• Bungobongo ( Bungobongo@lemmynsfw.com ) 
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      30
      ·
      3 years ago

      Its not so indiscriminate. Its just that theyre edgy libertarians and radical centrists. Its less about blanket making fun of everyone including themselves and that theyre smugly declaring “both sides bad” on most things.

      • magnetosphere ( magnetosphere@kbin.social ) 
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        6
        ·
        edit-2
        3 years ago

        The viewer must be able to laugh at themselves, or at least be able to tolerate writers who are deliberately pushing people’s buttons. Sometimes there’s a good point hiding in the bullshit.

        Or, just skip the show entirely. It’s great that their turnaround time is only six days(!), so they can address surprisingly current issues, but the show is past its prime anyway.

      • Cethin ( Cethin@lemmy.zip ) 
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        4
        ·
        3 years ago

        I think the old stuff is for sure, but didn’t they at one point notice how bad they were for thinking that way and change? Idk, I haven’t watched the show in probably 10+ years.

        • Ultimately the South Park moral comes down to change is bad. Let’s keep the status quo.

          And that’s what I find offensive. To be fair, The Simpsons does the same thing, as does Family Guy

          As does most society critical content that makes it to television.

        • vis4valentine ( vis4valentine@lemmy.ml ) OP
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          11
          ·
          3 years ago

          I’m neurodivergent, and I laugh in many instances South Park made fun of neudivergent and mentally disabled people. I’m Latin American, South Park made fun of latin americans so many times. I’m progressive, South Park made fun of progressives so many times. I’m atheist, same thing. I’m bisexual, same thing, I could go on.

          The problem with the Mr Garrison episodes is that, they are so viscerally transphobic, it is very obviously made in such bad faith.

          Of course they are not the worse thing depicted in South Park, but yeah, a show with the objective to be as offensive as possible gotta hit somewhere in a very personal point eventually.

            • Sadly, that’s not enough, just as Jaws did damage to shark conservation and The Silence of the Lambs did damage to Trans acceptance, even though it’s super clear Buffalo Bill is not conventionally trans but his own special kind of crazy.

              Then again, our love for police procedurals and serial killer mysteries does damage to mental health awareness and police brutality awareness. Also judicial overreach. (Lots of false convictions.)

            • Nobel Art ( nobleart9932@lemmy.blahaj.zone ) 
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              9
              ·
              3 years ago

              He’s messed up. And that’s all he is and all he’s supposed to be. At least that’s my take-away from the show.

              This in and of itself is part of the problem: It’s a common terf talking point. Trans people don’t exist they just have a mental health problem.

        • I think those “both sides” shows have to go out of their way to find things to make fun of in certain circumstances. So they feel forced to charicature or misrepresent those groups in order to make any proper humor. On the audience side people who buck the status quo are held under the same scrutiny as people who are rapidly climbing the discrimination pipeline.

          • If you have to go out of your way to find (or invent) a joke, you haven’t found the right angle on it. Satire is qualitatively different to bullying.

            Shows like South Park are at their most funny when the contrivances are kept to a minimum, or are so absurd that they’re obviously farcical. The best satire is when they’re teasing their target *and* their target’s detractors at the same time.

            There are so many other takes they could have made. (I’d give examples, but I’m too prudish to say 'em.)

  • magnetosphere ( magnetosphere@kbin.social ) 
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    39
    ·
    edit-2
    3 years ago

    It bothers me less depending on how old the episode is, and the overall tone of the joke. Older “let’s put this guy in a dress for cheap laughs” type stuff is lame, but not as bad as more recent attempts to make hatred more palatable by disguising it with a thin veneer of “humor”.

        • The Octonaut ( TheOctonaut@mander.xyz ) 
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          7
          ·
          3 years ago

          Can you tell me what’s transphobic about it?

          When I first saw it I would have thought it was trans-supporting, other than the detail that (IIRC) the trans woman was played by a cisgender woman.

          The entire point of it is that the only thing that is stopping Douglas from being genuinely, incredibly happy, becoming a better person and living an actually fulfilling life in the end is his inability to accept a historical detail that had made absolutely no difference to his relationship. And, since Douglas might be the worst person in the world, we see him destroy that because of his own weird machismo values. Just when we think he’s completely changed as a character, his shittiness on this one thing, emblematic of his incredibly toxic masculinity, comes crashing down on him. This is, darkly, funny. We are abruptly reminded that Douglas is an actual monster, to the point of fist-fighting with the person he loves. “Character is briefly happy but previous behaviour and/or shittiness of their character ruins it for themselves” is like at like 30% of Linehan’s sitcom plotlines.

          If there’s something I missed - and it’s been a few years, and thoroughly agree that Linehan’s subsequent behaviour justifies examining his previous work for ulterior motives - I would like to know it. Genuinely.

