ares35 ( @ares35@kbin.social ) 135•8 months agoit’s not that he is refusing to hold elections. headline is, of course, misleading.
the country’s constitution literally prohibits elections during martial law, a state the country has been in since the day russia started the war.
WalrusDragonOnABike ( @WalrusDragonOnABike@kbin.social ) 12•8 months agoConstitutions can be changed (Alabama’s 6th constitution was amended 977 times before they made a 7th constitution last year, for example). Headline is definitely inflammatory, but just because you happen to be in the position of dictator doesn’t mean can’t work towards not being one.
flipht ( @flipht@kbin.social ) 40•8 months agoSo they amend their constitution. During a war. To force people into the streets to vote.
How does the government make sure the election is fair? Some people won’t be able to vote due to danger. Some will be attacked. Some areas are occupied, and the occupation lines may change during the election.
If they tried to run an election now, Russia would publish their own results showing that the occupied areas voted for Putin. Trying to run elections is hard enough in normal times, doing so with Russia literally holding a large swath of your country is impossible.
Nougat ( @Nougat@kbin.social ) 18•8 months agoAmending the constitution or holding national elections (among other things) are prohibited during martial law.
WalrusDragonOnABike ( @WalrusDragonOnABike@kbin.social ) 5•8 months agoPass a new constitution then. Could be identical minus those two things.
bitsplease ( @bitsplease@lemmy.ml ) 22•8 months agoWhat exactly is the process for a complete replacement in the constitution in Ukraine? Is it something that can feasibly be accomplished during wartime?
Edit: apparently the process is “you can’t” https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/389-19#Text (Article 19 Section 1)
So basically there is no way for Zelensky to change anything about the situation without just fraglantly breaking the law (or declaring an end to martial law during wartime, which would be beyond stupid). Pretty hard to argue he’s a “dictator” when literally all he’s doing is following the law that was out in place well before he was elected.
Now, if the war ends and he still refuses to hold a election, I’ll be right with you in calling for action, but I fail to see any fault with his current course on this specific issue
WalrusDragonOnABike ( @WalrusDragonOnABike@kbin.social ) 3•8 months agoAn old constitution can’t control a new one. Its literally replacing the old one. Nothing it says is relevant.
bitsplease ( @bitsplease@lemmy.ml ) 12•8 months agoSo, in your opinion - in order for Zelensky to not be a dictator, he has to break all the existing rules of law in order to completely replace the existing constitution? And he should be allowed to do this unilaterally? And this would make him not a dictator? He’s not a fucking monarch dude, he’s the elected head of state - he doesn’t have supreme authority to do whatever the fuck he feels like.
The foundation of democracy is the idea that our elected officials have to abide by the rules of law that are already in place, including (and especially) those laws that concern how other laws are made. Otherwise any elected official could just declare themselves the new supreme ruler and toss out every law that limits their power.
And that’s all putting aside the question of how you would even hold an election in war ravaged Ukraine right now, a significant portion of which is under hostile occupation lol
flipht ( @flipht@kbin.social ) 6•8 months agoAgain, what good would this do if you are in a war torn country that cannot secure its elections?
nicetriangle ( @nicetriangle@kbin.social ) 7•8 months agoPretty sure these people aren’t arguing in good faith
WalrusDragonOnABike ( @WalrusDragonOnABike@kbin.social ) 1•8 months agoI don’t really care. Irrelevant to my point, which has nothing to do with Zelensky or Ukraine.
BraveSirZaphod ( @BraveSirZaphod@kbin.social ) 24•8 months agobut just because you happen to be in the position of dictator doesn’t mean can’t work towards not being one.
I’m pretty sure he’s been doing everything he possibly can do to get out of this state of martial law, so I suppose that’ll be satisfying for you?
Evkob ( @Evkob@lemmy.ca ) 21•8 months agoAnd I bet “Zelensky amends Ukraine’s constitution during wartime” would make similar headlines.
There’s fair criticism to be made of Zelensky, I’m sure. However, not holding an election during wartime, which is backed by the constitution and most Ukrainians, is not one of them.
WalrusDragonOnABike ( @WalrusDragonOnABike@kbin.social ) 1•8 months agoNot really criticizing him. My criticism is the weird constitution worship used as non-argument that simply begs the question.
Nougat ( @Nougat@kbin.social ) 11•8 months agoThe Constitution of Ukraine (Ukrainian: Конституція України, romanized: Konstytutsiia Ukrainy) is the fundamental law of Ukraine. The constitution was adopted and ratified at the 5th session of the Verkhovna Rada, the parliament of Ukraine, on 28 June 1996.[1] The constitution was passed with 315 ayes out of 450 votes possible (300 ayes minimum).[1] All other laws and other normative legal acts of Ukraine must conform to the constitution. The right to amend the constitution through a special legislative procedure is vested exclusively in the parliament. The only body that may interpret the constitution and determine whether legislation conforms to it is the Constitutional Court of Ukraine.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_Ukraine
I’m still looking for the actual constitutional bit that says “no elections during war,” or whatever phraseology has been passed around - Edit: Found it. (Links to original legal texts in this article.)
