Some of the LinkedIn Responses are direct and on-point, and also hilariously/depressingly based depending on how you look at it:
EDIT: In hindsight, I think I should’ve looked into posting this in a different community… It’s closer to a silly “innovation”… soo… is this considered FUD? I also don’t support smoking or vaping, especially among kids. Original title had “privacy-violating” before the “solution”.
- verdigris ( @verdigris@lemmy.ml ) 90•16 days ago
Good God I hate linkedin types. Imagine thinking writing an app that literally just displays a single notification is worthy of making a whole post about. They basically wrote a Hello World app for Android TV. And I’m sure they got paid like 40k by some poor school district to do so.
- fubarx ( @fubarx@lemmy.ml ) 71•16 days ago
How long before the students gamify it to see who can generate the most alerts?
- quant ( @quant@leminal.space ) English61•17 days ago
At least there are some criticisms. Considering it’s LinkedIn, forever, it will get drowned by a sea of synergy pivoting lunatics.
Rare LinkedIn ✨positive vibes✨ theater going off-script
- SSJMarx ( @SSJMarx@lemm.ee ) English52•16 days ago
we hope this will reduce vaping through social pressure
The social pressure of all of your friends knowing that you’re cool and break the rules?
- brokenlcd ( @brokenlcd@feddit.it ) 48•17 days ago
In my high school they managed to rip the alarm’s siren off the wall without triggering it; if these kids have even an 1/8 th of the ingenuity they had, these things aren’t gonna last
- Chuymatt ( @Chuymatt@beehaw.org ) 5•16 days ago
Plastic bag and a rubber band, my good sir!
- notfromhere ( @notfromhere@lemmy.ml ) 1•15 days ago
I’m intrigued. How does that work?
- Chuymatt ( @Chuymatt@beehaw.org ) 3•15 days ago
It has to have the vape fumes get to the sensor. Cover the sensor with the bag, tie off with rubber band. No more ability to sense what can’t get there.
I, in no way, am endorsing vaping, especially with kids.
- notfromhere ( @notfromhere@lemmy.ml ) 1•15 days ago
Oh haha yea. I thought that was for the alarm sirens.
- Possibly linux ( @possiblylinux127@lemmy.zip ) English4•16 days ago
That seems like a management issue.
They can see the time it went offline and then the time you walked out of the bathroom. It doesn’t take much to put it together.
Also I think these devices are designed to be resistant to tampering.
- wise_pancake ( @wise_pancake@lemmy.ca ) 2•15 days ago
Do kids prefer to not have doors then? Because I’m reading a lot of messed up headlines where the school removes the stall and bathroom doors and kids lose their privacy.
I’d rather have the TV with an alert than have to do competitive pooping.
- edinbruh ( @edinbruh@feddit.it ) 38•17 days ago
Tech Bros make a panopticon and call it a novel approach
- tetris11 ( @tetris11@lemmy.ml ) 11•17 days ago
A panopticon where it’s assumed that the inmates will repeatedly smash the doors, and the prison guards will repeatedly have to order new ones.
*sips beer* ah, the cycle of business
- lightnsfw ( @lightnsfw@reddthat.com ) 32•16 days ago
Imagine paying taxes for education and they spend it on shit like this.
- x00za ( @x00za@lemmy.dbzer0.com ) English25•16 days ago
- kibiz0r ( @kibiz0r@midwest.social ) English25•16 days ago
As it was with standardized testing, so shall it be with personal behavior: the goal is not to inform the student why, but to enforce compliance.
- SitD ( @SitD@lemy.lol ) 24•16 days ago
I’ll chime in with a weird take: this is a privacy community, we are united in a sense of defending our peaceful and unproblematic browsing on the internet and sending messages to friends from lunatics who seem to want everyone treated with the suspicion of highest criminal activity. the article posted describes a “privacy infringement” onto someone who not only has already broken the rule, but strongly publicized it by making people have to smell it. the perpetrators didn’t even have an expectation of privacy, so the premise is ridiculous.
I’ll say it like this: if the tv detects nicotine patches on someone’s skin, then i pick up the torches and pitchforks.
- shottymcb ( @shottymcb@lemm.ee ) 22•16 days ago
This may be a controversial take, but maybe we shouldn’t surveil children in bathrooms full stop.
- Allero ( @Allero@lemmy.today ) 9•16 days ago
There’s no indication they use cameras in there. It’s most likely just a sensor for vape smoke, similar to your common fire alarm.
And if it makes bathrooms a place where everyone can breathe without inhaling nicotine, I’m all for it. This is not a serious privacy concern.
- urheber ( @urheber@discuss.tchncs.de ) English4•15 days ago
Anything that picks anything up in a bathroom is a privacy concern.
