As an Indigenous Canadian, I think the whole Avatar series is sickening
An invading colonizing force of foreign people invading a native people … but the natives are incapable of helping themselves so they need a white saviour to lead them in the fight against their oppressors
It’s basically cultural appropriation masked as a space opera
The worst part of it is how wealthy European people are still able in the most imaginative ways possible are able to monetize the misery and memory of oppressed people. Not only did they destroy entire cultures, they spend a good part of their time making money off of that memory and history.
The only thing I enjoy about the films is the AI, CGI and special effects … beyond that, the writing is just another continuation of white people fantasizing about what it would be like to be a heroic Indigenous person who wins over colonizers … a fantasy that has never been allowed to exist in reality.
My favorite movie about an Indigenous person taking on an invading and/or colonizing force is Prey. No white savior there.
Good shit there for sure.
It’s kind of messed up how many pieces of media share that title. The 2006 video game is also about an indigenous person fighting aliens, but otherwise completely unrelated…
oh yes
I completely agree with you. Cameron always gets so triggered whenever he’s faced with this criticism as well, like all rich white American liberals. He doesn’t even try to hide these views because he’s so incredibly clueless:
In an interview with The Guardian in 2010, Cameron said the Lakota Sioux Nation was a “hopeless” and “dead-end society”.
The interview was prompted by Cameron’s visit to the Xingu tribe, located in the Amazon, who were fighting against the development of the Belo Monte hydroelectric dam.
During his time there he witnessed cultural ceremonies.
“I felt like I was 130 years back in time, watching what the Lakota Sioux might have been saying at a point when they were being pushed and they were being killed and they were being asked to displace,” he said.
He noted that ‘this was the driving force’ in creating Avatar.
“I couldn’t help but think that if [the Lakota Sioux] had had a time-window and they could see the future… and they could see their kids committing suicide at the highest suicide rate in the nation… because they were hopeless and they were a dead-end society – which is what is happening now – they would have fought a lot harder.” Source
To close open threads you’d first need a plot, James.
These marketing campaigns are getting a bit extreme (and simultaneously really whiney)
movie trailer voice "See Avatar: Fire and Ash in theaters now, or else! "
" …or else James Cameron is gonna be really sad, you guys, and he’s gonna quit and just make a book, you guys. You guys!"
Don’t threaten me with a good time.
He says, as if he’s not responsible for three out of four of the top grossing movies of all time…
The movies may be bland as all fuck, but the man knows how to put arses on cinema seats.
Not mine. The Avatar crap was too boring to even watch at home.
You can’t even watch it at home as intended. You’d need 3D (which is dead) and high frame rates for certain scenes (which aren’t supported).
deleted by creator
Yeah, we had Forest Avatar and Ocean Avatar. Now we have Fire Avatar, which still leaves room for Earth Avatar and Wind Avatar before they have to go fight the space cats.
Each one will have the same story, but still get stretched to 4 hours.
deleted by creator
Why does he have to keep making sequels to it? Like, I know Avatar was the highest grossing box office movie at the time it came out, but at the same time it’s hardly spoken of. Nobody’s quoting it. I haven’t seen memes of it since around its release. What even happened to get it those ticket sales? It doesn’t seem to actually be a popular film and yet… It is?
First well made 3D movie(as in the one that required a special glass to see) i guess? I too can’t figure out the popularity of it.
Edit: now i remember a bit more, it’s basically that. it released at the time when 3d cinema is still a fresh, exciting new thing, and Avatar came out and did the 3d justice, so everyone is excited to experience this and every recommendation is basically “best experience it in 3d”. I remember when it released in bluray, people basically said it lost the charm because it isn’t in 3d. But i guess it’s still a competently made movie because the second one made as much money as the first one.
The only reason the first one was any good was because they copied the homework of Unreal. All world building after the first has been shit and people only watched the first because of 3d which was a massive flex at the time.
