No paywalls, no invites, and even no accounts required. However, you’ll have to read some documentation and set up your system to join a certain overlay P2P network where that mod is hosted. So a link to this mod is likely to look like that: http://[201:26a2:981f:768a:dd52:5129:f038:77a9]/ or http://127.0.0.1:43110/134coUQAQU9EFfGdLiyFcSK854XvDgtkfy/. Would you reject it immediately, or you might give it a try?

Why do I even overthinking like that, you ask? Well...

Aren’t we all in Fediverse seeking self-sovereignty in one way or another, or at least wanting to reduce our dependence on 3rdparty vendors? So do I. I started making mods fairly recently, and the distribution issue popped up immediately. Good thing admins of my instance runs Nextcloud as well! However, I still would like to distribute my mods via a purposefully-built P2P solution (which doesn’t exists yet), or, more realistically, share them via either my own server or a general-purpose P2P network. Or both.

The best way to do any of these involves some additional software on both sending and receiving ends, which means I have to ask my audience (which is barely there yet) to install and run this software, as briefly described above.

And I really don’t have confidence to ask for it. So I would like to gather some opinions beforehand. If even Fediverse users aren’t particularly enthusiastic about this idea, I’ll probably have to stick with more grounded methods. Hope you don’t mind!

Edit: Changed the title to better reflect the main point.

  • I thought about this exact thing as well! Distributing mods using something like i2p would be perfect if you fear illegal DMCAs killing your project, but in return, users must invest their time and bandwith in order to contribute back, and be reachable using a P2P network, else it fails. That puts an unusual burden on them that other software doesnt.

    So even if most of the users dont mind installing this, its a big ask.

  • I would install additional software if and only if it’s a separate install process and the software is well known for the mod scene. An example would be Skyrim’s script extender that some mods needs. If it’s some random software that isn’t even mod related that’s a bunch of red flags.

  • I would really depend on the quality, content, and documentation of the mods. Unless it’s something really worth checking out, the answer is no.

    EDIT: Why not distribute with a torrent and a seedbox if your initial upload speed is a concern?

    • Hinori ( Hinori@scribe.disroot.org ) OP
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      3 days ago

      Point taken!

      And my concern isn’t exactly about an upload speed, but rather about reliability, redundancy, and, most importantly, the whole mod sharing pipeline, including pages with descriptions, screenshots and mod files itself. I’d like it to be fully self-sovereign, without strict dependence on any third-party providers… and free of charge.

      And the reason why I’m asking about some exotic P2P networks instead of well-known BitTorrent, is because they seem to be the least twisted way to have this entire pipeline at once within a single solution. And BitTorrent can only cover a fraction of what I’d like to have. If I use BitTorrent, I still have to share these pages elsewhere.

      Is that makes sense?

      • Torrent sites have description pages with file lists, the ability to add screenshots, and space to put a fairly large amount of information about what it is someone is downloading. You could also include html or text files in the torrent content that has all the information you want to share along with the modfiles. Not sure why you’re so intent on it being P2P though, it feels like no matter what you’re going to suffer a lack of discoverability, but torrents would probably be the best way to minimize that aside from just having a traditional webpage. The overlap of people who install mods and people who use torrents already is probably pretty large.

      • I see. I’m sympathetic to the idea of building a decentralized platform for sharing mods like that, I do think it’d be rather hard to convince users to download an entirely new program unless there were multiple large projects that distributed their stuff the same way you do.

  • I’m much less likely to install a mod if it requires additional software, depending on what that software is.

    Is the software open source/source available? If it’s closed source, is it from some developer with a lot of history/reputation?

    It sounds like you’re trying to sell us on installing a launcher just for mods, or even just some software that ultimately does the same thing that torrenting would do.

    Why not just set up a torrent for your mods instead?

    • Hinori ( Hinori@scribe.disroot.org ) OP
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      3
      ·
      3 days ago

      The software is, of course, open source and relatively well-known. In the most realistic scenario, I’m thinking of either Yggdrasil for the direct connection to my own server (a little less exotic, but availability is still tied to whether my server is online), or ZeroNet for P2P distribution (more exotic, but also much more reliable).

      Torrents might also be an option, however it’s only for files, and I’d also like to have some sort of web page with description, screenshots and so on. Broadly speaking, I’d like to replace NexusMods with a standalone and easily self-hostable solution.

      And the P2P-powered launcher just for mods is just a dream, it’s not there yet!

  • lath ( lath@piefed.social ) 
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    3 days ago

    With the threat of malware being so prevalent, I unfortunately avoid most mods. Any that use dll or 3rd party software are an automatic no for me because they’re simply too risky.

      • Vortex is different. It’s a mod management tool that downloads from specific locations. You can log the individual files and where they came from.

        At least that’s how it was a couple years ago, last time I used it. The trouble with software like that is they can make changes without telling you. Nexus is problematic for a variety of reasons, but at least their software has tended to be safe.

        • Hinori ( Hinori@scribe.disroot.org ) OP
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          1
          ·
          9 hours ago

          Just to be clear: your initial comment(s) was about the hypothetical all-in-one P2P-backed solution rather than a general-purpose P2P network, right?

          So if you can also log the individual files with full control over deployment with this software, and it doesn’t make any changes on its own, would that be enough for you to not treat it as a backdoor?

          • It would not, because P2P introduces a variable: there’s no trust chain between you and the file.

            In a traditional managed download, there’s trust between you, the ISP, and the file source. That’s what you’re getting is what’s advertised. There is always risk of a bad actor, but the risk is more knowable.

            In the case of P2P, it’s much easier for a bad actor to intervene, because there are significantly more entry points for interference.

            Short version: It’s about reducing, but not eliminating, risk. It’s always about reducing, but not eliminating, risk.