• OwOarchist ( OwOarchist@pawb.social ) BannedBanned
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    31
    ·
    27 days ago

    As much as I might agree with the political stance, I can understand them not wanting one of their members to hijack the performance to make a political statement.

    Nobody is really in the wrong, here.

      • If I was in the 1930s, and being horrified day-in day-out about the genocide that everyone is constantly being reminded about, and I went to the opera to mentally escape, just for one night. A single night where it’s not on my mind and I can go out to try and enjoy myself, and then someone made it about the genocide. I’d be less than thrilled.

        • You went to see an opera about Italians escaping Napolean’s armies as they invade Italy in which the newly appointed chief of police uses his power to kill the lover and family of the woman he chooses to be his bride, only for her to kill him and then herself in order to forget about genocide?

      • hakase ( hakase@lemmy.zip ) 
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        6
        ·
        27 days ago

        Art is supposed to make you feel something. That something can be political, but certainly doesn’t have to be.

        Unless this is one of those “literally everything is political” arguments, in which case the shit I took this morning is political too.

        • Sina ( Sina@beehaw.org ) 
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          6
          ·
          27 days ago

          I think it’s not as black and what as you make it out to be. If people made a habit of doing this during performances then theater would just stop. The argument that given the ongoing horrors of the world it should do just that & people should just protest on the streets instead of sitting in a warm theater all merry & warm could perhaps be legit?

          I just think a theater is a business with employees & they have to eat…

            • atrizzy ( atrizzy@lemmy.ca ) 
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              1
              ·
              25 days ago

              Nobody thinks its during the performance but everybody sees that its using the opera company’s mouthpiece. The company performs to and employs people of various backgrounds and persuasion and has every valid incentive to remain apolitical. It wants to engage the public in love for opera. And nothing else.

              I truly don’t see what is so difficult to grasp here.

              • There are so many comments in here taking issue or acting as if this happened during the performance, including the one I am replying to: " If people made a habit of doing this during performances…" What I have yet to see a single comment suggest is that this performer is a spokesperson for the company.

                Weird how you think something many are doing isn’t happening but something nobody said is being said often.

                I don’t see what is difficult to grasp about responding to the very finite and limited statement I made about what curtain call means without using it as yet another opportunity to soapbox about the ethics of such an act.

                • atrizzy ( atrizzy@lemmy.ca ) 
                  link
                  fedilink
                  English
                  arrow-up
                  1
                  ·
                  25 days ago

                  I mean… if you find it difficult to grasp, Im not sure what I can say.

                  Perhaps imagine you’re in charge of running a live theater company and after the show one of your actors starts waving around an Israeli flag.

        • atrizzy ( atrizzy@lemmy.ca ) 
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          1
          ·
          26 days ago

          The most egregious thing about this post is the grammar.

          I’ve read this many times now and the most charitable translation I can come up with is thst you meant “not every” and “did think.”

          But its truly a baffling sentence in the english language.

  • rekabis ( rekabis@lemmy.ca ) 
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    9
    ·
    26 days ago

    I’m of two minds on this one.

    On the one hand, the genocide needs extensive and copious pushback.

    On the other hand, he is inside of a play, as a performer, doing contracted work. Where in his contract does it give him this leeway?

    If this happened outside of the performance, then fine. But inside of it? Yeah, I’ve got mixed feelings on that one. It just seems… immature? Not sure that’s the right word, but it’s the closest one I have so far.

    • atrizzy ( atrizzy@lemmy.ca ) 
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      25 days ago

      There’s no gray area here.

      He’s opportunistically hijacking the platform that is the opera company’s viewership.

      He, alone, had no right to this platform and the company is well within their rights to remove him.

      As a thought exercise, (and I can scarcely believe this needs to be said) imagine he came out waving an Israeli flag.

      If that last sentence got any of this crowd irritated, we might admit what this instance did for the operators of the opera company.

      • Bubbaonthebeach ( Bubbaonthebeach@lemmy.ca ) 
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        25 days ago

        My first thought is What if it was a flag representing some group I disagreed with? How would I feel then. If your support changes based on which flag then your support isn’t valid. Now if he had gone out on the street right after the performance and waved his flag as viewers were leaving the property, I’d say he every right and MGMT could fuck off. But on the stage at the end of the performance, it wasn’t his right to do so.

  • Cethin ( Cethin@lemmy.zip ) 
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    5
    ·
    26 days ago

    Ok, I’m probably going to be downvoted for this, but this is the expected outcome. They knew this was going to happen. Is it the good outcome? Obviously not. It is expected though. Orchestras, and I assume operas too, are very strict. You have to be in uniform, and you can’t have anything that stands out. Even things like water bottles can’t stand out, if they’re even allowed those. You aren’t allowed to do anything like this, regardless of if it’s political or not. If it was just a sign that said their name or something the result would likely be the same.

    Now, the opera should make a statement saying they support the stance. That would be good. However, members aren’t allowed to do things like this. They agree to that when they join. This is more like a web developer putting a Palestinian flag on a website for a corporation they’re working for than a rockstar being removed because venue owners complained. Sure, both people are making a good statement, but one of them is doing something that isn’t allowed, and the other is just facing backlash by Zionists.

    • Orchestra musicians are a different breed for sure. But the opera are still actors and not that strict.

      As others have said, there’s no platform or venue that is closed off to protest

      • Cethin ( Cethin@lemmy.zip ) 
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        26 days ago

        Sure, yeah, protest, but this is the expected result is the point. Protest doesn’t mean there are no consequences. That’s my point. This was still a good thing the perform did. It’d be great if there weren’t consequences, or at least less severe, but it’s pretty expected.