So hopefully I’m doing this right! :) (I’m still new to some of this so haven’t figured out things yet! I did ask this via Mastodon also, but wanted to add more detail to my answer!)
Is there a computer game, a moment in a game, a boss fight, or a specific moment that you would love to experience fresh with no prior memory of it?
Mine would have to be The Seat of Sacrifice fight in Final Fantasy XIV, one of if not my most favourite fights in the game to date.
The mechanics work so well and tie into everything that’s been happening, and then that moment where <redacted> (I refuse to spoil it!) shows up to help and then leaves with I think what made me cheer SO MUCH the first time I did the fight.
The music, the song To The Edge has become one of my most played songs in my entire music library (alongside Endwalker - Footfalls and Shadowbringers) as it is quite frankly perfect for the fight. and when they revealed that Soken had been battling cancer and wrote it whilst in hospital…
I adore the fight all together, and cannot help but say the lines in the cut scene bit in the middle every time I do the fight, and will never ever get bored of it.
So what moments in a game would you love to complete again with no prior experience?
A game moment to do again with no memory? Leaving the sewers for the first time in Oblivion. It was the first open world game I had ever played as a kid, and seeing the glare of the sun and realizing that everything I saw was able to be explored? Pure gaming magic.
A whole game to do again? Disco Elysium. There are plenty of ways to go back through the game on another playthrough and do things differently, but there is nothing quite like the first run of that game.
I’m about to do a second playthrough of Disco Elysium, and this time I think I won’t try to redeem the MC… I will try to beat it as an alcoholic brawler with a good heart who can’t stop analyzing people.
But it’s taking all my willpower not to do Inland Empire again 😅
My second playthrough of DE was as a muscular drug addict. Put everything into physical and would take every opportunity I could to do/find drugs and Al Ghul.
Leaving the sewers… and almost immediately getting murdered by a khajiit with a giant hammer.
Same for me; I’d never even heard of Morrowind or played anything like it before. It was my first x360 game and it really made me believe the ‘next gen’ hype.
Still holding off on a second play through of Disco Elysium until memory fades some more. But there are some fantastic “oh fuck” story beats in there that just won’t hit the same the second time.
Portal 2. There are no words can can describe how I love that game.
Oh, portal is such a good suggestion. Both of them are great.
Playing through the first one was in my top 3 most satisfying game experiences. Great game, then suddenly there was a huge twist. Then that ending.
The second one is great but has such a different feel. And I wish they’d gone with “GladOS has actually been activated and bored this whole time” to explain why there was so much extra STUFF. And I didn’t want to hate Wheatley. Etc.
Still, all the Cave Johnson stuff was so great. And great puzzles. And the whole potato thing. And finding out GladOS’ backstory…
Portal 1, as Yahtzee famously said, is perfect. The twist, structure, pacing, music, even how efficient they were with assets and the length of the game. All flawless.
Portal 2 is great and also does a good job for its length but Portal 1 would be my pick.
Came to see portal, left to play portal
Oh man, the first time I played Portal and a couple years later Portal 2, I beat them in a single playthrough each. Stayed up all night then most of the next day. Could not put the games down! Hilarious and beautifully musical! The story was actually pretty compelling especially all the history in 2 💀
Chrono Trigger, the battle with Magus. Most boss battles in any game have a really high beats per minute, or awesome high energy track. The music for this boss fills you with a sense of dread and fear. I remember the first time I played it, I had goose bumps.
Oh yes, Chrono Trigger most certainly. I was so shocked the first time I got to THAT specific Lavos fight in the game. I’d never seen that happen in a game before.
Definitely this for me as well. Glenn was my favorite character, and this fight is the pinnacle of his story.
Return of the Obra Dinn and The Outer Wilds both for sure. Both have common themes of solving an over-arching puzzle by exploration and examination of an environment.
Ok, somehow I’ve missed The Outer Wilds. And I’ve played like nearly everything else people have mentioned. But since this is far and away the most mentioned game here, sounds like I need to play it :)
It’s a game where all of the progression is knowledge based. So once you play through the whole thing once, it’ll never really be the same again. Absolutely loved my time in it. I never thought they’d be able to do that twice, but the DLC effectively hit me all over again. I highly recommend that, too. Play it and tell me what you think once you’re done!
This is my answer too. I would erase this game from my memory every year and replay if I could (outer wilds specifically. Obra dinn is amazing too)
Subnautica, the first time I was attacked by a reaper I jumped out of my chair
This is the one for me. I got frustrated at one point not knowing where to go or how to progress and spoiled the game for myself by following a walkthrough and looking at the wiki. I’ve regretted it ever since.
The Knights of the Old Republic reveal. When I first played it, I was speechless, although I suspected some kind of twist with Revan and Malak.
Outer Wilds!
I don’t remember the level name(I think it was Ash something or something Ashes?) But the part in Control where you go through the confusing rooms with the headphones on is probably one of my favorite levels in any game I’ve ever played but it definitely lost some of its appeal on a second play through. The worst boss I’ve every played against has to be that stupid barrel in DKC that just drops two of each enemy you’ve encountered up to that point in the game. WHO THOUGH THAT WAS A GOOD BOSS IDEA?
I came here to say this as well. When the song by the (in universe) band Old Gods of Asgard starts playing it is on. I remember saying “That was awesome” the same time as the character did.
Bioshock Infinite, when Elizabeth realises what’s happening and slowly shows it to you.
Original one too. Would love to walk into Andrew Ryan’s office for the first time again.
oh yes both of those moments…amazing.
Would you kindly start another playthrough.
For me it would be completing final fantasy 7 all over again.
I ended up moving right after making it to Genova at the end of the third disc and lost my discs.
Years later my cousin had the third disc and a PlayStation but no memory card, and I found my memory card with my save game on it and was able to beat final fantasy 7 for the first time.
It was beautiful and glorious and wouldn’t hurt my feelings too much if I could live that over again
WoW, WotLK.
The scope of the world as you leave the starter area, discovering the world through quest lines, meeting people organically and playing with them for a while. I still love it, but the discovery was great.
Outer Wilds - I’d love to experience that fresh again.
Also Myst and Riven.
I loved the time-travel level in Titan Fall 2. I don’t play a lot of games so it definitely felt very unique.
Most of the boss fights in MGS3, but I liked The End most of all
Came here for The End. What a badass, creative, memorable boss battle. Close second was the ladder
Mass Effect 2’s final mission. Getting to use all the companions collected throughout the story, sending them off on tasks they may not survive and all within a brilliant atmosphere.
This was my first thought, too. That game is so incredible, and the suicide mission is such a wonderful way to bring it all together.