One day I hope to be as level headed as Cowbee

Read Constructive Criticism to maximize your unity struggle unity conversations.

  • 6 Posts
  • 186 Comments
Joined 8 months ago
cake
Cake day: January 26th, 2026

help-circle


  • In our context here I can’t ask for nuff’n because it’s a recording.

    This is not oral history, this is a recording. You have never experienced oral history within a society that practices it, so it’s hard to imagine.

    And it’s less efficient because it must be learned every generation.

    Same for written word. In fact, written word is so inefficient that one often has to take courses to understand it, every generation, by someone that practices oration (a teacher).

    I never claimed otherwise, oral history is better at capturing and sharing different types of information compared to written language. They both have strengths, and the point I am rejecting is your claim that written word is significantly better, not that written doesn’t have its uses or is worth ignoring.


  • Parts of this are true, but I’d push back against it being a full democratization. Literacy still requires training in a way that is unnatural (compared to spoken word), with distribution of and distruction of books and requiring someone to write it down are still gates. Books can be taken away from someone and also require additional material to create, in comparison to speaking doesn’t require anything but a memory and a voice. You can ask for a summary or of specific aspects of those sharing oral history, along with your other aspects listed, and once you hear it you’d simply remember it, as it’s been found that memory recollection is better in oral communities.