I’m looking to get a custom ROM that has good compatibility with my device. Would you recommend /e/? I couldn’t find a tutorial on how to install it with Linux but I don’t think it should be that hard to figure out.

  • LeTak ( LeTak@lemm.ee ) 
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    18
    ·
    2 年前

    It’s pretty solid. I use it daily and don’t have any big problems. Install is simple. Just install adb and fastboot from your linux repository. This should cover the most of the installation requirements.

      • Luffy ( Luffy879@lemmy.ml ) 
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        13
        ·
        edit-2
        2 年前

        I love the idea of the easy installer.

        looks at GrapheneOS installer… Literally just 3 buttons on a Website you have to click, all of the steps easily written with clear instructions for Linux as well as windows

        looks at /e/ installer

        • finds 5 Websites with installers for /e/, all of them apparantly official ones, decided to use https://e.foundation/installer/
        • Site dosent let you view this instructions without JavaScript.
        • enabled JS
        • Cant even use fcking Firefox to view this installer because a fcking pop-up Blocks my sight
        • goddamn privacy oriented Android Rom Website recommends using Microsoft edge or Opera (both of which are privacy nightmares, especially opera)
        • smashes pillow against the wall

        I give up. If you call that bloated peace of dierrhea an „Easy installer”, you could just as well say that gentoo is easier to install than mint.

  • I’ve used it for almost five years, flashed it myself on my FP3. I disabled microG and I’m very careful & strict about what I install on my phone, also their Advanced Privacy set of tools is pretty good. For my threat model is more than enough and I am very happy overall. Never had any serious issues, or even mildly serious ones tbh, despite people yelling about Android security updates arriving late. There was an outage in their cloud services in October that required a complete revamping of their server infrastructure and that took months but I don’t use their cloud so I wasn’t affected at all.

      • If OP was trying to secure themselves against interest from conventional state actor like a large intelligence service, I’d say they probably need to throw their phone in a woodchipper and start hitchhiking to the nearest professional spy training program.

        More realistic concerns that an ordinary person probably has are casual mass surveillance and local police fuckery. Random AOSP Roms are not sufficient to handle either of those threats.

          • Our local PD literally have access to stingrays, cellbrite/Pegasus (I don’t actually know which one they pay for) and military weaponry. In the suburbs, they have armored vehicles as well (tanks and APCs, not armored swat trucks).

            Obviously it varies by where you live because different departments will have different levels of funding and will ask for different toys from the feds, but you’d be surprised how comically over equipped many PDs are.

  • /e/ has good but not perfect privacy. It still contains connections to Google and they added a tracking parameter to their update calls.

    Their update cycles are very slow. You are usually one to two months behind monthly security updates. Full bulletins are a year behind and Webview is a problem as well. They ignore this point and do not realize, that Insuffizienz security is a privacy risk AS well.

    So if you want good privacy with a convenient user experience and without thoughts about security, here you go.

  • Imprint9816 ( Imprint9816@lemmy.dbzer0.com ) deleted by creator
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    8
    ·
    2 年前

    Hard truth: outside of GrapheneOS there is very little security and privacy gains from a custom Android OS over stock.

    From best to worst:

    Graphene OS

    iOS

    Stock Android / non rooted custom OS

    Branded stock android

    Rooted phones of any type

    EOL phones

          • Imprint9816 ( Imprint9816@lemmy.dbzer0.com ) deleted by creator
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            3
            ·
            2 年前

            Something’s are just more secure and private then others. That’s just a fact. For example, as of now GrapheneOS is the most secure and private consumer mobile OS. There is no gray area.

            Now whether your threat model requires it, can be much less black and white.

            But users here tend to gamify privacy and think they should get whatever the “best” one is. They tend to do whatever the most upvoted github list tells them to do.

            Rarely do I see someone like yourself, who considers threat model.

            • GrapheneOS wins, but whether iOS is more private than CalyxOS or /e/OS I think is very gray, and depends on the threat model, and on most devices they are going to be a significant improvement in privacy, and often security, over stock Android.

              And privacy may not be the only consideration when choosing a device.

              Since my threat model includes mainly surveillance capitalism (and no evil maids or targeted attacks) I don’t particularly feel like trusting a big tech that’s running their own targeted advertisement system.

