• I apologize for this being posted about 2 weeks after the bill was signed, was going through my usual methods of checking news and new laws and found this.

    Now terminals will read: “GNU/Linux comes with ABSOLUTELY NO WARRANTY, to the extent permitted by applicable law, and contains code known by the State of California to cause cancer or other reproductive harm.” /j

  • Please update your title to remove the misinformation about the bill, specifically calling it “OS-level ID verification” is not even close. It’s not got anything to do with personally identifying information or any actual verification of age information.

    It’s actually an incredibly privacy conscious method of doing what it is trying to do, which is to allow parents to set up a child’s account with their age information on a device and have that age bracket information passed to websites and applications. That way, it makes it harder for a child to bypass age-restrictions, but without requiring dangerous age verification methods such as ID or face scans.

    • astutemural ( astutemural@midwest.social ) 
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      9
      ·
      1 year ago

      Bullshit. This is not a voluntary thing that parents can choose to do or not: it is an enforced, mandatory requirement that is foisted upon literally all programs, regardless of user choice or whether it makes any sense at all to do so. Oh, and there’s a penalty of TWO HOUSAND FIVE HUNDRED DOLLARS for EACH VIOLATION for EACH CHILD.

      Download a foreign video app on your smart TV that doesn’t comply? Congrats, the pigs will fine a three-child family $7500 for the crime of watching manga.

      You live in the US. You know that this will be unequally applied to the poor and minorities. You know that this will be used as an excuse to search people’s devices at massive scale. You know that companies will simply shrug and use face ID anyway, because they already have to do it for other locales, so why not just reuse the same process? You know that this is a foot in the door for the facists and capitalists. You know all this, so stop running interference for them.

      • The law has no way to go after parents, unless there’s already some law on the books that does so and the penalties defined in this one somehow apply to that.

        The penalties defined in this law are for OS providers not having a way to set age data within an account on a device or for not sending the age signal when requested and for developers ignoring the age signal or not requesting it.

      • It’s better but the only place the word verification, or anything like it, actually appears in the text is in the title and in the introduction. It doesn’t have any verification in it, just passing whatever you tell your device to other systems it interacts with.

        I wish the politicians were honest about what it does. Accepting this makes it seem like we’re ok with verification because that’s what’s in the title, but it’s possible to be both supportive of requiring some type of standard parental control system and be against any sort of age verification.

        Think about how much it must take for parents to set up age controls on every single individual app and service their kids use. Having the ability to set up an account for your child on their phone or laptop and know that appropriate controls for that age range will be automatically applied will make it so many more parents will do so than they do now.

        This is a good thing because we don’t want what they’ve got in the UK, which is requiring this patchwork of age verification from websites and apps to avoid liability. We want it to be the responsibility of parents, so that we as adults can once again browse freely and no longer be asked to input our birthday to “verify” we are old enough to see a list of beers the local brewery has on tap.

  • kadu ( kadu@scribe.disroot.org ) 
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    29
    ·
    1 year ago

    Mandatory os-level

    Cute attempt, but libre software - as always - remains superior and impossible to control. That’s by design. Write any law you want, I can modify whatever line of code implements this stupid check, remove it, and move on.

  • We’ve seen some truly horrific and tragic examples of young people harmed by unregulated tech, and we won’t stand by while companies continue without necessary limits and accountability.

    So it’s individuals that will get the limits and accountability while privacy companies will get off with slaps on the wrist when they inevitably have data breaches. Really tired of this double speak bullshit.

  • krooklochurm ( krooklochurm@lemmy.ca ) 
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    22
    ·
    edit-2
    1 year ago

    While I oppose this with every inch of my being I do look forward to seeing some super tongue in cheek implementations in Linux distros.

    export $AGE

    Linux dev sitting there like: well, my work is done.

  • Interesting, it’s vague, and obviously going to go through legal hurdles. Windows, Google, and Apple will just do it. Ubuntu might, but what about Debian, or any number of server OS’s? Will users need to verify their age logging into a server? What about forks? Forks of forks? OSes developed outside of the US?

    Where this could be an opportunity, and hear me out, is that this could pave the way for privacy-friendly age checks to shut them up about “what about the children”. The bill says that all it needs to check is age - nothing else. If the OSS community can come up with a way to privacy-friendly validate age, then this whole thing could be solved. Websites wouldn’t need to store IDs, they could ask the browser who would check the OS. In fact, that might be the purpose of this bill, to curb all the “Just collect their IDs” with the websites. If the OS had a check stored securely that you’re over 18 and nothing else, then all other age checks could be cut.

    Also interestingly, it reads like they might be angling against Microsoft and Google for collecting private information on minors because “We didn’t know they were minors, how could we?”.

    I don’t like it one bit and it’s going to be completely unenforceable - and OSes like Arch will say “You can’t use this in California”, but if that’s the angle they’re trying to do, it might work.

    • Yeah it’s so good damn vague, you can say a simple checkbox of “I am above the age of majority” would suffice, or a full actual ID check whenever you make an account at Microsoft.

      I think Linux distros will have to either make a check/declaration on their website or just block IP addresses from California.

      I don’t know how far this will go, or if it means anything different by the start of 2026, when make laws here go into effect.

      • Yeah reading through the bill I’m feeling better about it.

        Provide an accessible interface at account setup that requires an account holder to indicate the birth date, age, or both, of the user of that device for the purpose of providing a signal regarding the user’s age bracket to applications available in a covered application store.

        Where an “Account Holder” is:

        (1) “Account holder” means an individual who is at least 18 years of age or a parent or legal guardian of a user who is under 18 years of age in the state. (2) “Account holder” does not include a parent of an emancipated minor or a parent or legal guardian who is not associated with a user’s device.

        The way I read this, this bill actually assumes the person installing it is over 18 and an adult. (Let’s not argue with them on that). It’s simply saying that "You need to provide a way to create child accounts, and your app stores will need to respect that).

        What I do not see is that OS’s must validate IDs or anything.

        provide an accessible interface that allows an account holder to indicate the birth date, age, or both, of the user of that device for the purpose of providing a signal regarding the user’s age bracket to applications available in a covered application store.

        “Mom or dad need to set the age bracket for junior so that apps rated NSFW can’t be downloaded”

        This title does not require the collection of additional personal information from device owners or device users other than that which is necessary to comply with Section 1798.501.

        Honestly, rereading it, this is how I would do age protection if I were to do it. Rereading this multiple times now, this might be the most privacy safe way to validate age, shut up lawmakers who cry “what about teh children!!!” and let us adults move on in peace.

        You buy jr a laptop, it’ll ask on account creation how old they are. That’ll be a flag they can’t modify that will be passed into browsers and app stores. That will prevent children from accessing content they can’t. Adults then continue on. Jr grows up and either buys his own device, or mom and dad swap their account to adult.

        • greybeard ( greybeard@feddit.online ) 
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          2
          ·
          1 year ago

          I’ve always felt like the whole age verification thing was simply a failure of the OS. Yes, kids could potentially setup their own device, but most likely it is being setup by a parent. The parent should be able to create a the admin account, then an account for the child flag as a child account. The browser and any apps could then read that flag and act appropriately.

          It seems like a simple solution that would be rather easy to implement for any multi-user OS. For single user OSs like Android and iOS, they have user accounts to fall back on that can work exactly the same.

          This puts the control in the parents hands, and responsibility too.

          • I like it for that reason too. If you’re so worried about the children, then you can check a box that says this is a minor’s account. If a parent can’t be bothered with that then it’s on them, and should be on them.