davel [he/him] ( @davel@lemmy.ml ) English72•6 months agoSome instances know their embrace, extend, extinguish history and some don’t.
Olgratin_Magmatoe ( @Olgratin_Magmatoe@startrek.website ) 34•6 months agoAnd for those that don’t:
https://ploum.net/2023-06-23-how-to-kill-decentralised-networks.html
sovietknuckles[they] ( @sovietknuckles@lemmy.ml ) 5•6 months agoThe important part, from @kev@fostodon.org:
davel [he/him] ( @davel@lemmy.ml ) English3•6 months agoThis conversation will be off the record.
Ahaha, fuck no. If someone did go, please spill that tea.
Corgana ( @Corgana@startrek.website ) 4•6 months agoCan you explain what that means in this context? How does defederating Threads prevent Meta from extinguishing anything?
davel [he/him] ( @davel@lemmy.ml ) English21•6 months ago- Embrace: Join the fediverse with your existing user base that dwarfs the fediverse’s existing user base, and with infinitely more money.
- Extend: Use your size, in terms of users and capital, to steer the direction of the ActivityPub fediverse standard to your advantage and your competitors’ disadvantage. You see everyone else as a competitor because you are a corporation seeking to monopolize the user base for profit.
- Extinguish: See what Google did to XMPP for a concrete example.
DarkThoughts ( @DarkThoughts@kbin.social ) 17•6 months agoOr what Google does right now with Chrome and web standards.
davel [he/him] ( @davel@lemmy.ml ) English20•6 months agoFor those unaware of Google’s latest web browser malarkey: Web Environment Integrity
EFF/Cory Doctorow/Jacob Hoffman-Andrews: Your Computer Should Say What You Tell It To Say
Google is adding code to Chrome that will send tamper-proof information about your operating system and other software, and share it with websites. Google says this will reduce ad fraud. In practice, it reduces your control over your own computer, and is likely to mean that some websites will block access for everyone who’s not using an “approved” operating system and browser. It also raises the barrier to entry for new browsers, something Google employees acknowledged in an unofficial explainer for the new feature, Web Environment Integrity (WEI).
TheFriendlyArtificer ( @TheFriendlyArtificer@beehaw.org ) 3•6 months agoI genuinely want Gopher back.
I want to share information and to communicate. I don’t want every bowel movement tracked and monetizes. I don’t want 30 cross site requests when going to a news site. A single story should not require 10MB of JavaScript libraries.
I have no doubt that most of the authors of the original internet are aghast at what their high-minded creation has itself created.
Corgana ( @Corgana@startrek.website ) 5•6 months agoBut how would defederating prevent any of that?
PoolloverNathan ( @PoolloverNathan@programming.dev ) English7•6 months agoIt would make Threads unable to see content from instances defederating it and vice versa, preventing the Embrace step.
Corgana ( @Corgana@startrek.website ) 3•6 months agoThat’s a common misconception actually, any and all data available via federation is already public and easily scrapable even without running an instance of one’s own. Defederating only hides (in this case) Threads content from users on the instance doing the defederating, but the data is still public. Not to mention copies of it would still be fully available on any extant federated instances.
Gestrid ( @Gestrid@lemmy.ca ) English5•6 months agoBut they would still be unable to embrace (and, by extension, extend and extinguish) because users from Threads would be unable to interact with users from other instances. Basically, they’d be unable to get rid of a potential competitor using the EEE method.
Corgana ( @Corgana@startrek.website ) 1•6 months agoBut how could interoperability lead to extinguishing? That’s the part I don’t understand. By what means could Threads “extinguish” the network of instances that stay federated?
davel [he/him] ( @davel@lemmy.ml ) English5•6 months agoThe same way we prevented any of that up ’till now: by doing our own thing on our own terms.
