• Björn ( bjoern_tantau@swg-empire.de ) 
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      26 days ago

      Yeah. Nobody felt comfortable calling them RPGs. Because apart from character stats they were far removed from other contemporary RPGs.

      Saw a YouTube video the other day about what genre we’d put Doom in if we didn’t call it FPS. And they also arrived at RPG because Doom was basically a continuation of first person dungeon crawler games. They just weren’t as deluded as OOP.

      We could call most story driven games nowadays RPGs And that’s simply because that’s the root of many games. A lot of nerds wanted to bring their favourite TTRPG onto the computer and so invented a myriad new ways to do so which has been iterated on ever since.

      Calling every game with RPG elements an RPG is like calling every mammal fish. Technically correct but massively oversimplified.

  • cybermonkey ( cybermonkey@piefed.zip ) 
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    27 days ago

    Sure, everyone knows what an RPG is, but they do also have certain expectations that come with them, such as stats and the like that you don’t typically find in imsims. Ahah! Maybe that’s the difference. Immersive sims are RPGs without the stats.

    Both of these games had stats so they were RPGs. I think Thief is more like immersive sim or can be actually called as such since you don’t need to build your character at all. The game gives you all the tools and you’re on your own. it depends on the player how he wants to play the game, whether going full ghosting without killing or knocking or just backstabbing anyone on sight etc.

  • I used to like the genre term “immersive sim” and was sad that it wasn’t getting much love. Then I heard someone say the phrase better describes games that simulate trucking or menial retail jobs and now I’m OK with looking for new language.