I don’t think so, at least not usually. If anything, regular dry pet food is closer to a scam, especially cat food - wet food is just a lot better for them.
Regular (especially dry) petfood also uses a lot of meats and plants that a cat would normally never eat in their regular diet. And this meat is usually the cheapest, least desirable scraps from farms, because pet food isn’t usually subject to the same safety and testing regulations as human food.
Meat based on fish can contain contaminants from ocean pollution (like mercury) that accumulates in the food chain and (I speculate) might be a bigger concern for some pets than others, like if they have kidney problems that make it harder to filter out toxins.
Prescription pet food can be used to address a vitamin deficiency, to avoid an ingredient the cat can’t digest, to add more fiber to help with digestion, to avoid an allergen, or so on, just like a human diet.
The vet should tell you why it’s prescribed in a particular case, though, especially if you ask. If they can’t then maybe I’d be doubtful, personally.
Edit: if in doubt, get a 2nd opinion from another vet, like you would with human doctors.
Usually, prescriptions are to prevent abuse, misuse, and interactions for people. How does that translate into needing a veterinary approval for a particular food?
I can’t just go buy the food they recommend, I need a prescription for anyone to sell it to me.
Veterinarians must prescribe certain therapeutic diets because, depending on the disease being addressed, these foods may contain levels of nutrients below what is legally allowed to be sold for a healthy pet without that medical condition.
and
While some are not appropriate for long-term use, as they’re not 100% nutritionally balanced (some low fat or low protein foods fall into this category), all are safe for pets in the short term.
and
veterinarians believe they might be misused by owners, or worse, implemented in lieu of veterinary care. Neither of these things are good for pets.
HOWEVER, I also found:
(Prescription Diet® is a registered trademark of Hills® Pet Nutrition, Inc.®)
and
In the dog food world, the term Prescription Diet® describes an effective marketing agreement between a hundred-million dollar pet food manufacturer and the veterinarian community. This agreement allows for the sale of their foods through licensed veterinarians only. Veterinarians benefit because they can achieve a much higher mark-up on these foods than they would by offering foods widely available without a “prescription.” The pet food manufacturer, in return, gains credibility as a manufacturer of veterinarian-recommended food and uses that as an endorsement, if you will, for the rest of their products.
Add to the data that I’ve heard (from a vet, but that’s not a source you can verify yourself, so take that how you will) Hills is often kind of like a D&D 5e warlock patron for veterinarians, in that they give out a lot of scholarships and grants to people going through vet school, and many vet schools’ only nutrition-based course is taught by people on Hills’s payroll.
I have long experiences with cats that need prescription food - the first cat I adopted as an adult needed it from the day I adopted him, until he passed away ~12 years later.
Now one of our 3 cats has an issue and we’re back to the current version of that food again.
Believe me, I feel your pain. But I don’t for a minute think the vet is doing it to make money. They don’t even make any money on it when we order from Chewy.
Of course they make money on it if you buy it there. But I’ve never experienced a vet requiring me to buy something from them.
My point here is that every vet I’ve used doesn’t care if you buy it from them or somewhere else. One of our cats requires medicine every day, and the vet office put us in contact with the pharmacy so we could get it directly from them. They want what’s best for the animals.
I don’t think so, at least not usually. If anything, regular dry pet food is closer to a scam, especially cat food - wet food is just a lot better for them.
Regular (especially dry) petfood also uses a lot of meats and plants that a cat would normally never eat in their regular diet. And this meat is usually the cheapest, least desirable scraps from farms, because pet food isn’t usually subject to the same safety and testing regulations as human food.
Meat based on fish can contain contaminants from ocean pollution (like mercury) that accumulates in the food chain and (I speculate) might be a bigger concern for some pets than others, like if they have kidney problems that make it harder to filter out toxins.
Prescription pet food can be used to address a vitamin deficiency, to avoid an ingredient the cat can’t digest, to add more fiber to help with digestion, to avoid an allergen, or so on, just like a human diet.
The vet should tell you why it’s prescribed in a particular case, though, especially if you ask. If they can’t then maybe I’d be doubtful, personally.
Edit: if in doubt, get a 2nd opinion from another vet, like you would with human doctors.
Usually, prescriptions are to prevent abuse, misuse, and interactions for people. How does that translate into needing a veterinary approval for a particular food?
I can’t just go buy the food they recommend, I need a prescription for anyone to sell it to me.
A quick google search tells me that:
and
and
HOWEVER, I also found:
and
Add to the data that I’ve heard (from a vet, but that’s not a source you can verify yourself, so take that how you will) Hills is often kind of like a D&D 5e warlock patron for veterinarians, in that they give out a lot of scholarships and grants to people going through vet school, and many vet schools’ only nutrition-based course is taught by people on Hills’s payroll.
Yet another great idea that is spoiled in practice by capitalism.
I have long experiences with cats that need prescription food - the first cat I adopted as an adult needed it from the day I adopted him, until he passed away ~12 years later.
Now one of our 3 cats has an issue and we’re back to the current version of that food again.
Believe me, I feel your pain. But I don’t for a minute think the vet is doing it to make money. They don’t even make any money on it when we order from Chewy.
They make money by making you come in to get a refill. That’s what I experienced anyway.
Of course they make money on it if you buy it there. But I’ve never experienced a vet requiring me to buy something from them.
My point here is that every vet I’ve used doesn’t care if you buy it from them or somewhere else. One of our cats requires medicine every day, and the vet office put us in contact with the pharmacy so we could get it directly from them. They want what’s best for the animals.
Yes, but it costs money to visit the vet. That’s the point I am making, plus my cats don’t like going anywhere so it’s stressful to them.