KubeRoot ( @kuberoot@discuss.tchncs.de ) 4•6 months agoIt prevents that specific strategy that would culminate in extinguishing. The idea being to siphon users away from other platforms, then add features that other platforms won’t or can’t implement, and use that to create an image of their own platform being better, having more features. If they succeed at having a lot of users oblivious to what’s happening, they will use those features, and when they don’t work for people on other platforms, they will blame the other platforms instead of their own, further cultivating the image that other platforms are broken/unreliable. In the end, they leave other platforms unable to compete, forcing users to either have a “broken”/incomplete experience, or migrate to their platforms. (Or leave the fediverse entirely). Or they can simply stop federating at that point, after users have left for their platform, cutting off the rest of the fediverse from content hosted on their platform.
The way defederating prevents a strategy like that is by cutting them off before they can get a foothold - they can’t make users feel left out if they don’t get to influence their experience in the first place.
Nougat ( @Nougat@kbin.social ) 58•6 months agoThe color codes and symbols aren’t at all propagandist.
Gamma ( @GammaGames@beehaw.org ) English11•6 months agoI thought the same, then I saw the quote at the top of the page and realized it wasn’t strictly for information tracking
GBU_28 ( @GBU_28@lemm.ee ) English6•6 months agoHuzzah for data visualization. This effect is happening all around you, in all sorts of content.
Dessalines ( @dessalines@lemmy.ml ) 35•6 months agoNice, props to whoever made that site.
https://veganism.social/@nm should have added in the desc.
MudMan ( @MudMan@kbin.social ) 32•6 months agoHuh. You’d think more instances were blocking, given the amount of buzz.
Being generallky in favor of letting individual users make this call that’s… mildly encouraging. Of course I happen to be in an instance that is blocking, so…
It’s worth noting that this still splits Mastodon pretty much in half. That’s arguably a bigger concern than anything else Meta may be doing. They may not even have to actually federate to break Mastodon, which is a very interesting dynamic.
Gamma ( @GammaGames@beehaw.org ) English20•6 months agoWhat is fedipact?
0xtero ( @0xtero@kbin.social ) 14•6 months agoIt’s a silly hashtag för instances that are in a “pact” to block Threads
sour ( @sour@kbin.social ) 10•6 months agowhy is silly
0xtero ( @0xtero@kbin.social ) 4•6 months agoBecause the people signed the pact did it long time ago, before any details about Threads federation was known. It was a typical fedi kneejerk reaction.
sour ( @sour@kbin.social ) 2•6 months agois facebook
- java ( @java@beehaw.org ) 2•6 months ago
The key detail about Threads is that it’s owned by Meta. That’s the reason to block Threads. It was known back then, so there’s nothing silly about it.
JokeDeity ( @JokeDeity@lemm.ee ) 16•6 months agoNot nearly enough.
Levsgetso ( @Levsgetso@lemmy.zip ) English14•6 months agoThere seems to a mistake saying that Threads is not blocked by lemmy.zip, when we defederated them months ago.
DoucheBagMcSwag ( @DoucheBagMcSwag@lemmy.dbzer0.com ) 14•6 months agoThis is why I love DBZER0
Kierunkowy74 ( @Kierunkowy74@kbin.social ) 12•6 months agoThis is not an exhaustive list. For example, Instagram Threads profiles are available from kbin.social, which is not listed here, though.
moitoi ( @moitoi@lemmy.dbzer0.com ) 9•6 months agoSo, I choose the right instances at the beginning.
Count042 ( @Count042@lemmy.ml ) 5•6 months agoThis is wrong. Rwn.lol blocked threads.net months ago.
Auzy ( @Auzy@beehaw.org ) 4•6 months agoHonestly, all of them should.
I don’t think I’ve ever successfully reported anything on Facebook to get removed, no matter how bigoted or scammy. The reports are always ignored
No doubt threads is moderated as poorly.
If you allow your instance to federate with threads, consider the possibility that it’s completely unmoderated… bots, scammers and bigots.
You’ll be advertising grounding strips to prevent cancer in no time…
Alsephina ( @Alsephina@lemmy.ml ) 3•6 months agoWe gotta pump these numbers up
pwalker ( @pwalker@discuss.tchncs.de ) 2•6 months agoI like how they added the comment from mastodon.art admin 😅