I used linux in the past, both privately and work-related, but the last time was over 10 years ago, so I’m a bit out of touch. I am in need of a new PC, but it’ll be a good year before I have the funds, so for now I am making due with an i5 7500 and a gtx 1660. I do have 32 GB so there’s that. I finally feel confident enough to make the permanent switch to linux from windows as all of the programs I use are either available on linux or have a good/better equivalent. The only thing I fear will hold me back is games. I know Steam has Proton now which will run most games, but how does it compare? The games I play most are Skyrim (heavily modded) , RDR2, Witcher 3, Transport fever, Civilization, Crusader kings 3 and Cities Skylines (uninstalled atm waiting for 2). I’m on the fence to either wait until I can afford a new PC and dual boot or make the switch now and deal with a few gaming problems. Thing is, what kind of problems may I expect? Anyone able and knowledgeable to give me some advice?
EDIT: Wow, those are a lot of replies; thank you everyone! You really helped me. I will make the switch sooner rather than later.
- simple ( @simple@lemm.ee ) 35•1 year ago
Check out https://www.protondb.com, to see which games work well on Linux. Games that are platinum should work out of the box, ones that are Gold might need some tinkering. Most games work great, but a lot of multiplayer games aren’t supported.
In general gaming on Linux has been a pretty smooth experience lately. Games on Steam usually just work, but IMO running games outside of Steam is pretty hit or miss. They sometimes need following a guide or trying to fix an obscure issue that only like 2 other people have.
The thing about Linux is that you might have some issues outside of gaming. Things you might not expect like Discord not being able to screenshare audio or that one program you need not working on your distro properly. Also you should know games on an NTFS drive don’t work well on Linux, so you can’t expect your drive full of Windows games to just work if you have them on a 2nd drive. In general I still think you need some patience if you’re going to settle on a Linux desktop, it’s not entirely a bug free experience yet.
- JetpackJackson ( @JetpackJackson@feddit.de ) 7•1 year ago
I’m not the OP, but drat, I didn’t know that bit about the NTFS drive not working nice… that was gonna be my plan for my games so I wouldn’t have to re-download hundreds of gigabytes of games (Battlefield 1, Borderlands, TF2, Genshin, etc…)
- simple ( @simple@lemm.ee ) 6•1 year ago
Yeah it’s a real pain point. I copied my games to an external drive, reformatted the drive, then put them back and everything worked smoothly then. On the bright side if you can’t do this, Steam makes moving games to your Linux drive pretty easy.
- JetpackJackson ( @JetpackJackson@feddit.de ) 1•1 year ago
I’m gonna have to try this when I switch then, thanks!
- fmstrat ( @fmstrat@lemmy.nowsci.com ) English1•1 year ago
What distro?
- simple ( @simple@lemm.ee ) 2•1 year ago
I’m on Nobara currently, but the NTFS thing is an issue with Linux in general.
- coehl ( @Coehl@programming.dev ) English2•1 year ago
I just copied my library to a properly formatted drive. No duplicate downloads were needed.
- JetpackJackson ( @JetpackJackson@feddit.de ) 1•1 year ago
Oh ok, cool!
- VerbTheNoun95 ( @VerbTheNoun95@sopuli.xyz ) English1•1 year ago
NTFS will work, I used it for a few years without even realizing. I eventually switched to EXT4 for my games drive from an old Windows install when I realized ntfs-3g was using a decent amount of CPU and had a small impact on performance.
- Gork ( @Gork@lemm.ee ) 2•1 year ago
Does your EXT4 games drive play nice when trying to run the games in Windows?
I’d like to dual boot but the NTFS / EXT compatibility issue remains a concern for me since I would rather not have to redownload everything only to have it not work on one of the OSes.
- VerbTheNoun95 ( @VerbTheNoun95@sopuli.xyz ) English1•1 year ago
I don’t boot into Windows often enough so I just reformatted the drive to ext4. When I did use both though NTFS was perfectly usable for both.
- JetpackJackson ( @JetpackJackson@feddit.de ) 2•1 year ago
Oh ok, that’s interesting that there would be a performance impact! But that’s cool that it does work. I’m honestly more worried now about getting Nvidia to work since that’s what my pc has since I’m using sway, but I guess I’ll worry about that when the time comes. Thanks!
