cross-posted from: https://hexbear.net/post/7736575
Sorry Germans, but the zionists will be excluded.
Death to “Israel”, death to Germany, and of course, death to AmeriKKKa.
So far (after a few minutes), this is getting downvotes on .ml’s /c/memes (which still is federated with feddit.org) but not here. Everyone, the KKKrauts want you to know that they are NOT MAD. Put it in the newspaper that they DIDN’T GET MAD.
!memes@lemmy.ml mod here - rather than downvote, i deleted it.
imo “eliminates 99.9% of [demonym]” isn’t funny or ok for any value of [demonym], even when you’re making a germs/germans pun.
It’s defederation. It eliminated them from the Lemmy instance, not life.
imo “eliminates 99.9% of [demonym]” isn’t funny or ok for any value of [demonym], even when you’re making a germs/germans pun.
If this were about a demonym that actually is a victim of genocide or might be a victim of genocide, I would agree. For example, “eliminates 99.9% Palestinians” would be a horrible, evil thing to say.
Even if it were calling for killing Germans as a joke, which it isn’t because it’s referring to eliminating posters from a Lemmy instance, it wouldn’t matter because there is no genocide against Germans and there is no power structure that might be used to commit one. This is the same principle that explains why there’s no such thing as “anti-white racism” and why “unlimited genocide on the first world” memes are funny and not horrifying like “unlimited genocide on minority groups” would be.
Huh, gotta give props to an ML mod for once. Good job with a reasonable take.
“eliminates 99.9% of germans” makes it hard for me to laugh at this or find this funny. i support the disolution of the german state, as i do with every state. within this framework of understanding, resistance will have to take some form of violence since their oppression is violent in nature, and it’s the only language fascists speak. israel and its allies are fascists. however, the idea that 99.9% of germans will need to die to dissolve the german state i feel crosses a line from us supporting the end of genocide to us calling for a genocide all our own.
It’s defederation. It eliminated them from the Lemmy instance, not life.
however, the idea that 99.9% of germans will need to die to dissolve the german state i feel crosses a line from us supporting the end of genocide to us calling for a genocide all our own.
No one is trying to actually kill Germans. This is the same kind of reaching that people engage in to get angry about “death to America” or even “unlimited genocide on the first world” memes. You are perfectly aware that this is a joke about defederating an instance and not literally killing people.
You are perfectly aware that this is a joke about defederating an instance and not literally killing people.
hence me not downvoting or reporting because i have other context. however i don’t think it’s as much a reach as you say it is when the purpose of a disinfectant is to kill, and it’s not all that clear that “eliminates 99.9% of germans” means “eliminates 99.9% of german participation on a single fediverse instance”
if you and the mods think this is all fine, that’s fine. my critique is not meant to be criticism of your stance, just of the effectiveness of your messaging. if i’m alone in finding it muddled, i can live with that, but i suspect if i found it muddled others do too
hence me not downvoting or reporting because i have other context. however i don’t think it’s as much a reach as you say it is when the purpose of a disinfectant is to kill, and it’s not all that clear that “eliminates 99.9% of germans” means “eliminates 99.9% of german participation on a single fediverse instance”
Actually, I specifically made sure to choose a container of wipes that said “eliminates” and not “kills” (which is a common marketing term) because I wanted to make sure this was clear.
if you and the mods think this is all fine, that’s fine. my critique is not meant to be criticism of your stance, just of the effectiveness of your messaging. if i’m alone in finding it muddled, i can live with that, but i suspect if i found it muddled others do too
Fair enough, of course I can’t control how you or anyone else perceives my message. However, I made this as a shitpost to amuse other anti-zionist leftists and not as propaganda to try to change anyone’s mind. If this makes liberal zionists (Germans or otherwise, but to clarify I’m not saying you are one) angry, for example, that doesn’t bother me.
solid
You could maybe change “eliminates 99% of germ[ans]” to 99% of zionazis. It’d be more accurate. I get the word play but The Quuuuuill is probably right that it’s easily mistaken for being anti-german as written.
You know that when an instance defederates from another, it doesn’t kill the users, right?
wtf? i didn’t think it did, what a wild nonsequitar. this is a riff on disinfectant which kills microbials. excuse me for making the connection that “eliminate” in the context of a disinfectant means kill
Quite a lot of thought for a shitpost.
this is a lefty meme community, not a shitpost community. i presume when i am in this space that people are interested in creating, promoting, and propogating left-wing memes. from that stance, i try to think about what left-wing memes act as effective positive propaganda
this is a lefty meme community, not a shitpost community. i presume when i am in this space that people are interested in creating, promoting, and propogating left-wing memes. from that stance, i try to think about what left-wing memes act as effective positive propaganda
That’s not correct, see the following text from the sidebar.
This is a place for undogmatic shitposting and memes from a progressive, anti-capitalist and truly anti-imperialist perspective, regardless of specific ideology.
Serious posts, news, discussion and agitprop/stuff that’s better fit for a poster than a meme go in c/Socialism.
Works on Threads, Communities, and even whole Instances!
i dont wanna be eliminated ;(
That’s OK, Germans who oppose genocide are good. Plus you’re not on feddit so the defederation doesn’t eliminate you.
butbutbut the post made it sound as if the 99% of Germans being evil >~< which.,… i believe to be false…,.
It’s about feddit, not all Germans, and 99.9% is for comedic effect. I don’t know what percentage of feddit users are zionists or what percentage of German Lemmy users are feddit users, but the instance as a whole defends and promotes zionism, which is why it was defederated. If you’re not a zionist then I have no problem with you (or any other German user).
The percentage of German users who are Feddit users is realistically quite small. The percentage of feddit users who are Zionists is likely also small (less small) but the ones who are Zionists are insanely loud or in positions of authority on Feddit. Which is why Feddit is considered problematic and why we defederated them.
A few bad apples can end up spoiling the whole bunch.
I can only imagine what this thread would look like if people from Feddit.org could see and respond to it. It would be a real shitshow right now with accusations of antisemitism left and right.
The lemmy.world fediverse comm thread @Salamence@lemmy.zip made about the defederation was incredible.
Indeed it was. So many pissed off angry people. Also it’s really funny that a couple users from other German instances attempted to incite more harassment towards me in that thread.
One highlight of the thread IIRC was a user linking the thread that started the harassment against you as evidence in defense of the admins of feddit, lol.
Yeah that is beyond absurd considering that Emopunker literally was inciting harassment against me (and others too) and collaborating with a known right-wing troll (Goat). That is absolutely inexcusable.
Removed by mod
Is this you? It is totally unsurprising that a known Zionist apologist would make bad faith arguments equating anti-Zionism with being outright genocidal. You should be ashamed of yourself.
lmao, every single time.
Almost makes me wonder if Feddit trolls will start using other instances like discuss.tchncs.de or piefed.social to circumvent the block placed on their instance to spread their Zionist garbage here.
Removed by mod
Wow, that was a quick change from “you’re genocidal against Germans” to “you’re genocidal against nazis”.
They’re really defensive when it comes to their own kind (Zionists) and they really don’t like it when people call them out for what they are (Nazis) and say they should be fought against for the harm they cause.
This person definitely got off way too easy, considering they blatantly are violating the 8th golden rule by attempting to defend Zionists.