In usual schools teachers are required to walk through every bathroom once in every break because the children are hiding in there to skip going in the yard. I do think this is much more annoying though.
- wise_pancake ( @wise_pancake@lemmy.ca ) 3•15 days ago
I think your take is too far. It’s just beyond reasonable.
If a teacher were outside the room and heard a loud crash, they’d go investigate. This is doing the same thing.
It isn’t identifying individuals, it doesn’t record any information about a person, it simply flags that somebody is breaking the rules and is worth taking a look.
This is about the least invasive technological solution you could get.
And it’s a heck of a lot better than alternatives like removing the stall doors.
- Nobilmantis ( @Nobilmantis@feddit.it ) 20•16 days ago
This. It’s a sensor, detecting only a specific air type. Not a camera, not a microphone. It doesn’t have to do with privacy, this is not “scan and collect data about all to punish one” and cannot be turned into one.
I’ll agree it’s a fuc**ing dumb idea. Like utter useless garbage. Classic capitalistic “fix behavioral trash-consumption issue with overpriced fancy tech products that sound amazing in theory and are garbage in practice, without fighting the problem at the root”. Screenshot comment said tax moeny but I’m willing to bet this is some kind of private school.
- Possibly linux ( @possiblylinux127@lemmy.zip ) English24•16 days ago
I am all for vape detectors. They only detect the fumes and aren’t really that invasive. They are basiclly specialized fire alarms.
Nicotine is very bad for developing brains. I don’t understand why you are ok with minors using it in a public school of all things.
- samwise_gamgee ( @samwise_gamgee@beehaw.org ) English14•16 days ago
It’s not really the detector that I have a problem with here, it’s the “reduce vaping incidents through social influence” part. Their plan (as I understand it) is to have a display outside the washroom to tell other kids that the person in the washroom is vaping and essentially get them to quit through public shaming, which is both cruel and ineffective. If the detector instead alerted teachers privately that there was someone vaping in the washroom then the teachers would deal with it appropriately, I think it could be okay.
My brother used to vape back in high school, and punishment never got him to stop, it just made him get more creative about how he hid it. When he eventually did quit after he graduated, he chose to because he knew it was harmful.
- Possibly linux ( @possiblylinux127@lemmy.zip ) English6•16 days ago
I think it is a bigger issue. I think the vaping companies need to be held liable for targeting under age kids.
I think long term the idea is to keep them from starting to begin with. That’s hard to do but getting it out of school will reduce the spread of the addiction. It definitely will be appreciated by the students who don’t vape and don’t want to smell or inhale it.
- Possibly linux ( @possiblylinux127@lemmy.zip ) English9•16 days ago
It is literally a glorified smoke alarm.
Although, I am sure it is a slippery slope. Next the may want to install CO2 detectors and water line monitoring. They even may install pencil sharpeners in the classroom
- BaroqueInMind ( @BaroqueInMind@lemmy.one ) 4•16 days ago
They might also finally getting around to deterring school shooters by mounting those cool AI powered Samsung smart guns they recently installed at the Korean DMZ
- Uriel238 [all pronouns] ( @uriel238@lemmy.blahaj.zone ) English23•16 days ago
Kids figure out how to provide false positives in 3… 2… 1…
- ByteOnBikes ( @ByteOnBikes@slrpnk.net ) 10•16 days ago
Doing minor “crime” in school was how I became a programmer!
- orca ( @orca@orcas.enjoying.yachts ) 23•16 days ago
I’m in tech and could never take myself seriously ever again if I built this.
- SpaceCowboy ( @SpaceCowboy@lemmy.ca ) 22•16 days ago
Sure it seems draconian, but how else are we going to get the kids to stop vaping and start smoking cigarettes like we did when we were in high school?
Won’t someone please think of Phillip Morris’ profit margins?
- Allero ( @Allero@lemmy.today ) 8•16 days ago
Doesn’t Phillip Morris profit from vapes, too?
Bringing vapes as a popular nicotine delivery system is literally the way tobacco companies are able to proliferate and return smoking into fashion.
Also, smoking should be prohibited as well. Not only because it hurts the smokers themselves, but because others are affected without their consent.
- TachyonTele ( @TachyonTele@lemm.ee ) 1•15 days ago
Your responding seriously to a joke.
- Hydra_Fk ( @Hydra_Fk@reddthat.com ) English1•11 days ago
A big salty tear.
- Ash ( @Leyley@lemmy.ml ) 22•16 days ago
Schools are more like prisons nowadays
- Hupf ( @Hupf@feddit.org ) 7•16 days ago
Start them early
- uis ( @uis@lemm.ee ) 2•16 days ago
Reeeeeeee! Fucking badges and metal detectors.