- cross-posted to:
- technology@lemmy.zip
- technology
- privacy@links.hackliberty.org
- BubbleMonkey ( @BubbleMonkey@slrpnk.net ) 57•3 months ago
I find this wholly unsurprising.
All ai projects should be forced to show the entirety of their training data. I don’t give a flying fuck if they want to call it proprietary, they don’t own most of the data in the first place. Even if they bought it, it doesn’t belong to them, just like we don’t own digital movies we buy.
And if even a single piece of that training data doesn’t have proper licensing for that specific use for that specific model, or they are ever found to have withheld any of the data, the model as a whole should be immediately scrapped, along with everything even tangentially derived from it, and the company should be fined fully double whatever amount of money that model generated or one years revenue for the company as a whole, whichever is more (no I don’t care if this leads to bankruptcy, should have thought about that before you stole data), and like use if for affordable housing programs or public schools or something, whatever.
They can try again with clean data, also subject to review. One time. Second time they do the same shady shit, permanently banned from the entire sector.
But regardless, we need to stop rewarding them for this behavior. And we need the consequences to actually hurt or we can expect it to get worse, not better.
- delirious_owl ( @delirious_owl@discuss.online ) 2•3 months ago
Don’t stop there. All software should be required to be open source, especially anything that is used by the government or enough of the citizens that it impacts national security
- rcbrk ( @rcbrk@lemmy.ml ) English24•3 months ago
“Current AI models cannot forget data they were trained on, even if the data was later removed from the training data set,” Han’s report said.
Bullshit. You delete the entire model and start again.
- Possibly linux ( @possiblylinux127@lemmy.zip ) English1•3 months ago
I now understand Israel motives
- Churbleyimyam ( @Churbleyimyam@lemm.ee ) 8•3 months ago
I just assume now that any content or data that I make available to a company will be exploited by them. So I don’t do it. It’s pretty sad to be honest. I want to keep things special and share with the people I know and love but I can’t do it without also sharing with others at the same time, who cheapen and abuse it. Intimacy, trust and shared experience as a core part of human life is being erased and I don’t think anyone is really even noticing it happen to them.
- NigelFrobisher ( @NigelFrobisher@aussie.zone ) 7•3 months ago
Me can’t believe it.
- delirious_owl ( @delirious_owl@discuss.online ) 5•3 months ago
So if I mark my phone as being owned by a kid, do I get extra legal protection?
I buy sunscreen made for babies for similar reasons.
- The Doctor ( @drwho@beehaw.org ) English3•3 months ago
Don’t bet the farm on it.
- theilleist ( @theilleist@lemmy.ml ) 5•3 months ago
While I personally wouldn’t want AI inserting trains into photos of my kids without my consent, many kids like trains, and they could add some whimsy to an otherwise uninteresting picture.
- xthexder ( @xthexder@l.sw0.com ) 3•3 months ago
I know you’re making a joke, but this doesn’t really feel like the place to do it given the subject being discussed.
- theilleist ( @theilleist@lemmy.ml ) 2•3 months ago
Yeah, robots looking at photos of kids that their parents voluntarily posted on the internet is no laughing matter. Way more serious than, say, violent crime. And nobody makes jokes about that, do they?
- xthexder ( @xthexder@l.sw0.com ) 1•3 months ago
I personally don’t appreciate jokes about violence either, but whatever. I’m not policing the Internet.
- theilleist ( @theilleist@lemmy.ml ) 4•3 months ago
Aw, come on.
“Cartoonist found dead in home. Details are sketchy.”
“Where’s the best place to hide after committing murder? Behind a badge.”
“Did you know today is the anniversary of the Jonestown massacre? I’d tell you a joke about it, but the punch line is too long.”
- xthexder ( @xthexder@l.sw0.com ) 1•3 months ago
We clearly do not share a sense of humor.
- theilleist ( @theilleist@lemmy.ml ) 3•3 months ago
You remind me of God in this classic:
A holocaust survivor dies of old age and goes to heaven. When he gets there, he meets God and tells him a holocaust joke.
God says, “That’s not funny.”
And the man says, “I guess you had to be there.”
- istanbullu ( @istanbullu@lemmy.ml ) 5•3 months ago
This is such a bad headline. There is no “the AI”. There are lots of different people doing unrelated things.
- mranachi ( @mranachi@aussie.zone ) 2•3 months ago
You’re right, it doesn’t at all capture how disturbing the reality is.
Ignored privacy settings; unknown third parties can train AI models on data scrapped from private images and video host on common social media platforms.
- The Doctor ( @drwho@beehaw.org ) English3•3 months ago
I won that bet.