• Ooops ( Ooops@feddit.org ) 
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    22
    ·
    7 months ago

    Gnome is good for people who like their philosohy and design and opt for less customisation. That’s enough.

    Pretending that Gnome is good because you can customise it with just these few tools (that will totally not break with every upgrade) however is stupid and in line with “look Windows is totally okay after you spend 12 hours with tweaking the install with these 3rd party tools”.

    • KianaTabion ( KianaTabion@lemmy.today ) deleted by creator
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      7 months ago

      that will totally not break with every upgrade

      While I agree that it’s a lot more brittle than it has any right to be, it hasn’t been that bad in my experience. For example, it only took me 1-2 days after its official release to upgrade to Fedora 44 (and with it, GNOME 50). Out of the 5/6 extensions I had installed, only 1 has broken on me. Arguably, that is one too many. But as GNOME offers a very stable and polished experience otherwise, I suppose this is pretty acceptable.

  • anothermember ( anothermember@feddit.uk ) 
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    18
    ·
    7 months ago

    I’m a big fan of GNOME for the opposite reason, I like the default workflow and use it completely vanilla. If you’re going to tweak it you may as well use KDE, but the vanilla GNOME workflow is actually pretty great if you embrace it fully as it is.

      • harmbugler ( harmbugler@piefed.social ) 
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        2
        ·
        7 months ago

        In vanilla GNOME, you can turn on Window List system extension which is like Windows’ task bar and shows your open apps. It also has a system tray, if that’s what you mean. Obviously you can add a lot of other stuff with user extensions.

        I also use GNOME pretty vanilla and like it that way. I add the Tiling Shell extension though, just to snap windows to corners and not just sides. That’s the one thing I’d prefer.

    • turdas ( turdas@suppo.fi ) 
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      18
      ·
      7 months ago

      Funny, for me it’s the exact opposite. The design language of most of the apps is stupid. I’m on a PC. I have a mouse and a widescreen monitor. Why does the app have a single column smartphone app layout where everything is gigantic and the right mouse button is never used for anything?

      • Welcome to the losing side, I guess. At least an ancient egyptian would enjoy the fact that we’ve regressed to using hieroglyphs instead of proper written words in our menu systems.

        “Press the hamburger menu in the upper corner” “the what now?” “Press the three horizontal lines in the upper corner and then look for the cogwheel” compared to “Press “File” in the upper corner and then choose “Settings””.

        If making design and aesthetics easier in multiple languages means regressing to hieroglyphs that change meaning depending on context, then I rather have a menu that grows a bit unseemly when using a language with longer words than English.

        • I can’t use apps with hamburger menus. They’re trash.

          What a lazy fucking design. We used to have menu bars, abd I still feel macos is the only OS that uses them correctly.

          They only exist because websites can’t change the menu bar, and phone apps are lazily implemented.

      • imecth ( imecth@fedia.io ) 
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        7 months ago

        the right mouse button is never used for anything?

        I’m curious, what exactly would you want RMB to do? And the reasons why it’s not used much is twofold, lack of discoverability and touch based device compatibility (which isn’t just phones btw).

            • turdas ( turdas@suppo.fi ) 
              link
              fedilink
              arrow-up
              7
              ·
              7 months ago

              The blockers are in Gnome’s design guidelines, which many Gnome-related apps tend to follow.

              The quintessential app I am thinking of here is Bottles, which has one of the worst UIs I’ve had the displeasure of using in recent memory.

              • imecth ( imecth@fedia.io ) 
                link
                fedilink
                arrow-up
                1
                ·
                7 months ago

                The blockers are in Gnome’s design guidelines

                And yet most gnome apps use context menus… They’re just not a priority given that any functionality in a context menu needs to be duplicated elsewhere so that people can find it. This isn’t just a gnome thing btw, it’s the way UI everywhere is going: Hamburger menus all the way down.

                bottles

                I like it, i use lutris though because i don’t care for the sandboxing.

                • adarza ( adarza@lemmy.ca ) 
                  link
                  fedilink
                  English
                  arrow-up
                  1
                  ·
                  7 months ago

                  firefox did that bit right. the burger menu might be the default–but that menu bar is right there waiting to be called to action or given center stage.

  • BrilliantBadger ( BrilliantBadger@piefed.ca ) 
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    6
    ·
    7 months ago

    Blg fan of fedora atomic Cosmic been my daily for awhile but ran into a show stopper bug (for me) with release 44

    So as wait on that resolve thought I’d try KDE again, and it just felt so busy & cluttered lol

    Back to Silverblue with few tweaks and it feels just like home. Simple, beautiful, elegant & snappy

    Gnome is fantastic indeed, no hurry to leave

    We each have our personal zen, options are good

    • OwOarchist ( OwOarchist@pawb.social ) BannedBanned
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      7 months ago

      thought I’d try KDE again, and it just felt so busy & cluttered lol

      But KDE is highly customizable … every single bit of that ‘clutter’ could easily be turned off and removed if you tried. If you want to, you can make KDE show you an absolutely blank screen with nothing on it at all.

