Sounds like we’re generally in agreement. There are always edge cases. One in particular: there is no good alternative to goose down for ultralight winter backpacking gear. So maybe I shouldn’t indulge in winter backpacking. My own personal decision is to go with the most ethically-sourced down I can find, and to care for my gear well enough that it will ultimately outlast me.

Which is just agreeing with your “for the most part,” I guess. I expect you and I could sit down and happily enjoy a vegan meal together.