- nottheengineer ( @nottheengineer@feddit.de ) 1•1 year ago
I run this setup right now and it works very well. The key is to disable fast boot in Windows (preferrably before even installing Linux), otherwise it won’t shut down all the way and leave the drive in a dirty state. The ntfs-3g driver will still read and write to it, but games won’t work.
- JetpackJackson ( @JetpackJackson@feddit.de ) 1•1 year ago
Does disabling fast boot make it so when you tell the computer to shutdown it actually shuts down? I found out that shutdown doesn’t really shutdown after checking Task Manager and seeing the uptime
- nottheengineer ( @nottheengineer@feddit.de ) 2•1 year ago
Yes, that’s what it does.
- JetpackJackson ( @JetpackJackson@feddit.de ) 1•1 year ago
Oh nice, that’s always irritated me so much. I’m gonna work on disabling that then, thanks!
- noddy ( @noddy@beehaw.org ) 1•1 year ago
A bit of a tangent to the discussion but that issue with screensharing audio could perhaps be worked around, by piping the system output to the browser mic input, given that the mic still works when screensharing. Easy with pipewire and an audio I/O graph tool like helvum.
- sleepyTonia ( @sleepyTonia@programming.dev ) 2•1 year ago
I did that for a while and it does kinda work if you bring your mic threshold way down, but there is a modded client called “discord-screen-audio” which tricks Discord into almost working properly. The one limitation being that you can only stream your main monitor and not another one, or a specific app. But the audio does work!
- Tibert ( @Tibert@compuverse.uk ) 1•1 year ago
Outside of steam, there are community scripts with Lutris and other alternatives.
But sometimes they don’t work well.
There are also ways to play epic games and gog games easily through the Heroic games Launcher and Wine-GE.
(wine and winetricks and 2 other wine components need to be installed).
- s20 ( @s20@lemmy.ml ) 27•1 year ago
It depends. Do you play stuff with kernel level anticheat? If no, then the current state of Linux gaming is, by and large as good as, and occasionally better than, Windows - even on games that don’t run natively.
Proton is astounding, and the state of Wine is amazing compared to 10 years ago (and it wasn’t bad then). Get Bottles or Play on Linux going, plus Steam, and there’s very little you can’t do…
Except kernel level anticheat.
(To be 100% transparent, there are other issues. I have a couple games I can’t get to run reliability, but they’re all obscure edge cases. But like 90% of stuff without anticheat just works at this point.)
Edit: proofreading
- Holzkohlen ( @Holzkohlen@feddit.de ) 2•1 year ago
To be fair I could not even get Valorant running on Windows. Anti cheat like that is complete and utter bs and will make me never play any game with it. Just like I don’t buy a game until they remove Denuvo.
- s20 ( @s20@lemmy.ml ) 1•1 year ago
I wouldn’t buy a game that uses Denuvo even if I was running Windows. That stuff’s basically malware.
- Dandroid ( @dandroid@dandroid.app ) 1•1 year ago
I haven’t used proton recently because I replaced my Linux laptop with a Windows one (changed jobs, didn’t need it anymore). But when I did play games with Proton a lot, around 2020, I sometimes had issues with cutscenes not showing at all. Just black screens for cutscenes on some games. Did that get fixed?
- MrPasty ( @Sebbe@lemmy.sebbem.se ) 2•1 year ago
This can usually be fixed by using GE-Proton.
- Kaped ( @Kaped@lemmy.ml ) 1•1 year ago
edit proofreading
ok removed
- dino ( @dino@discuss.tchncs.de ) English15•1 year ago
If a game doesn’t work on linux, I don’t buy/play it until it does. End of story. There is plenty of choice and time is limited, so having an extra filter is just helpful.
- Father_Redbeard ( @Father_Redbeard@lemmy.ml ) 15•1 year ago
The only experience I have is with Steam Deck and it’s fantastic! I love it so much that I’ve decided to build my next PC as a Linux only box. I am a refugee from /r/patientgamers though. I don’t play the new hotness unless it’s first party Nintendo stuff.
I’m also so fed up with Microsoft’s anti-consumer practices and disastrous updates, so it makes it an easier decision.
- lemmyvore ( @lemmyvore@feddit.nl ) English13•1 year ago
protondb.com will tell you how well each game works. There’s also an icon on Steam, if it says it’s certified for the Steam Deck that’s also good.
I’ve installed Manjaro in 2020 during covid specifically for gaming and never looked back since.
We’re living in the golden age of Linux gaming right now, get yourself a piece of it.