  • adarza ( adarza@lemmy.ca ) 
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    6
    ·
    7 months ago

    alternate title: “gnome is actually good–once you get rid of most the ‘gnome-ness’ with these thirteen extensions”

    and it is… and it also isn’t. once you turn gnome into a kde clone, the kde is gonna run circles around your extension-laden desktop.

  • Until gnome fixed the issue where their logon screen runs as a separate user that can’t verify Thunderbolt devices, I couldn’t use Gnome if I wanted to.

    And Gnome looks very nice, but I don’t think I could develop apps for GTK4, they need to get their asses on finishing it and making it actually work.

    I tried it out. I ran into constant framework side errors and gaps.

  • I like KDE Plasma because it uses the same old Desktop paradigm that we’ve all been used to for decades, which GNOME doesn’t have. I really hate its default desktop. I feel it’s missing too many features.

    What I DO love about GNOME is the limited configurations. (Yeah, I know. Super weird coming from a Linux or KDE user.) I find KDE has WAY too many customizations to a fault. GNOME is more focused. I really enjoyed using GNOME 2 and MATE. It was just perfect.

    With the proper extensions, GNOME can be a great Desktop. The best example I can think of is Zorin OS. They really did a great job of customizing it into a more standard experience.

    But when a desktop environment needs so many extensions to make it (in my opinion) useable, then the environment is a failure. KDE Plasma is ready to go out of the box.

    Again, that’s my opinion. You don’t have to agree with it.

    • jcarax ( jcarax@beehaw.org ) 
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      7 months ago

      I actually like Gnome’s paradigm. But I also used CDE-style desktops for quite a long time, so I’m not really locked to the Windows ways. I would say Gnome is CDE inspired, but with the weird activities fuckery.

      Ultimately, Gnome is just too lacking in customization. No panel, no notification area, window switching behavior… I have to install extensions for basic functionality. Which is fine at first glance, but then I have to be careful with updates when a new version is released, until the extensions update. Then I have to chase new extensions for the ones that are really lagging or cease development. Which happens a lot, because most people seem to get sick of dealing with that shit and stop using Gnome at some point.

      Honestly, if Gnome would let me show the panel when docked and banish it to activities when undocked, I could probably live with all the rest. Also, have they fixed reversal of swipe gestures when you reverse scroll direction? That’s just absurdly bad UX, which is actually out of character. We might disagree with a lot of UX decisions from the Gnome project, but they’re usually refined and precise. The swipe gesture issues are just plain broken, or were, it’s been a couple years since I’ve used it.

      KDE is just too much, and there’s quirky stuff I’m really not fond of. I’m using it now, have been for about 6 months now, which is by far the longest I have going back to trying it occasionally starting back in the late 90’s.

      I’m excited for Cosmic, I used that for a good stretch, and it might be time to give it another try soon. I’m also excited for my old friend XFCE, and some other mid-weight DEs, finally finding their way to Wayland.

  • mmmm ( mmmm@sopuli.xyz ) 
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    7 months ago

    an application with an odd name, designed entirely to easily install and update the Firefox GNOME Theme, which transforms Firefox (or LibreWolf, in my case) into something that much more closely resembles a GNOME/libadwaita application

    When I used to be around in reddit once read a post or a comment from someone who claimed to be a gnome dev calling for a direct port of firefox to wayland to solve all of those gui kit issues once and for all.

    Someone else said such thing was not possible - you can port gui apps’ kits to gui kits, not to desktop rendering engines - but a few days ago I also read something about developing an app directly on wayland and that it would be really difficult.

    At this point I don’t know what to believe but if this can be done it would be awesome. It’s kind of funny that the linux version of firefox, written in gtk, needs extra stuff to look good and integrated even in freaking gnome

    • imecth ( imecth@fedia.io ) 
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      7 months ago

      developing an app directly on wayland and that it would be really difficult.

      yes it would - you’d just end up reimplementing work from projects like SDL and gtk, this is why we invented libraries.

      firefox and gtk

      firefox is gtk3 based, which is substantially different from gtk4, and moreso adwaita. there’s some discussion about porting to gtk4, but for large projects like these shit is slow moving - just look at how long steam is taking to port their client to wayland.

  • blayd ( blayd@piefed.world ) 
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    7 months ago

    For me, GNOME for trackpad/touchscreen and KDE for mouse/keyboard. Just updated to 50 on my FW13 (Fedora), it works well but prolly should’ve waited because I use a few extensions. In time, I want to configure Niri, but uni comes first 🥲