My cat would probably just jump into the box it came in. Or sit on the receipt.

Dogs are better

Giving my cat new toys is the greatest thing ever. He’ll take it, go play with it for a minute or so, then come give me a head butt kiss before he goes back to playing, just like he’s saying thank you. If I give him something like a pack of toy mice he’ll go “test run” each one individually and I get a kiss between each one.