              • Imprint9816 ( Imprint9816@lemmy.dbzer0.com ) deleted by creator
                link
                fedilink
                English
                arrow-up
                2
                ·
                edit-2
                2 年前

                Personally I think if you look at what privacy features CalyxOS actually offers or read reviews from someone like kuketz you realize its pretty lacking in both privacy and security.

                What Calyx does offer is a decently degoogled experience for people who don’t have the budget, access, or want for a Pixel with GOS.

                I understand your issues with Apple, that’s fair. OTOH I think their offerings, such as private relay, RCS messaging by default, properly implemented sandboxing are objectively better privacy features then what most android operating systems can offer. They also are much more reliable in terms of security updates.

                I also have had issues with Calyx using pretty obvious lies to market themselves such as saying the OS can’t be tampered without your knowledge. Not that Apple doesn’t have its fair share of blemishes.

              • Imprint9816 ( Imprint9816@lemmy.dbzer0.com ) deleted by creator
                link
                fedilink
                English
                arrow-up
                1
                ·
                edit-2
                2 年前

                Not necessarily, there are tons of things that are very secure but not at all private.

                But… having a massive attack surface and known security issues and thinking your data is somehow private because you use a FOSS application is silly.

                EDIT to answer your edit: partly. I mean regular timely security updates seems to be a struggle for most of these android OS but also because it provides a bunch of privacy by default options that these other android ROMs don’t such as a private relay, default RCS messaging, and makes them easy for users.

                • You do have a good point. However, I can’t consider a proprietary operating system like iOS truly private. It may be secure (certainly more so than stock Android and some random custom Android based ones) but if I can’t be sure that my operating system isn’t spying on me, then security alone doesn’t matter much for me tbh. Apple’s operating systems are no exception to this.

                  So, in a ranking that considers both security AND privacy, iOS being the second one is questionable. However, if the ranking is based solely on security, then I have no issue with it.

          • Imprint9816 ( Imprint9816@lemmy.dbzer0.com ) deleted by creator
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            3
            ·
            2 年前

            Lol nobody is calling windows secure or private. Nobody even mentioned it.

            Companies literally pay thousands of dollars a year in hardware and enterprise software to make up for its deficiencies.

  • Depends on how far you want to go. From what I’ve been able to tell, they pedel a lot of flashy metrics and still had a bunch of google calls. Some of which you can manually remove, same as LOS. I would avoid buying into their cloud and keeping an eye on things yourself, if you want to install it. I saw them rebrand a bunch of OSS tooling as their own products back then. Don’t know if things changed since then, but I don’t trust the marketing.

  • Im using it for a couple of years. I flashed my fairphone 3 by my self back then, before the easy installer. It was the first time i did something “advanced” with a phone, but it worked quite well. After my fairphone 3 died, I bought a Fairphone 4 via murena. So everything was already installed etc In total I am happy with the Os. Their goal, the release of privacy oriented OS for everyone (so f.e. even my parents could use them) is quite of a utopia I suppose. But still, the team and community are doing a good job.

    Yeah I already heard about grapheneOS, but its not working well with fairphone right? So murena it is for me :) And I would recommend to people, who are aware of the downsides and are little enthusiastic :)

      • It wasnt the battery, sadly. Some Fairphone3 have the issue, that their mainboard(?) is breaking down after a couple of years without any clear reason - and I was the lucky one. Its the only “unreplaceble” part and kind of phone breaker. Sure, you can replace this too, but it would somheow be like buying a new phone. At this point, the fairphone 4 was alreasy released, so I took the upgrade. Fairphone 4 and 5 have now a waranty of 5 instead of 2 years. So at least on this point ill be save for 3 years more :>

  • I used it for a few years on Oneplus Nord, and a few days ago switched to pixel7 with LineageOS. First impressions are that e/os was much more usable out of the box.

    I surely have worse experience with banking: Revolut and SmartID app just refuse to work due to rooted phone (worked well on e/os). Other bank app is somewhat more broken - on e/os it didnt fully load but at least showed notificatioms on each transaction, now doesnt and is useless.
    Could be due to newer android version on LineageOS though, I didnt investigate that.