You mean about adding SSD to gnome, which will not happen?
As an argument in favour, I see:
Support for more applications that “don’t want” to implement CSD (i.e. foot terminal, davinci resolve, that one archive manager I can’t remember)
Lifting burden for applications that don’t need custom decoration buttons, and so don’t care about implementing their own decorations
Making the decorations on those applications consistent with the theming of the system
As an argument against, I personally don’t see any. Sure, most gtk apps are designed for CSD and will not translate well to SSD, but I just don’t see why that should stop gnome from implementing SSD. I remember the gnome maintainers were strongly convinced against SSD, but I don’t remember their argument
You mean about adding SSD to gnome, which will not happen?
As an argument in favour, I see:
As an argument against, I personally don’t see any. Sure, most gtk apps are designed for CSD and will not translate well to SSD, but I just don’t see why that should stop gnome from implementing SSD. I remember the gnome maintainers were strongly convinced against SSD, but I don’t remember their argument