Welcome to the 25th writing club update! 😊
I hope you’ve all found some nice cozy spots in the shade, to do some creative thinking or writing. Or perhaps some of you have been taking a break, there’s nothing wrong with that either!
The usual info about how this writing club update works:
To anyone stumbling upon this post and wondering about the rules – there really aren’t any! This is a club for mostly the same regulars and semi-regulars, but visitors are encouraged to comment on writing updates or share their own. The main idea is to set a goal for yourself and try to achieve it by the next month’s update. :)
Feel free to comment and tell us how things are going for you, regarding writing, creative works, and everything related!
Oh, another Save The Cat! hater? Fascinating! 😮 (I’m not saying that’s a bad textbook, but it’s just not for me.)
Well, it’s alright. It’s fine for outlining a normal book I think… My only problem with it is that it’s primarily designed to make old fashioned books like they’re Hollywood movies or TV shows.
That made a whole lot of sense when people were still going to the movies and watching TV. That way, your book’s layout (not the story… That’s a different matter) would match what people are used to.
It’s made for short-term consumption: ~6 hours.
When a reader picks up a printed book, that is what they expect: To be entertained for about six hours, then put the book down maybe forever.
When it comes to web novels, that style of outlining makes no sense. The longest-running web novels that are still popular focus on character development for the most part.
How much of Save The Cat! is focused on character development? Like, zero. It’s about tightening your story into a concise, easy to read format that readers have historically enjoyed. It makes a lot of sense for traditional publishing!
You can wave your hands in the air and say that character development is something you’re supposed to fit into the story e.g. just write well when writing say, Dude with a Problem.
You can also say that even if you’re trying to write something big, you should still divide it up into volumes and each volume should follow a traditional publishing plot flow (e.g. 5 act, 3 act, Save The Cat!, Hero’s Journey, etc).
All fine advice, LOL. I believed! It made so much sense! Not only that, but what other advice are we all told to follow?
I believed all of it until I read The Wandering Inn. It’s all bullshit!
80,000 word chapters, colorized text, emoji. It’s fantastic. Reading that was so refreshing and completely made me do a 180 on all that other advice.
I’ve read other extra long web novels and enjoyed them too. Not only that but I really appreciate bullet points and tables! Also, colorized text here and there looks fantastic and can be super immersive.
Even the occasional emoji can be super fun and make the reader smile.
Now, I haven’t fully read the book but I heard a lot about the theories in it. And they make sense if you “write for the modern mainstream market”. I don’t think truly old-fashioned books followed this formula either, the Save The Cat formula from what I’ve heard seems - with this narrow focus - to be a more modern invention.
For example, I write these type of books where people say Save The cat applies, yet I don’t consider it useful because I write for the purpose of art, not for the purpose of sales.
Edit: and I’m not entirely against streamlining. I do it as well, for aspects where I think it fits my work. However, I don’t like writing books that only present the streamlined view as the correct one, I just decided against buying a similar one yesterday for that reason. I think writing books should be broad and open-minded, so that new artists choose the narrow mainstream path consciously rather than because they think that’s the only option.