To make it clear to those who are misunderstanding: that’s a list of companies that host matrix for you. They do it at a good price.
If you and your friends chip, it’ll be a few bucks a pop per month to have your own private server with voice chat rooms and video chat rooms.
It’s all opensource and contributes to the ecosystem. Best of all, no age verification because the data is yours.
This kind of lack of perspective is why open services always struggle. It seems like it’s the only tool the advocates of it use since they fall into the “I have a hammer to everything that isn’t a nail doesn’t matter” trap.
This post could have been a list of free instances to join. But instead it offers people to learn hosting and sysadmin stuff.
I’m sure there will be a bunch of replies trying to teach me how easy it is… But I am a sysadmin. I’m not your audience, and some people don’t see a difference.
People who use corporate platforms do it because it’s easy. Joining matrix instances is pretty easy. Presenting Matrix like people need to host servers to use it is detrimental.
But instead it offers people to learn hosting and sysadmin stuff.
It does not. The post says paying for a hosted matrix server. That means you pay for somebody to host it. There’s nothing more to it.
The full discord nitro plan costs 10$/month. That can get you a server for your friends and you can communicate with other servers. If everybody chips in, it’s the cost of discord nitro minimum if you’re 5 friends.
I think they’re complaining you don’t list where to host it/managed hosting.
That literally what the link provides
I’m aware, just guessing.
This is also why bluesky picked up over all the other twitter alternatives. The average user doesn’t want to learn all this shit, they just want to use something that works (which in that situation is unfortunate, because Mastodon is right there and works perfectly fine out of the box with their default public instance, but it is what it is I guess).
Realistically I don’t see Matrix picking up as a widespread discord clone. Just the entire idea of Matrix being a protocol and having different clients to choose from is enough to turn a lot of folks away from it. Meanwhile, Stoat is practically building a 1:1 discord clone, and is much easier for the average user to understand.
How do hosts of those instances afford to make them free?
People pay for Discord Nitro?
wait for the free trial, sign up with it using like a gift card that has a few cents on it or an empty paypal account. trial lasts like 2 weeks but you’ll get more than a month as they email you daily “we can’t charge your account, you’ll lose nitro in 3 weeks”
Repeat this every time they offer you a trial, which they will, without verifying that you’ve already had a free trial. I’ve had Nitro for months doing this and have never paid them a dime.
But why?
dumb reasons really. I like having an animated avatar but don’t want to pay for it. It’s stupid I know.
Haha, hey at least you recognize it for what it is. Can’t knock you for that. Eff it, enjoy your animated avatar. Don’t let anyone take that away from you.
Actually, I privately think ill of someone when I see they have Nitro, because I don’t care for the corporation ever since they took My username
Unfortunately, yes.
I pay for Discord Nitro because it’s where the vast majority of the people I have real interactions with online are and I like being able to send my own emojis outside of my own server. I also like having better audio and video quality for my server’s voice chat. Dumb, maybe, but it’s literally less than a club cover fee per month.
Vencord.
deleted by creator
Does it improve video and audio quality?
deleted by creator
I’m on over 40 Discord servers. And yes I had one for my own group which I moved to Matrix. That still means I’m in over 40 Discord servers. Plus I also run Matrix.
I dunno, I recently read it’s not that simple and feasible.
I read somewhere that you’re wrong.
I think I read what I just wrote back to myself.
You’re free to explain why, other than being a contrarian. I read this here, and the linked article too. Make of it what you want.
Paying for managed matrix is not that simple? Why not?
No, I meant using it.
Did you try for yourself?
Never had the need, since I don’t play much online. I used ICQ, IRC a little years ago, but never went far.
Hen how do you know what you read about matrix to be true?
I read an article that seemed reasonable and well written, and detailed the reasons for not suggesting the use of Matrix, you know, like the many other things you can’t try directly in life. Now I’m sorry I offended your favourite team, but every further message of yours in this conversation isn’t going to make me wanna try Matrix any more, so you can stop.
Lol. If simple questions offend you, maybe Matrix is better without you
It’s mostly rust but there’s typescript, js and go too.
Donate, buy merch, become a member, etc…
Cooool. Now just convince everyone else on discord and we’re good.
What’s that, you say? You can’t? You’re still trying to convince people to get off Facebook after 10 years? Huh.
Any providers that have hosted Matrix servers?
That’s the link of the post 🤔 It seems like you’re not the only one mistunderstanding that. Why is that?
Oh I see it now. It looks really close to like an ad that my brain immediately filtered it out, sorry about missing that.
No problem. I wasn’t sure how to frame it. It just bothers me that people are willing to pay for closed source stuff, but as soon as it comes to opensource it must be free and have all the features, otherwise they won’t use it.
I’ve been trying out different alternatives with my friends. Screenshare and audio sharing capabilities across Linux, Windows and Mac is the one feature that Discord does right that no one else seems to. I really like Element (and by extension Matrix), but they really like to stick their head in the sand when it comes to important feature requests. The lack of screenshare with audio is a big thing that helps bring about the unfortunate choice to stick with Discord.
I know it’s a tricky thing to get right, and I have love for the work that open source does; I don’t have quite the level of skill yet to make/contribute an implementation myself. But it’s strange it’s been this long and nobody seems to have gotten this feature working, despite a big want for it.
EDIT: After taking a look at the issues on the element repos, it seems like this is getting worked on! https://github.com/element-hq/element-web/issues/29891 https://github.com/element-hq/element-desktop/pull/2850
But it’s strange it’s been this long and nobody seems to have gotten this feature working, despite a big want for it.
It’s not strange at all that the feature hasn’t been implemented. Not enough people donate, so there isn’t enough funding to implement features. Most people wait around until something is there or pay for closed source stuff. Funding is the major issue. If there were funds, people could spend time to implement such complicated features. Discord had millions in seed funding and has thousands of developer hours sunk into the platform. The developers of element have to juggle element and their jobs.
That is exactly why I’m saying: if you have the money to pay for discord nitro, throw some money Matrix’s way. It’ll benefit us all instead of some money-hungry enshittifiers.