These regularly scheduled elections were disrupted by the state of martial law declared in 2022, at the start of the full-scale Russian invasion. This can be expected from a country fighting for its very existence, where significant portions of its territory are occupied. Martial law is established as a concept in the Ukrainian Constitution and last updated by the national legislature in 2015, before Zelensky entered politics.
Article 83 of the Ukrainian Constitution states that if the term of the Verkhovna Rada expires under martial law, it shall automatically be extended until a new Rada is seated following the end of martial law. Article 19 of Ukraine’s martial law legislation specifically forbids conducting national elections. Thus, for Ukraine to conduct elections while under martial law would be a violation of legal norms that predate Zelensky and the full-scale Russian invasion.
but assuming that’s true,Zelenskyy has nothing to do with whether or not elections happen. Having elections would be in violation of the constitution.And Zelenskyy has nothing to do with amending the constitution, either; that’s for the legislature to do.Zelenskyy is following the law, as his office requires that he do.Edit: I’m a bit wrong there. Article 93 reads:
The right of legislative initiative in the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine belongs to the President of Ukraine, the People’s Deputies of Ukraine, and the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine.
Draft laws defined by the President of Ukraine as not postponable, are considered out of turn by the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine.
Which means that the President can put forward legislation for the parliament to vote on, even cutting to the front of the line. I bet this includes constitutional amendments.
But Article 19 Section 1 of the Ukrainian martial law legislation says no changes to the consitution and no national elections during martial law.
Kierunkowy74 ( @Kierunkowy74@kbin.social ) 7•8 months agoI’m still looking for the actual constitutional bit that says “no elections during war,”
Article 83 paragraph 4
And article 157 paragraph 2 forbids amending the constitution during martial law or emergency.
Nougat ( @Nougat@kbin.social ) 4•8 months ago83-4 only refers to the parliament. 157-2 says exactly that.
Article 19 Section 1 of Ukraine’s Martial Law legislation reads (translated to English from Ukranian with Google translate):
- In the conditions of martial law, the following are prohibited:
changing the Constitution of Ukraine ;
amendment of the Constitution of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea ;
conducting elections of the President of Ukraine, as well as elections to the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, the Verkhovna Rada of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea and local self-government bodies;
conducting all-Ukrainian and local referenda;
conducting strikes, mass meetings and actions.
krolden ( @krolden@lemmy.ml ) 6•8 months agoSounds like a democracy we should continue supporting right??
Covoid ( @Covoid@lemm.ee ) 34•8 months agoI don’t think this is unreasonable. Citizens in occupied territory won’t be able to vote and elections would just add pressure to a country that’s fighting a major conflict on its own soil.
However I would expect Zelensky to hold free and fair elections as soon as the conflict ends, especially if he wants Ukraine to be part of the EU and eventually NATO
Kbin_space_program ( @Kbin_space_program@kbin.social ) 29•8 months agoNot to mention that Russia would absolutely bomb voting centers.
Hexadecimalkink ( @Hexadecimalkink@lemmy.ml ) 5•8 months agoYou’re confused with the country bombing hospitals right now.
ursakhiin ( @ursakhiin@beehaw.org ) 4•8 months agoAnd then claim Ukraine did it.
Auzy ( @Auzy@beehaw.org ) 34•8 months agoHow do you expect Elections to work? All the soldiers take a few hours off of fighting to put their ballots in?
The rest of the citizens amass themselves in a few concentrated areas?
People who are being bombed or in hiding from russia leave their shelters and are exposed for the day? I’m sure if they wear an official uniform, that Russian soldiers won’t be tempted to copy the uniform, and replace the ballots.
So, who wants to volunteer to hand out the ballot papers? I’m sure Putin would be more than happy to
Track_Shovel ( @Track_Shovel@slrpnk.net ) English15•8 months agoI can see his point. They’re in the middle of a fight for their existence. Why would you hold an election, particularly if he’s doing a good job of it? Yes, I concede that this is a slippery slope for democracy, in that this is the very rationale that dictators use to shore up power. However, the grounds that they make those claims are usually against imagined foes rather than an actual country invading yours.
Day 1 after they kick russia out permanently? Election.
scorpionix ( @scorpionix@feddit.de ) 5•8 months agoWhy would you hold an election, particularly if he’s doing a good job of it?
Well, that’s up for debate and should be decided by the people. As you said: It’s a slippery slope and I’ll add the way to hell is paved with good intentions.
- Omega_Haxors ( @Omega_Haxors@lemmy.ml ) 11•8 months ago
Really disappointing how quickly the west turned on Ukraine so they could go off to fund a genocide. They really are min-maxing for fascism.