- czak ( @czak@lemmy.ml ) 12•1 year ago
For me it reached a point where I now expect a new game I’m trying to just work. This was a monumental shift when I first realized that a few months ago.
Your best bet is Steam/Proton, since Valve stands behind it and development on all the Proton components (Wine, DXVK, VKD3D, Gamescope, …) is very active.
If you get games outside of Steam (I often prefer GoG if that’s an option, plus I have some itch.io bundles purchased a while ago), some tinkering may be necessary. For those, I like to go “vanilla” with Wine(-GE-custom usually), plus DXVK or VKD3D on top. There’s also Lutris to help with these scenarios. Works great too.
Another topic is native Linux games. There are some gems which work beautifully. I recently finished native Celeste from itch.io and it was flawless. Another great Linux port is Bastion. But some older titles may have compatibility issues - missing or incompatible libraries, broken gamepad support or stuff like that. For those, the Windows version via Proton may actually work better than the native version. Luckily, we can now pick either one.
- Corroded ( @CorrodedCranium@lemmy.dbzer0.com ) 11•1 year ago
Have you heard of ProtonDB? It rates the current state of games and recommended fixes.
Gaming on Linux has improved a lot over the years. It’s typically only multiplayer games with Easy Anti-Cheat (EAC) that you’ll run into major issues with. Mod managers frequently require a fair amount of extra work and reading but I think a lot of Bethesda games have easy work arounds and documentation.
Thanks, I didn’t know about ProtonDB. I never play multiplayer so that won’t be a problem.
- loops ( @loops@lemmy.ml ) English7•1 year ago
If you never play multiplayer, you’re probably fine. Though the only issue with that is triple A games not letting Anti-Cheats work on Linux for whatever reason.
Other then that, you’ll only run into issues when modding Skyrim for the most part. Here’s a github page with a step-by-step guide on how to do it; although, far as I can tell it’s four years old and might be obsolete.
There’s also this post in the Steam Community forums which is two years old at the earliest.
- jaykstah ( @jaykstah@waveform.social ) English2•1 year ago
For Skyrim I’ve had pretty good luck with just adding Vortex mod manager as a non steam game, running it with Proton and using mods that way
- Commiunism ( @Commiunism@lemmy.wtf ) 1•1 year ago
Just to add to your comment, steamtinkerlaunch is a compatibility tool that allows you to install any mod manager through a GUI. Pretty handy.
- Corroded ( @CorrodedCranium@lemmy.dbzer0.com ) 3•1 year ago
One other website I’d check out if you are getting into any obscure/older games that might not have a lot of comments on ProtonDB is the PCGamingWiki. Lots of fixes are listed there
> Mod managers frequently require a fair amount of extra work and reading
That’s one complaint I *do* have sense switching to linux, I wish that there was a linux version of vortex (or MO2 or what have you) so that modding can be made relatively simple for more than just a few games that have easy workarounds
- Corroded ( @CorrodedCranium@lemmy.dbzer0.com ) 2•1 year ago
I could be wrong but I think there are Lutris install scripts that help with that
- Kaped ( @Kaped@lemmy.ml ) 11•1 year ago
Its really fucking good. Open and play nowdays
- 👁️👄👁️ ( @mojo@lemm.ee ) English10•1 year ago
The whole reason I kept Windows around was for Genshin Impact. At compete random, the game silently added proton compatibility with their anti cheat, so now I never have to boot into Windows anymore. I was never expecting it to actually happen lol.
- Lettuce eat lettuce ( @Lettuceeatlettuce@lemmy.ml ) 6•1 year ago
Wait, when did that happen?? That’s great! I always was playing it with the sneaky secret way that shall not be named lol.
So that’s not necessary anymore?
- 👁️👄👁️ ( @mojo@lemm.ee ) English3•1 year ago
Yup, I just run the exe thru Lutris as is. No modifications. Happened randomly like 5 months ago or something.
- Lettuce eat lettuce ( @Lettuceeatlettuce@lemmy.ml ) 2•1 year ago
Dang, awesome!
- hellishharlot ( @hellishharlot@programming.dev ) 2•1 year ago
More players = increased revenue potential
- 👁️👄👁️ ( @mojo@lemm.ee ) English2•1 year ago
If only more companies realized this…
- hellishharlot ( @hellishharlot@programming.dev ) 1•1 year ago
They do. It’s a matter of assumed additional dev time and library lock in. Actively fighting proton efforts is stupid tho
- Holzkohlen ( @Holzkohlen@feddit.de ) 8•1 year ago
I’m playing Baldur’s Gate 3 since day 1. That’s really all I need and a lot more than I expected just a few years ago. It’s only gonna get better from here.
