• Tell me the irony isn’t lost on anyone else that this website article about users being frustrated by min maxing profits and inorganic design language is designed exactly like the kind of site that they are talking about.

  •  Liome   ( @Liome@pawb.social ) 
    link
    fedilink
    English
    40
    edit-2
    1 year ago

    Oh, it was annoying me recently, so I turned off JavaScript, and it’s great again.
    I’m very glad, that people finally call those sites on their bullshit, and hopefully reclaim the internet.

    EDIT: removed stray ‘with’

  • I still think it’s crazy that the same guy who created Wikipedia also founded Fandom, and I believe is still involved. Considering what Wikipedia is and its utility, it almost seems like an incompatible ideology to have anything to do with both at the same time. I guess he’s got to make money somehow…

        • Fandom purchasing Gamepedia and moving everything onto Fandom Wikia was so awful. I’m so upset the Dota2 Gamepedia wiki is now on Fandom, and I’m sure many other communities feel that way for their own community run and community led wiki pages.

          Not that I was particularly warm about Gamepedia either, but at the bare minimum I didn’t feel like the page was all ads and no information. Fandom wikis are explicitly set-up to drive as many eyeballs as possible onto advertising and engagement, and are holding actually relevant information for the visitor as a hostage to get those eyeballs. It’s information masquerading as a social media site.

          The Runescape community convincing Jagex to cover the hosting costs and moving all their wiki pages to their own set-up has been such a huge boon for their community. It is super unfortunate that for many communities, the community-led wiki pages are a huge trove of information but the companies/games/groups these communities coalesce around have shown little to no interest in merely just financially supporting the endeavor.

          • I’m certain that Jagex wasn’t necessarily doing that out of the kindness of their hearts. RuneScape community sites have had a history of advertisements that border on malware at worst, are paid phishing attempts at best, and benevolently full of grey market account services and real world trading platforms.

            Best case scenario was them hosting the platform to protect the integrity of their game, and the community.

            Not to distract from the good move that it was, of course.

    •  alyaza [they/she]   ( @alyaza@beehaw.org ) OP
      link
      fedilink
      English
      16
      edit-2
      1 year ago

      Wait a multibillion corporation hosts an official wiki on fandom???

      it’s not official in that way no. “official” in this case is being used to mean “this is the wiki everyone uses, and which is acknowledged to be the Minecraft wiki”―but it has no formal ties with Mojang or Microsoft. some people have suggested they finally make the relation official to get the hell off Fandom, but i’m not sure how much Microsoft cares.

      • The real reasons why the wiki is no longer official (because everyone seems to have their own version of events) is here, but here’s the cliffnotes:

        • Mojang/Microsoft’s legal team contacted them notifying them that the contract they signed with Curse in 2011 is being terminated (probably because Curse was no longer the owners after being bought by Fandom)
        • As a result, all of the official logos/artwork/anything copyrighted by them could not be used legally.
  • For anyone who wants to avoid fandom: https://getindie.wiki/

    Redirects any fandom wiki to their Indie alternative which are in most cases the only ones actually being updated.

    For every wiki where that isn’t possible because they only exist on fandom, it redirects them to alternative frontends, which remove all the fandom crap.

      • I have also used that in the past, but when I did it only redirected fandom to BreezeWiki and not the other independent wiki.

        For example, Indie Wiki Buddy does this, while libredirect didn’t: oldschoolrunescape.fandom.com -> oldschool.runescape.wiki

        And it still doesn’t say it does that. Am I wrong with that? Cause I’d definitely use libredirect if that was the case.

        • for me is this: old School RuneScape Wiki has its own website separate from Fandom. Read Main Page on Old School RuneScape Wiki →

          The Old School RuneScape Wiki was founded on February 14, 2013. In October 2018, the RuneScape Wiki left Fandom (then Wikia), citing their apathy towards the wiki and excessive advertisements, with the Old School RuneScape Wiki following suit.

