Apologies if this is long winded, but I’m going to over-share a bit. Basically I want to tell you a bit about my history playing Magic and how I’m feeling about it lately.

I first played Magic over 20 years ago. I was just cooling off a little bit from the wave of Pokemania that swept the nation when my family gifted me the Starter Box 2000, not the one with Thorn Elemental that everyone seems to have nostalgia for, but this one. !

Starter Box 2000

I learned to play at a basic level and collected a few decks, but since I was more interested in playing how I wanted instead of playing well I never really “got” the game.

Fast forward a few years, my family has moved a few times and now we live in a tiny town with a single game store, my brother is off to college and I don’t really have anyone to play with so I haven’t touched the game in a while. I was digging around in the basement and I found a Ravnica Fat Pack!

Ravnica Fat Pack

Parents seemed confused when I brought it up, maybe it was a forgotten present for my brother or me, but it was a current set, I don’t know how it could be that old. Anyway I open it up and suddenly I am neck deep in magic again. I even started attending FNM events at the tiny game store. The events had a pretty good turnout but I always got trounced by people who bothered to actually get good. I still had a good time. But once again my interest waned, I moved on to college and as a poor student I didn’t have money to spare on cards. I did attend a single draft in this time, for original Innistrad, where I only won a single game thanks to a random Moonmist. I remember getting hyped because my brother and I went halfsies on a booster box and we pulled both Liliana of the Veil and a Snapcaster Mage. Even though they aren’t really worth much now I still wish we had kept them instead of trading them in.

Another thing about my brother who I keep bringing up is that he just does not commit to a single game. We played Pokemon together but then he moved on to Magic before teaching me, then Warhammer, he also dabbled in Legend of the Five Rings, the Star Wars CCG, the Dragon Ball Z CCG, YuGiOh, pretty much anything he could get his hands on. I guess I got a little bit of that habit too, but where his interest was playing all these games I sort of enjoyed collecting more.

I’m getting deep in the weeds of my backstory here but I’m feeling self indulgent. Anyways, that was the last time I played Magic until I joined the Navy. I saw a flyer advertising a little standard tournament so I showed up and totally embarrassed myself by including a card that wasn’t even in standard, (it came in the bundle I bought, how was I supposed to know!?) The little event didn’t seem that formal, and I felt my opponent could have been nicer about it, considering we were playing on a little folding table in the corner of the Navy Exchange.

Next thing I know I was on deployment some time in 2018. Every now and then our whole department would get these great shipments of care packages from various groups full of snacks, crossword books, stuff to keep us happy you know. This one particular shipment came with a Blessed vs Cursed duel deck in every single package. It basically lit a fire in every single person who knew how to play, there were way more of us than I expected relative to the size of the boat. Suddenly people are hanging out every break playing and trading Magic, every time we get a resupply there are just mail bags full of more Magic cards people are buying online. I often laugh thinking back on what proportion of our mail calls were just Magic cards (and instant noodles.) My buddy in my shop was quite a bit more knowledgeable about the game and had bought a couple decks for this other format I had never heard of called “Commander.” We played a bit of 1v1 but because I wasn’t super in tune with the game I had this presupposition that any non-standard format was not really worth my time. I didn’t really give it much thought, I just wanted to play my sick Ixalan dinosaur deck.

After we returned home I dropped by a few game stores and bought some cards, but I could never pluck up the courage to play with strangers especially after the last time I tried. But sure enough as the great lockdown is waning my other brother mentions that he has been dropping by the store near his house to play every now and then and he wanted suggestions on a pre-constructed deck he wouldn’t need to put much work into. He has a whole family and works full time so there’s not a lot of time for tinkering with decks. I recommended him this little format called commander, since I heard it had a pretty casual community.

“Well,” I think to myself, “I guess I should throw together a commander deck so we can play together.”

It’s the perfect storm, I’ve got hundreds of barely playable cards from various eras of magic, a beloved legendary creature from Ravnica I always wanted to play but could never justify putting in a deck, and commander content is absolutely EXPLODING on YouTube. So I cobble together my Razia, Boros Archangel deck and bring it to the little store that’s closest to my house and lose spectacularly. But I’m hooked. It turns out it’s everything I ever wanted in magic. People are playing cards just cause they like them and not because they’re the best. I move on to a bigger store that doesn’t smell like hot dogs, the one I still go to now, and I build out my collection, up to nearly 20 commander decks.

We’re up to about a year ago at this point and something is getting to me. I’m going to my LGS every week. Commander is now the undisputed most popular format and there are more people playing magic than ever, but every week I’m sitting down with a pod of people that barely know how to play. It’s still fun enough but there’s definitely something missing.

So fast forward to the Hobbit prerelease. I’m traveling for work so I drop in to a random game store, but something had been set in motion with the previous few sets. I’ve been playing Magic Arena just enough to fill out the mastery pass, and since I occasionally come up short on gems the most reliable way to get them is through drafting. I could barely convert enough gold to gems to make it worth it but I got by. I thought I might like drafting in person but surely the people doing that were all just the folks grinding to practice for real competition right? I thought back on some of the people who had absolutely dominated me in prereleases. What if everyone was that good?

But now we’re getting to the point of this absolute drivel that I do not apologize for. Within limited formats there’s a level of unpredictability that I could not find in constructed 60 card formats, and that I could imagine in Commander but did not frequently present itself in a fun way. It doesn’t have the social trappings that a random commander pod will give you or the financial burden of Standard or Modern. Most surprisingly, there are still total newbies playing limited. I don’t know why but it adds such an unexpected vector to the game. A thing that felt like such a constraint in a four player pod is really gratifying in solo competition.

(TLDR) I don’t think commander is unfun, I’d even go so far as to say that with the right pod it can be some of the most fun Magic you can play. What I am saying is that draft is really fun. You should play it.

Thanks for (hopefully) reading. Feel free to share your memories, how did you get into Magic? How do you feel about Commander?