Because your argument is rooted in Liberal Zionism.
No, it’s rooted in an understanding of how harmful majority stereotypes are. You completely ignored the bolded sentence which was the one I identified as antisemitic, and instead focused on the first sentence, which I agreed was fine.
80-90% of Jews in modern time are Zionists [FINE]. Zionism is the accurately representative of modern Judaism [ANTISEMITIC].
You could safely reword it to something like “The majority of Jews support Zionism”. That would be accurate.
Otherwise it’s no different from claiming something like “80% of gay men are promiscuous [made up statistic btw]” and then going on to state “Promiscuity is accurately representative of male homosexuality” as though it were true for every gay man.
OP’s black-and-white thinking* leads him in these directions sometimes. He keeps getting mentions on c/meanwhileongrad despite not being a “tankie,” since dialectical materialism is the furthest thing from dichotomous thinking.
*I don’t mean to psychologize; the wiki entry just happens to be categorized as such.
No, it’s rooted in an understanding of how harmful majority stereotypes are. You completely ignored the bolded sentence which was the one I identified as antisemitic, and instead focused on the first sentence, which I agreed was fine.
You could safely reword it to something like “The majority of Jews support Zionism”. That would be accurate.
Otherwise it’s no different from claiming something like “80% of gay men are promiscuous [made up statistic btw]” and then going on to state “Promiscuity is accurately representative of male homosexuality” as though it were true for every gay man.
OP’s black-and-white thinking* leads him in these directions sometimes. He keeps getting mentions on c/meanwhileongrad despite not being a “tankie,” since dialectical materialism is the furthest thing from dichotomous thinking.
*I don’t mean to psychologize; the wiki entry just happens to be categorized as such.
Agreed, and it’s an all too common mistake that I’m sure we have all been guilty of at one time or another.