- sounddrill ( @sounddrill@lemmy.antemeridiem.xyz ) English8•1 year ago
“Making do”
i5 7500
1660
32 GB RAM!
me with my plebian i5 6500, 16gb back alley ram and igpu 😭
i5 2500. And this fucker refuses to die.
- grimaferve ( @grimaferve@kglitch.social ) 6•1 year ago
Sorry if there’s a lot of technical terms.
My anecdotal experience is that Skyrim modding under Linux worked surprisingly well. Despite that I think I would still say “YMMV”. I have it running under Lutris-GE-Proton8-13.
I used the GOG release because having local access to the installer is a major win. Note that even if you don’t install the AE upgrade it’s the same version number, 1.6.659 so bear this in mind when installing SKSE64 and mods. I think there’s a specific release of SKSE64 for GOG. Many mods label that version as AE only, which isn’t true of the GOG release.
I chose to install in Lutris because of how easy it is to manipulate prefixes. I had issues with the automated scripts, which I expected. So I did it myself.
I downloaded Skyrim from GOG and installed Skyrim using the “Install a Windows game from media” option, then run once from the launcher to ensure everything was initialised before modding.
Inside this prefix I installed MO2 using “Run EXE inside WINE prefix”.
I chose that mod manager because I used it on Windows and it worked just fine. I don’t know a lot about Vortex. There’s a DLL to add support for Epic and GOG installs of Skyrim. I duplicated the Skyrim SE runner and changed the target to ModOrganizer dot exe. There’s a UI bug that makes reordering mods act weird, just click another mod entry if it gets stuck.
The Nemesis issue I had, which appears to be a Linux/WINE problem - the solution given (Extract it to the Data folder then run the executable from MO2 with VFS) worked for me.
TBH my modlist is pretty tame compared to most that I’ve come across so I didn’t expect many problems. LOOT worked as expected so I just let LOOT handle my load order.
There’s probably more to it but this is what I remember. Happy modding!
- 30021190 ( @30021190@lemmy.cloud.aboutcher.co.uk ) 1•1 year ago
So my current experience is Lutris-GE-Proton8 doesn’t work properly with all GOG installers and it just gives black flickering… However I used to have great success with Lutris.
- Gush ( @Gush@lemmy.ml ) 5•1 year ago
If your pc doesn’t support vulkan you’re fucked, unless you use steam
- CoderKat ( @CoderKat@lemm.ee ) English1•1 year ago
What does supporting Vulkan entail?
- EddyBot ( @EddyBot@feddit.de ) 2•1 year ago
Steam Proton (which does the heavy lifting of running windows games on linux) includes DXVK/D9VK/VK3D3 which translates Windows DirectX games (don’t work on Linux) into Vulkan (which works on Linux)
not having Vulkan will result in falling back on the way older DirectX -> OpenGL translation which not many actually care about nowadays and hasn’t been opti.ized to run well in years (awful performance)
- monotrox ( @monotrox@discuss.tchncs.de ) 1•1 year ago
Vulkan isnt that new though so a 1660 should be fine, right?
- Gush ( @Gush@lemmy.ml ) 1•1 year ago
I use a 1650ti and it’s not supported
- chayleaf ( @chayleaf@lemmy.ml ) 1•1 year ago
1650ti most certainly does support Vulkan. However there may be problems if you have switchable graphics.
- Gush ( @Gush@lemmy.ml ) 1•1 year ago
Indeed, i have to use optimus manager in X11 in order to let my graphic card process games and other things
- rodbiren ( @rodbiren@midwest.social ) English5•1 year ago
Can be pain free but it can also be painful. Some things straight up won’t work because of anti cheat and unsupportive developers. I’d say give it a try. Gotta bump up the market share so Linux support actually matters in developer business cases.
- gabriele97 ( @gabriele97@lemmy.g97.top ) 4•1 year ago
I’m using Pop OS for gaming and work and it works flawlessly. Looking at the game you listed, I think they will work without problems. Give a look at protondb so you can have an idea. However I would suggest you to try it yourself and see how it goes, gaming on Linux is a very different matter compared to ten years ago!