Are you just conditioned to say that when you see the word true? This isn’t a No True Scotsman scenario because the claim isn’t that “all oppressed humans grow past a desire to become the oppressor” at all, it’s saying that people that do are morally good. The post is about someone viewing the world as having oppressors and the oppressed and nothing in between (would rather have a symbol on a tank than a concentration camp prisoner’s uniform). So saying “Growing out of that desire is true humanity.” is describing what the commenter views as good traits for humans.
No True Scotsman fallacy is this,
All X do Y
I know someone who is X who doesn’t do Y
They are not truly X.
It has to do with excluding people from a group. The commenter is clearly not trying to say people with this belief aren’t humans, moreover they wouldn’t have any need to do so because they’re not trying to defend a point they made against someone pointing out some humans do that (because they never said it was a requisite for being a human).
I’ll tell you what true humanity is. True humanity is genocide, slavery, rape, slaughter, and destruction. You can’t say those traits aren’t the true legacy of humanity upon this dying world. True humanity is killing itself in pursuit of worthless stacks of paper, harming countless innocents in the process. True humanity will go extinct from its greed and it won’t be missed. Animal agriculture won’t be missed. Coal mining won’t be missed. Luxury megayachts won’t be missed. Fox News won’t be missed. True humanity is a blight upon this world and I would welcome its destruction if it were not for the innocent animals that will die in its wake.
And if you want true humanity to be anything different, then rise up and depose the leaders of humanity who are embodying true humanity.
Thinking poorly of humanity doesn’t make me a doomer, but believing your species is exceptional in spite of all the abuses your people have committed against the other inhabitants of this planet does make you a bigot. I didn’t want to use personal labels because they make people resistant to change, but if you’re taking us to this point then I have to say that believing in your race’s exceptionalism while they’re committing a holocaust against the animals is incredibly tone deaf and insensitive.
Not to agree with the other commenter leaping right to fallacies… I feel like I know how you meant it, but it’s important to avoid dehumanizing people - yeah even repulsive war criminals and bigots.
Not to police phrasing in the middle of a genocide. It’s just we sometimes have legit bigots or bad actors wading into these threads and trying to muddy the waters.
I didn’t mean to dehumanize, I was talking about growth, both personal and collective, we are not human enough if we allow ourselves to be like this. We can do better.
Oppressed often fantasizes with becoming the oppressor. Growing out of that desire is true humanity.
No true Scotsman fallacy.
Are you just conditioned to say that when you see the word true? This isn’t a No True Scotsman scenario because the claim isn’t that “all oppressed humans grow past a desire to become the oppressor” at all, it’s saying that people that do are morally good. The post is about someone viewing the world as having oppressors and the oppressed and nothing in between (would rather have a symbol on a tank than a concentration camp prisoner’s uniform). So saying “Growing out of that desire is true humanity.” is describing what the commenter views as good traits for humans.
No True Scotsman fallacy is this,
It has to do with excluding people from a group. The commenter is clearly not trying to say people with this belief aren’t humans, moreover they wouldn’t have any need to do so because they’re not trying to defend a point they made against someone pointing out some humans do that (because they never said it was a requisite for being a human).
I’ll tell you what true humanity is. True humanity is genocide, slavery, rape, slaughter, and destruction. You can’t say those traits aren’t the true legacy of humanity upon this dying world. True humanity is killing itself in pursuit of worthless stacks of paper, harming countless innocents in the process. True humanity will go extinct from its greed and it won’t be missed. Animal agriculture won’t be missed. Coal mining won’t be missed. Luxury megayachts won’t be missed. Fox News won’t be missed. True humanity is a blight upon this world and I would welcome its destruction if it were not for the innocent animals that will die in its wake.
And if you want true humanity to be anything different, then rise up and depose the leaders of humanity who are embodying true humanity.
Then tell them, not me.
Okay.
Hey @josefo@leminal.space true humanity is violence and oppression.
Ok doomer
Thinking poorly of humanity doesn’t make me a doomer, but believing your species is exceptional in spite of all the abuses your people have committed against the other inhabitants of this planet does make you a bigot. I didn’t want to use personal labels because they make people resistant to change, but if you’re taking us to this point then I have to say that believing in your race’s exceptionalism while they’re committing a holocaust against the animals is incredibly tone deaf and insensitive.
lol, I just said humanity can do better. I think I found one of those trolls the internet taught me not to feed.
Not to agree with the other commenter leaping right to fallacies… I feel like I know how you meant it, but it’s important to avoid dehumanizing people - yeah even repulsive war criminals and bigots.
Not to police phrasing in the middle of a genocide. It’s just we sometimes have legit bigots or bad actors wading into these threads and trying to muddy the waters.
I didn’t mean to dehumanize, I was talking about growth, both personal and collective, we are not human enough if we allow ourselves to be like this. We can do better.
This is how I understood it, but thank you for clarifying.
The zionist occupation predates the holocaust. And the “star of david” was a symbol that got famous for being a symbol for it.