          This wiki’s core community has wholly migrated away from Fandom. You should go to Old School RuneScape Wiki now!

          • I know that. And Indie Wiki Buddy redirects to the new wiki, while libredirect doesn’t.

            I used ORS as an example. The same goes for most wikis I personally use. Path of exile, Terraria, etc. all have migrated to new wikis and Indie Wiki Buddy redirects all links from the old fandom pages to the new wikis.

  •  rnd   ( @rnd@beehaw.org ) 
    link
    fedilink
    English
    311 year ago

    Not to mentiom that Fandom rejects any attempts by the admins of their wikis to move offsite. If you put up links to the new wiki, they’ll erase them. If you start deleting your contributions, they’ll revert the edits.

    • I was just trying to remember when the old school RuneScape community got off fandom.

      Fandom wouldn’t let them nuke the wiki because they claimed to own the IP that was the crowdsourced information that filled it.

      Fuck fandom, i refuse to use them.

      •  ruk_n_rul   ( @ruk_n_rul@monyet.cc ) 
        link
        fedilink
        English
        14
        edit-2
        1 year ago

        They prevent any large wiki they hosted from closing because those have good SEO. They wanted the traffic for the ad revenue, even if all mods and writers got off the platform and replaced with shitty ones.

        It really is the reddit migration before reddit migration.

        •  Laxaria   ( @Laxaria@beehaw.org ) 
          link
          fedilink
          English
          111 year ago

          As another example, the Path of Exile community moved off onto their own community-run wiki domain, but the Fandom variant (which is woefully out of date) continues to be one of the top results when searching for a PoE wiki page.

          In some regards that’s inevitable, but it clearly shows what Fandom’s priorities are.

        • Backfired on them, the whole OSRS community was intentionally searching for things in google and using the “official” wiki results to bury fandom, then the game devs themselves added a wiki button into the game.

          I don’t care what their rationale was, it’s to claim you own intellectual property that other people wrote for you. If I write a story, and post an excerpt to someone else’s website that doesn’t immediately confer copyright or IP ownership of that to the website owner.

          Even more so when the information that is your IP is copied word for word from another companies IP and iterated on by a third party to qualify for fair use.

    • They’re just now finding out? I guess better late than never.

      as i recall they were basically merged into the platform because their host got bought out by Fandom–it wasn’t strictly voluntary, and there have been a lot of frustrations from day one.

  •  Rentlar   ( @Rentlar@beehaw.org ) 
    link
    fedilink
    English
    211 year ago

    Even slightly older styles like Liquipedia and Wikidot have far superior interfaces to fandom wikis. Every year they seem to get slower and more bloated with additional popups. Like wth is the purpose of the “Are you a kid?” question.

  • Fandom and FextraLife are fucking awful wiki sites. The former just sucks all around, and the latter just pushes their shit Twitch streaming and has a severe lack of info outside of, like, the first two Dark Souls games.

  •  Sev   ( @Sev@feddit.uk ) 
    link
    fedilink
    English
    181 year ago

    Every little weird game i’ve played that has a fandom site, it always seems outdated and wrong. Plus mobile browsing on a phone is painful. I remember the runescape fandom site…ugh lol

  •  Fizz   ( @Fizz@lemmy.nz ) 
    link
    fedilink
    English
    111 year ago

    This already happened with old school runescape. Editors got fed up with it and moved and now old school runescape has a fucking amazing wiki. It covers almost every single aspect of the game in autistic detail.

  •  chris.   ( @nihilx7E3@beehaw.org ) 
    link
    fedilink
    English
    10
    edit-2
    1 year ago

    good fandom sites are the ugliest & most bloated sites i’ve ever seen & used, & the only site that i’ve seen use 25-50% of the CPU (a wiki page with a lot of videos &/or gallery pages will do this every single time) while ublock is actively blocking ads. like, wtf