substantial room within the niche market for the likes of Fairphone and Shiftphone to get into new regions.

      On the other hand, mandates for major operating systems to report illegal activity that are in the pipeline could have a larger effect.

      I dunno, I’m talking out my ass.

        • hdnclr ( hdnclr@beehaw.org ) 
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          7
          ·
          1 year ago
          1. A shitton of people have lived economic realities that don’t allow them to splurge on a phone at all, even if they’d really like digital freedom or privacy. See: half of the global smartphone market, where Android Go and KaiOS enabling cheap smartphones lead to millions of sales.

          2. People who can and want to don’t even make the jump because the reality of owning a non-iOS/Android phone is that it requires sacrifices. I went to a concert last night that required me to have the Ticketmaster app to even get in. Everyone at that concert had to have either an iOS or Android phone, myself included. I’m testing Ubuntu Touch on a second phone, but if I make it my daily driver, I’m going to have to keep a second phone around for stuff like that. Ecosystems are too locked down now, and unfortunately you will have to either miss out on some things, or adapt hard-core.

          3. The devices and software have to be there. Right now there are only a handful of truly modern devices thar you can load Ubuntu Touch or another Linux distro on, and they’re… not quite straightforward for non-techy people to get up and running. Which is, believe it or not, the vast majority of users.

          2025 being the year of the alternative smartphone OS seems just about as likely as any other year being the year of the Linux desktop.

        • ulterno ( ulterno@programming.dev ) 
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          3
          ·
          1 year ago

          I am going to refute you over here.
          I can’t seem afford a Linux phone (or any mobile device really), simply because they tend to be made by labour in high-pay countries, while I am in a low pay country (which means I am not paid as much either).

          And then I can’t afford to try any possibly existing Linux ROMs on my phone, because I can’t afford to brick it at all.

    • KeenFlame ( KeenFlame@feddit.nu ) 
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      1 year ago

      Ah yes cause that’s the only part of any platform that requires a full name and address and will absolutely make a dent when the walled garden servants now have to use their slave names people sure will Exodus in droves

  • stray ( stray@pawb.social ) 
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    1 year ago

    I’m really confused by this. First, does any phone running a legit copy of Android count as a “certified Android device”?

    How can they enforce this for apps not on the play store? Like if I write my own APK will my phone just refuse to run it if I don’t go through some paperwork with Google? How does that work?

    Like if they’re capable of this then why aren’t they doing it already to prevent piracy?

    • certified android devices are those you can get in most stores. the play store is important for many people, ajd many apps don’t work correctly without the google mobile services components, and device makers can only legally install these on their phones if they certify their device. the certification process requires an array of quality controls and restrictions.

      How can they enforce this for apps not on the play store?

      certified devices will need to integrate an app verifier that will check if an app has been approved by google. the public AOSP project is said to also get this, but anyone basing on it can rip it out or modify it to their advantage. but certified device makers don’t have a choice thn to include this restriction.

      Like if I write my own APK will my phone just refuse to run it if I don’t go through some paperwork with Google?

      what we know so far, apps you made can be installed through a development tool. but app store aps like fdroid don’t have access to this tool, it’s difficult to enable, and somewhat risky too

    • bl4kers ( bl4kers@beehaw.org ) 
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      1 year ago

      First, does any phone running a legit copy of Android count as a “certified Android device”?

      Yes

      How can they enforce this for apps not on the play store?

      Checks will be built into the operating system and run on install attempts

      Like if write my own APK will my phone just refuse to run it if I don’t go through some paperwork with Google?

      Yes

      How does that work?

      TBD. Probably a database check

      Like if they’re capable of this then why aren’t they doing it already to prevent piracy?

      Piracy of what?

      • maybe a dumb question but i’ve been looking at both lineage and graphene. i currently have a s24+ so obvs i’m going to need a new one anyway to do anything. is one better than the other? i do have google fi (i don’t like google services but it’s a cheap phone plan compared to verizon). it seems like google fi works fine on graphene with the sandboxed google fi app would it work as good on lineage? and if so what do you think about pixel 9 vs 8? i was leaning for the 8/9a vs the pro since i wanted to keep my s24 just in case but if the a series is that much worse then i’ll just bite the bullet.

        • I just recently replaced my Moto G7 power which lasted me about 6 years.

          Lineage OS for me provides a really nice experience where I’m in control of the device. I do wish Lineage OS had bootloader locking support since many devices do support it. However, I get where the devs are coming from.

        • 0xD ( 0xD@infosec.pub ) 
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          2
          ·
          1 year ago

          Graphene is by far the most technically secure option and it allows you to choose for yourself how much google you want on your phone. But you need a google phone. Lineage, as far as I know, is “just” a custom ROM with more device flexibility.

          My experience with Lineage is very old and I’ve been running Graphene for more than a year now. So take it with that in mind.