• tenchiken ( tenchiken@anarchist.nexus ) 
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      42
      ·
      1 year ago

      that’s a great notion, but in the process real roles that ARE needed are empty until someone realizes the mistake, or until people die.

      This sounds like overreaction, but what about for EMS services? 911 operations? Emergency room staffing? Nursing? Hospital IT staff?

      Having open positions, or even just insufficiently filled hours, will cause situations where there are huge ramifications.

      Just because someone isn’t hired, doesn’t mean the role isn’t critical and needed… it means there’s consequences if the need is unfilled. There’s dozens (or more!) of medical professionals needed desperately that aren’t being hired, ultimately due to greed (those driving the AI process here) and this results in worse care.

        • tenchiken ( tenchiken@anarchist.nexus ) 
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          10
          ·
          1 year ago

          Yep, agree with all this.

          It doesn’t detract from the fact that not hiring is still a cause for the situation deteriorating. Some of the businesses are using AI as the vehicle to refuse hiring while yelling about nobody wanting to work.

          ultimately, AI is just another tool in this case for the rich to continue enriching while maximizing profit.

          I hate it.

      • You’re right: critical roles in healthcare, emergency services, hospital IT — they’re not being filled.

        Not because they aren’t needed. Because the system doesn’t reward filling them. It rewards cost-cutting, higher margins, shareholder returns.

        So we automate hiring with AI… …to justify not hiring humans.

        The machine isn’t the problem. It’s the excuse.

        We’re moving from a system that grew rich by exploiting people — with CEOs earning hundreds of times more than their workers — to one that thinks it can grow rich by eliminating workers altogether.

        But if everyone cuts staff… who will buy the goods?

        And when no one has money, who will buy what AI produces?

      • Yeah but the business is still operating, right? No matter that it’s ruining the work quality of those who are left, if things are still working then it means you can cut that position. So much efficiency of the open market!

    • t3rmit3 ( t3rmit3@beehaw.org ) 
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      8
      ·
      1 year ago

      That is a bunch of assumptions right there.

      The reality is that businesses often don’t know when more people are needed, don’t have the correct people making the decisions whether to hire even if needed, can’t get the budgets approved even if the hiring mgmt chain is on board, can’t get approval to offer competitive salaries, etc etc.

      There are a million reasons why companies don’t hire when they need to, or do hire when they don’t.

      Humans aren’t perfectly rational, and can’t create perfectly rational systems.