- cross-posted to:
- news
- globalnews@vlemmy.net
- Chipthemonk ( @Chipthemonk@lemmy.fmhy.ml ) 6•1 year ago
Apologizing for your forbears actions is strange to me. Colonialism had many bad results and effects, but it also brought about many incredibly positive changes and advancements. It’s not a black and white issue.
- lntl ( @lntl@lemmy.ml ) 6•1 year ago
When I first read this comment, I thought "for sure, not black and white. This fella says there’s ‘incredibly positive changes and advancements’ "
Then I tried to think of one positive change or advancement that colonialism brought about. I’m sorry, my lemon, I’m calling BS. Honestly, the best thing I could come up with was “a bunch of bananas for 79¢” and frankly, that industry is horrifying.
@Chipthemonk @BrikoX Is there something that makes you think positive changes & advancements wouldn’t have happened without colonialism?
- boyi ( @boyi@lemmy.sdf.org ) 2•1 year ago
Expedite technology transfer, for example. For the GB being able to exploit and plunder the Indian subcontinent, they have to provide good transport system to transfer all the plundered goods back to their country. Just look at Indian’s rail system now. It is hard to imagine them having it without this unintentional transfer of tech.
Having said that, I don’t condone using this argument to make things right. Ethically their still wrong. At least The Netherlands has the guts to admit it. My country is one of the countries exploited by the British. It is nice, as a good gesture, to hear the British to admit they used to be the bad guy. It’s not going to change anything in the past, but it can somehow provide a sense of closure for the future.
- Chipthemonk ( @Chipthemonk@lemmy.fmhy.ml ) 1•1 year ago
It’s hard to imagine that we would be where we are today, as a technologically advanced and free society in the west, without colonialism.
@Chipthemonk To assist your imagination, consider Japan. It wasn’t colonised (in fact it eventually became a coloniser) but found its own path to development.
- Lols [they/them] ( @Lols@lemm.ee ) 2•1 year ago
many incredibly positive changes and advancements for the netherlands from exploiting colonies that saw extremely little of that wealth making its way back
any wealth that did make its way back was nearly exclusively to aid in the exploitation, not out of some genuine kindness
not to mention that doing a good thing does not bar you from blame for reprehensible actions, such as the netherlands shockingly brutal retaliation to any disobedience by the indigenous people of its colonies
I.E. the netherlands got rich off the backs of its colonies, which were neglected and abused for it
not to mention their expansive role in the transatlantic slave trade
an apology from the main representative of the nation is more than warranted, and its honestly fucking embarrassing that this absolutely tiny, practically meaningless statement took this long
- Chipthemonk ( @Chipthemonk@lemmy.fmhy.ml ) 2•1 year ago
But what does this apology actually do? It doesn’t accomplish anything at this point. The people apologizing aren’t the perpetrators. “I’m sorry my great grandpa did horrific shit.” What? You weren’t even around when your great grandpa was. You are apologizing for something for which you have absolute no control or agency. It doesn’t make any sense.
- Lols [they/them] ( @Lols@lemm.ee ) 1•1 year ago
it acknowledges the crimes and that they were in fact bad things to do that we are not proud of, and it makes people feel better at 0 tangible cost to the netherlands
no one is suggesting that anyone alive today is at fault
i also dont know why you did some schpiel about how colonialism totally wasnt that bad if your real issue issue is apparently the lack of agency
- taanegl ( @taanegl@beehaw.org ) 1•1 year ago
By each passing day, monarchs of Europe look better than any house or senate representative.
“…bUt aT lEaSt wE’rE nOt a MoNaRcHy”
Yeah, but it’s starting to look a lot like the aristocracy.
- lntl ( @lntl@lemmy.ml ) 0•1 year ago
If you’re actually sorry, make ammends. Give the people of Congo your wealth Mr. King man.
- tchotchony ( @tchotchony@mander.xyz ) 1•1 year ago
Dutch, not Belgian.