• m-p{3} ( mp3@lemmy.ca ) 
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    17
    ·
    1 month ago

    Telesat Lightspeed main focus is enterprise and defense clients though, they don’t plan to expand into direct consumer service which would require a larger deployment.

    Still nice to have an alternative to Starlink for that purpose though.

      • klankin ( klankin@piefed.ca ) 
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        5
        ·
        1 month ago

        If fiber companies used 1% of the money we throw at them to actually build fiber, sattelite internet would never need to exist.

        Its the most centralised, short term, low speed, expansive option possible and we are choosing it.

        • Fibre doesn’t work in airplanes or remote areas. Ukraine can’t use fibre in its very long range drones (they do for the short range ones).

          There different use cases. That said, I still agree with you, we should have more fibre.

          • klankin ( klankin@piefed.ca ) 
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            2
            ·
            1 month ago

            I agree-ish, wartime is something else, but if we have fiber up in Hudson bay we really don’t need-need starlink anywhere in 2026 (other than where we’ve dragged our feet getting fiber).

            airplanes could use an elliptical sattelite for their high speed, low latency requirments. Personally though any connection more than a high orbit satellite provides is a nice to have, but not safety critical by any means.

            Plus LEO is just intentionally wasteful, I wouldn’t be surprised if starlibk was a money hole without its military contracts.

            • I would argue the internet isn’t critical, and is in fact harmful, and we would be better without it. I expect downvotes for this- but my point is, critical doesn’t really come into the question imo.

              But I’m a bit of a luddite and think technology in general is bad for the human experience. Not inherently, but in practice.

        • Latency. Lower orbits give much less latency, and latency is a huge problem with satellite internet. This is especially bad if you’re trying to do anything realtime like, say, navigate a drone.

          That’s why Ukraine got so fucked by Musk throttling Starlink on them recently. They use it to pilot both their long range drone weapons and their drone interceptor systems that protect people from Russian drones.

            • Range, line of sight, and infrastructure.

              Radios have limited range. For reliable communication, that is limited to, functionally speaking, line of sight. While you’re probably aware that it’s possible to transmit radio signals beyond visual range by bouncing them off of the ionosphere, this kind of long range communication requires substantial infrastructure; eg, a tall radio antenna placed in a high up location. This doesn’t work for piloting drones because a) the drone does not have the benefit of substantial communications equipment on it’s part, and b) the tall or high antenna is obviously a very exposed and vulnerable target. It’s also extremely unreliable. While bouncing signals off the ionosphere is possible, it’s deeply imperfect, heavily weather dependent, and the interference involved could easily impair the operation of a drone.

              What Ukraine needs is the ability to:

              • operate a drone very, very far beyond line of sight. Several thousand kilometres in some cases.
              • do so reliably and without interruption of service
              • do so with equipment that does not require an exposed position to operate from. Starlink dishes or similar can be pointed almost straight up, so you can operate them from, say, a small clearing in a woodland, among a cluster of buildings, or down in a trench or foxhole. They also don’t need very much power, you can run one off of a portable generator.

              And they need to do all of that with as little latency as possible. LEO satellites are the only option that ticks all of those boxes.

              I will note that radio is used for the operation of FPV drones, the small drones piloted using a first person view (FPV) camera that you’ve probably taking out Russian tanks and troops. This is one of the key limitations of these drones; they cannot operate beyond visual range. That means if you’re separated from your target by a hill or tree line, you will likely lose control on the final approach. These weapons have been as effective as they are in Ukraine because the terrain is extremely flat and these kinds of obstructions are rare.

              But what we’re talking about here is specifically long range strike drones (intended to hit targets deep in Russian territory) and interceptor drones intended to knock out Russian long range strike drones being sent into Ukraine. In order to effect an intercept on an enemy long range strike drone you need to hit it as far out as possible. If you wait until you have line of sight, it’s already too late. Hence why, in both these cases, satellite communication is required.

  • Great, so we jam more satellites into orbit, redoubling the same work and clogging up massive swaths of spectrum just so we can have someone else dictating terms and taking profit. Wish we could do it once, globally, and be done with it.

  • antianarchist ( antianarchist@sopuli.xyz ) deleted by creator
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 month ago

    Keep on dreaming and wait for another 5-8y until this is actually comparable in terms of bandwidth and latency to Starlink in certain regions. You need a fuckton of satellites up there. Building is one thing. Having a payload slot on a carrier is the way more difficult part and one reason starlink was built so quickly. Their launch capacity is just insane. And if you don’t have your own space crafts, you just wait for a slot.