Tap for spoiler
ontributed by Rúben Alvim (1) on 18.07.2004.
One of director James Cameron’s pet projects after Titanic was an epic sci-fi extravaganza called Avatar, much hyped in Hollywood circles at the time and poised to redefine the notion of a truly alien world on the big screen.
The project fell apart some years ago, but the scriptment (a hybrid between a script and a treatment ) by James Cameron still exists. Interestingly, you can find quite a few similarities between it and Unreal:
Both feature a basic plot premise where, by virtue of circumstances mostly beyond his control, a reluctant hero becomes the saviour of the native race of an alien planet forced to mine their land for ore of utmost importance to an invading race coming from the skies. In both cases the saviour is seen by the natives as someone who also came from the skies and is thus initially met with some alarm or distrust only to be later hailed as a pseudo-messiah.
The native race is called “Na’vi” in Avatar and “Nali” in Unreal. The physical description of the Na’vi by Cameron can be visualised as basically a cross between the Nalis’ tall, lean, slender bodies and the IceSkaarjs’ blueish skin colour patterns, facial features, ponytail-like dreadlocks and caudal appendages.
The Nali in Unreal worship goddess Vandora. The home planet of the Na’vi in Avatar (which the Na’vi worship as a goddess entity) is named Pandora.
In Avatar, one of the most dazzling alien settings described is a huge set of sky mountains, “like floating islands among the clouds”. One of the most memorable vistas in Unreal is Na Pali, thousands of miles up in the cloudy sky amidst a host of floating mountains. The main sky mountain range in Avatar is called “Hallelujah Mountains”. The main Unreal level set in Na Pali is called “Na Pali Haven”. Both include beautiful visual references to waterfalls streaming down the cliffs and dissolving into the clouds below.
The Earth ship in Avatar is called “ISV-Prometheus”. One of the levels in Unreal takes place in the wreck of a Terran ship called “ISV-Kran”. Even more striking, in the expansion pack Return to Na Pali, the crashed ship the player is asked to salvage is called “Prometheus”.
One of the deadly examples of local fauna in Unreal is the Manta, essentially a flying manta-ray. In Avatar, one of the most lethal aerial creatures is the Bansheeray, basically a flying manta-ray. The expansion Return to Na Pali even features a Giant Manta, while in Avatar one of the most formidable predators is a giant Bansheeray, which Cameron dubbed “Great Leonopteryx”.
In the two stories (especially Return to Na Pali, on Unreal’s end), a plot point arises from the fact the precious ore behind the invasion of the planet (“tarydium” in Unreal, “unobtanium” in Avatar) causes problems in the scanners.
Unreal was in development for several years before its release in 1998. The Avatar scriptment was probably finished as early as 1996-97. Bearing all the above in mind the temptation to start wondering about further suspicious parallels may be quite strong, but in spite of these similarities both titles have few else in common and many aspects actually veer off in wildly different directions. Even so, the coinciding factors can make for an interesting minutia comparison.deleted by creator
Hire George RR Martin to finish it.
Those films are weird in that I enjoy them while I’m sitting there, but the moment it finishes I couldn’t name or describe a single one of the characters in it or any details of the plot.
It’s because they messed up a fundamental principle of character design - we can tell real human faces apart because our brains are highly tuned to it, but with cartoons and CGI faces you need to really exaggerate differences to get them to stick in the mind. The Avatar team tried to go for some notion of realism instead, and tripped over their own feet with a lineup who are virtually indistinguishable from each other.
Pantera was Earth all along.
James Cameron needs to hire actual good story writers. He made an incredible world filled with potential, but he cannot write a story to save his life. It’s the most generic shit ever filled with plot holes, humans invading? Drop all that.
If he doesn’t make a movie people want to watch, what makes him think he can write a book people will want to read?
Because it will be written in Papyrus font.
Disney keeps trying with Star Wars, failure after failure…so, why not? Avatar is a much better IP, at this point.











