Let’s go ahead and just… set SAT scores aside. That’s a whole can of worms on the discrimination question, but I think at least we can all agree that your SAT score alone is not highly indicative of how good a student you are, how successful you are likely to be in further education and life, nor how valuable you will be at contributing to better educational standards for all other students at the university. Indeed, many elite universities are starting to deliberately disregard these scores for not being particularly useful to them.
What you are saying makes perfect sense and is exactly backward.
The assumption that all candidates are equal is what is being asserted when someone argues that acceptance rates should match the racial demographic breakdowns of application rates. That higher Asian application rates mean there should be higher Asian acceptance rates. My response to that is no, for a racially-underrepresented person to have similar test scores to a racially-overrepresented student implies that the underrepresented student worked harder to get there, all else being equal. They started with and overcame a systemic disadvantage and thus you should weight their scores to some degree.
If we set aside race and substitute it with something else, there’s no question this is true. If a student grew up wealthy going to elite private schools and with access to expensive and unusual extracurriculars is pitted against another student that grew up very poor and went to public school that had no extracurricular funding, and doesn’t have significantly better test scores than the poor student, that indicates the poor student showed more grit and achievement even if his test scores are slightly lower. They’re the better candidate. Not to even mention their background brings a piece of valuable (economic) diversity to the institution which all elite institutions agree improves academic outcomes for ALL students.
I understand why people get squeamish about the same thing when race is used. Saying “Asian students, for various diasporic reasons, have system advantages are preparing for and applying to elite, selective universities” feels like the same kind of “model minority” racist bullshit we all should have already set behind. But when the outcome of a policy shows racial underrepresentation of a group, it means systemic bias is at play and we should always seek to overcome systemic bias. Which is exactly what AA policies among elite institutions was doing.
The institution that picks the slightly higher-scoring wealthy student over the slightly lower-scoring poor student is foolish. They chose the worse candidate by being “blind” to the economic background. If we apply that same logic to race, it’s clear that race-blind admissions will lead to worse candidates being selected too.
Let’s go ahead and just… set SAT scores aside. That’s a whole can of worms on the discrimination question, but I think at least we can all agree that your SAT score alone is not highly indicative of how good a student you are, how successful you are likely to be in further education and life, nor how valuable you will be at contributing to better educational standards for all other students at the university. Indeed, many elite universities are starting to deliberately disregard these scores for not being particularly useful to them.
What you are saying makes perfect sense and is exactly backward.
The assumption that all candidates are equal is what is being asserted when someone argues that acceptance rates should match the racial demographic breakdowns of application rates. That higher Asian application rates mean there should be higher Asian acceptance rates. My response to that is no, for a racially-underrepresented person to have similar test scores to a racially-overrepresented student implies that the underrepresented student worked harder to get there, all else being equal. They started with and overcame a systemic disadvantage and thus you should weight their scores to some degree.
If we set aside race and substitute it with something else, there’s no question this is true. If a student grew up wealthy going to elite private schools and with access to expensive and unusual extracurriculars is pitted against another student that grew up very poor and went to public school that had no extracurricular funding, and doesn’t have significantly better test scores than the poor student, that indicates the poor student showed more grit and achievement even if his test scores are slightly lower. They’re the better candidate. Not to even mention their background brings a piece of valuable (economic) diversity to the institution which all elite institutions agree improves academic outcomes for ALL students.
I understand why people get squeamish about the same thing when race is used. Saying “Asian students, for various diasporic reasons, have system advantages are preparing for and applying to elite, selective universities” feels like the same kind of “model minority” racist bullshit we all should have already set behind. But when the outcome of a policy shows racial underrepresentation of a group, it means systemic bias is at play and we should always seek to overcome systemic bias. Which is exactly what AA policies among elite institutions was doing.
The institution that picks the slightly higher-scoring wealthy student over the slightly lower-scoring poor student is foolish. They chose the worse candidate by being “blind” to the economic background. If we apply that same logic to race, it’s clear that race-blind admissions will lead to worse candidates being selected too.