        • macniel ( DmMacniel@feddit.de ) 
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          1
          ·
          3 years ago

          More telling is the creator (Graham Linehan) who is a vocal TERF.

          well sad to see/hear. But I’m still not convinced that the episode in its entirety is transphobic.

          • It’s the b-plot from what I recall, it’s not the main focus of the episode.

            It was written long before his TERF days and so it’s not exactly hateful, just ignorant and it’s comparable to a lot of other ways comedy treated trans characters from the era - The League Of Gentleman was much, much worse than the IT Crowd imo, and that was a recurring character in every episode.

            It’s rather the issue that while Matt Berry has distanced himself from the episode Linehan actually still defends it as pro-trans.

      • Gnome Kat ( GnomeKat@lemmy.blahaj.zone ) 
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        7
        ·
        3 years ago

        I was thinking this binging The Boys recently. In universe apparently fish can communicate with each other and have feelings and shit, there is a dude who can talk to fish. But they also show a weird amount of casual fish abuse in relation to that character and in a way that sorta plays it for laughs. The Boys is already pretty satirical so I think the writers are doing it on purpose to satirize real life animal mistreatment but even still I’m not sure it’s done that well as its still presented in a lot of scenes as a joke.

        • BigBananaDealer ( BigBananaDealer@lemm.ee ) 
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          4
          ·
          3 years ago

          they do that because in the first episode SPOILER The Deep rapes the new superhero joining the team. and its found out hes done this countless times. so the show shits on him hard the rest of the way

          • Gnome Kat ( GnomeKat@lemmy.blahaj.zone ) 
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            1
            ·
            3 years ago

            The part I am criticizing is all the depictions of animal abuse surrounding the deep, mostly not being committed by him but characters around him. Like the show sorta plays it as a joke or something. Like he deserves to see all these fish that as far as he is concerned are thinking sentient people be abused around him because he is a rapist. And in later season he himself is raped. It’s unclear what we are suppose to take away from his story line, is the animal abuse only he seems to care about suppose to be ok because he is a rapist? Or are we supposed to sympathize with him? the fish? It’s just a bit of a mess.

            I just think that aspect of the show could have been done better… the deep in general is kinda one of the worst characters in the show imo, by s3 his story line barely even intersects the main plot.

        • vis4valentine ( vis4valentine@lemmy.ml ) OP
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          7
          ·
          3 years ago

          Antivaxxers? Trump supporters? Callous billionaires?

          Science deniers and right wingers has never been on the right side of the history, so these you mentioned will be remembered as the idiots they are, and Billionaires will continue to exist but will be remembered but not in the Star Trek name dropping Elon Musk kind of way, but in the way we remember other idiotic and callous billionares from a century ago.

        • Neato ( Neato@kbin.social ) 
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          6
          ·
          3 years ago

          In the case of previous groups, it’s usually persecuted and marginalized groups. So I don’t think that fits.

          I’m already seeing terms like “stupid”, “dumb”, “crazy” and other terms to refer to conditions people didn’t choose, especially mental ones, being used less and frowned upon occasionally. So maybe “crazy/insane” if we actually recognize it wildly as an issue or treat it.

          Online? I’m seeing a lot more hate and memes against furries cropping up that I hope goes away. Not that that’s new, but I think it’s shifting towards them since it’s become unacceptable in most circles to denigrate sexual and gender identities.

          Otherwise I think the question is: Who is society denigrating that is both a marginalized group and not actively/actually harmful?

        • darkregn ( darkregn@beehaw.org ) 
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          4
          ·
          edit-2
          3 years ago

          Think about the words you and other people use and what they actually mean. Are you using a word that refers to a certain group of people who are part of some marginalised group? “Gay” used to be a very common insult, particularly in South Park. What about “lame”, “dumb”, “tard”, etc.

    • Troy ( troyunrau@lemmy.ca ) 
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      3 years ago

      Going to throw this out there: self identification as a member of racial/ethnic/cultural group will become a hot button. Right now the left screams “cultural appropriation!” when this happens. But appropriating another gender is somehow okay. There’s a real mismatch here in logic, and at some point in the future this will flip. Like, currently it’s okay for me to say “I identify as a woman” but not “I identify as a black woman”. How does that even make sense?

      • I think that’s mostly an American thing: they think that their “racial” categories are the same thing as ethnicity, and since race is defined by racists (who believe that it’s an innate inherited trait), it’s constrained by them too.

        “I was born French, but now I consider myself Corsican.” is an uncommon but perfectly normal thing in Europe.

        American racism is just absurd, even by racism standards. That absurdity even influences American anti-racism.

      • Good question. Men and women generally have radically different traditional roles, limitations, stereotypes, and expectations. The same can be said of white people and Black people. So, why is it okay to identify as one but not the other?

        Most questions I see involving identity aren’t asked in good faith, but this is an interesting one. Granted, it’s probably been addressed repeatedly, but I haven’t come across it before.