EthicalAI ( @EthicalAI@beehaw.org ) 2•8 months agoBased comment
iAmTheTot ( @iAmTheTot@kbin.social ) 8•8 months agoI’d be interested to see the comments if this were Putin.
nicetriangle ( @nicetriangle@kbin.social ) 13•8 months agoFeel free to check back in with us when Russia is the victim of a major invasion
iAmTheTot ( @iAmTheTot@kbin.social ) 4•8 months agoI’m just not sure why being the invaded party is the deciding factor here. Do the people not get a say in who leads their defense, only their offense?
nicetriangle ( @nicetriangle@kbin.social ) 9•8 months agoOk so you’re being intentionally obtuse. Got it 👍
iAmTheTot ( @iAmTheTot@kbin.social ) 6•8 months agoNo, I’m not. Could you please at least engage in the conversation if you’re going to reply?
ivanafterall ( @ivanafterall@kbin.social ) 7•8 months agoRather false equivalency, don’t you think? They’re not comparable in any other way, thus the difference…
iAmTheTot ( @iAmTheTot@kbin.social ) 6•8 months agoThey are both (supposedly) elected officials of a (supposed) democratic state, and they are both at war. If Putin said he wasn’t going to hold elections because it would be irresponsible to do so during a war, I don’t think he’d get the same understanding answers. There’s precedence for countries holding elections while at war, it’s not like it’s some infeasible thing. Just seems weird for everyone to be so quick to say that it’s reasonable to suspend an election.
ivanafterall ( @ivanafterall@kbin.social ) 9•8 months agoBecause they are completely different situations. They are not merely “both at war,” you are comparing the head of an invading country to the head of the country being invaded. And Putin has decades of history of overseeing dishonest elections. It’s borderline gaslighting to feign ignorance of the differences.
iAmTheTot ( @iAmTheTot@kbin.social ) 3•8 months agoRussia is trying to interfere with elections of countries it’s not even at war with. Is Ukraine just never supposed to have an election again because Russia might interfere with it? Is it not up to Ukraine to ensure that their elections are free and fair? Like, I don’t think that any precautions they would take against Russia interfering is gonna stop when the war stops.
e-ratic ( @e-ratic@kbin.social ) 5•8 months agoDoes Russia have a foreign army in their borders? Very strange use of the word precedence there… there are also cases where countries at war have postponed elections, isn’t that precedence too? How is that relevant for Ukraine specifically?
iAmTheTot ( @iAmTheTot@kbin.social ) 2•8 months agoIt’s not relevant for Ukraine specifically, it’s relevant for anyone who would claim that free, fair, and regular elections are a cornerstone of democracy. Someone else said better than I could: shouldn’t the people get a say in who is leading them in this war?
Evkob ( @Evkob@lemmy.ca ) 5•8 months agoI think there’s a pretty massive difference between being invaded and being the country orchestrating the invasion.
PhineaZ ( @PhineaZ@feddit.de ) 6•8 months agoProbably similar, if a large portion of the populace would be unable to vote due to occupation by a foreign (former super-)power.
iAmTheTot ( @iAmTheTot@kbin.social ) 5•8 months agoDo we have a rough idea what percentage of Ukrainians are under Russian control right now?
PhineaZ ( @PhineaZ@feddit.de ) 1•8 months agoI do not, but the Ukraine most certainly has as well as people who know more about the topic than I do.
iAmTheTot ( @iAmTheTot@kbin.social ) 2•8 months agoIt’s just Ukraine btw.
PhineaZ ( @PhineaZ@feddit.de ) 1•8 months agoWell, thank you for your correction then. I hope you have also learned from this conversation.
ivanafterall ( @ivanafterall@kbin.social ) 7•8 months agoGiven Russia’s penchant for messing with elections (and with Ukrainian officials), it seems prudent as a short-term measure.
ChiefSinner ( @ChiefSinner@lemm.ee ) 4•8 months agoTell me, how is Zelinsky not a fascist? He and his government has been persecuting the Ukrainian Orthodox Church for well over a year now, countless Nazi groups in his military wearing pagan Nazi symbols. Heck, Canada recently “honored” a general that was literally in the Nazi army back in WW2 and Zelinski said he’s a “Ukrainian hero”
Dieguito 🦝 ( @DieguiTux8623@feddit.it ) 1•8 months agoA pure and true example of Democracy™ which all European countries should imitate. Elections are a waste of money, and if there is more than one party are a threat to political stability. Let’s abolish all elections altogether./s
This is the best summary I could come up with:
“We all understand that now, in wartime, when there are many challenges, it is utterly irresponsible to engage in topics related to an election in such a frivolous manner,” Zelensky said in his nightly video address to the nation on Monday.
Prior to the war, Ukraine’s presidential elections were scheduled for March 2024, but the country’s constitution mandates that they cannot go ahead until any declaration of martial law is lifted, which is unlikely to happen in the near future.
Zelensky first declared martial law on February 24, 2022, the day Russian President Vladimir Putin launched a full-scale invasion of his country.
Ukrainian National Security and Defense Council Secretary Alexey Danilov has also said that “no elections can be held” under martial law in the country.
Days earlier, Ukrainian Foreign Minister Dmytro Kuleba said during an online appearance at the World Policy Conference in the United Arab Emirates that Zelensky was weighing the pros and cons of a presidential vote in spring 2024.
The Ukrainian leader’s approval rating in Ukraine remains near the record-highs set shortly after Russia’s full-scale invasion of the country began, data from Gallup shows.
The original article contains 423 words, the summary contains 188 words. Saved 56%. I’m a bot and I’m open source!