cross-posted from: https://lemmy.ml/post/45061709

There are at least a dozen people spending at least several hours attacking GrapheneOS across platforms on a daily basis. It’s a very strange situation. How do these people have so much time and dedication to keep making posts across platforms attacking us? It’s relentless.

Every day, dozens of new accounts join our chat rooms to spread the same fabrications about GrapheneOS including via direct messages.

On Hacker News, one of the accounts making personal attacks based on fabrications in most threads about GrapheneOS has been doing it for 8 years.

Y Combinator has a financial stake in numerous surveillance and exploit development companies. Hacker News is a platform they own and the moderators on it have permitted years of vile harassment towards our team which they’d normally remove if others were targeted.

Hacker News mods micromanage it enough to repeatedly ask us not to reuse a bit of text across our comments. Meanwhile, they do nothing about disgusting personal attacks and harassment content consistently being spread in threads about GrapheneOS on their heavily moderated site.

The largest privacy community on Reddit /r/privacy bans any discussion or mentions of GrapheneOS. A bot automatically removes any post mentioning GrapheneOS they’ll very actively ban people who evade their filters. The mods of the subreddit misrepresent this as something we want.

Many privacy subreddits have mods who are hostile towards GrapheneOS. We were banned from posting on /r/Android for multiple years. The mod who banned us said our official project account on Reddit was ban evading because they once unjustifiably banned one of our team members.

On Wikipedia, a company attacking GrapheneOS project made years of edits to the site pushing false narratives about us. They cited articles based on their own press releases. Other content was made paraphrasing Wikipedia which ended up being cited by it. It continues to this day.

Articles about GrapheneOS on most platforms often have comments engaging in baseless personal attacks towards our team, linking to harassment content and making many clearly inaccurate claims about it. We’ve found chat rooms coordinating this including attacks on the X platform.

Privacy projects are more vulnerable to these attacks because the userbase and supporters largely avoid social media and other platforms where it happens. Many people believe what they read on social media if it isn’t countered and it builds echo chambers hostile to GrapheneOS.

Many people think these must be state sponsored attacks. However, our experience is these attacks are primarily orchestrated by companies selling dubious products marketed as private and secure. We did get targeted by state sponsored smear campaigns in France and Spain though.

    • Luke ( lukecooperatus@lemmy.ml ) 
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      11
      ·
      8 months ago

      That’s not a fair statement to make. As published in their FAQ, developer time is not what’s lacking in the effort to support more devices:

      For most [unsupported] devices, the hardware and firmware will prevent providing a reasonably secure device, regardless of the work put into device support.

    • DJ Putler ( mistermodal@lemmy.ml ) BannedBBannedOPB
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      3
      ·
      8 months ago

      I’ve never found this dumb joke appropriate when talking about all but the tiniest projects. How do projects gain & lose support for their development?

        • DJ Putler ( mistermodal@lemmy.ml ) BannedBBannedOPB
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          5
          ·
          8 months ago

          Yeah in your head where “civil discourse” is supposed to matter more than security standards. This is an operating system aimed at people who have high security standards. Once we clear this up, we can start talking about Graphene’s fundamental hardware privacy limitations & how far the chain of trust really goes. Responding to people who call you wrong actually improves your standing with those who view things rationally. The loudest voices on the internet are those who have the most time to waste. Like me at work!

            • DJ Putler ( mistermodal@lemmy.ml ) BannedBBannedOPB
              link
              fedilink
              arrow-up
              2
              ·
              8 months ago

              You’re literally talking shit about them right now, and promoting a goddanged youtube channel like I’m going to actually switch my audio track away from music so that a guy can complain in my headphones, or something. I could not give a fuck about >86% of what you just typed if someone put a gun in my mouth. This is how people who wish they could be in court but would get smoked talk. Publishing information about people’s attacks on you is called a response, which is allowed IMO. I’ll permit it! People online aren’t your students hitting each other. Pretending it’s their problem because you made it your problem with them is mindboggling to me. Better listening material for you, while we’re posting You Tubes: Popol Vuh – In den Gärten Pharaos.

              The optics of silence in the face of your critics is… what? In other words, I rebuke you demon

                • DJ Putler ( mistermodal@lemmy.ml ) BannedBBannedOPB
                  link
                  fedilink
                  arrow-up
                  2
                  ·
                  8 months ago
                  1. I don’t need to listen to someone talking about why it’s bad to respond to critics because of the optics. Framing is dumb. Tech youtubers are awful and the good ones get banned. 2. I said I could not give a fuck about what you just said. Having fun and playing online is a priority. Not doing what random people say like WATCH MY YOUTUBES.
          • Auli ( Auli@lemmy.ca ) 
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            2
            ·
            8 months ago

            It has put put me off from using not for a long while, when he was fighting with calyx OS. The graphenOS community was toxic don’t know if it still is.

            • DJ Putler ( mistermodal@lemmy.ml ) BannedBBannedOPB
              link
              fedilink
              arrow-up
              1
              ·
              8 months ago

              I don’t really get the “community toxicity” thing when ppl are talking about stuff that can land you in jail. If you think online arguments are stressful, imagine prison! Can’t log off from prison. Besides, arguments online are fun if you change your perspective on them.

    • DJ Putler ( mistermodal@lemmy.ml ) BannedBBannedOPB
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      4
      ·
      8 months ago

      LineageOS is chill IDK why you think having extreme device security doesn’t matter to people, in many corporate settings it’s worthwhile. Probably undermined by Google anyways, but that can never be admitted in COURT. I run LineageOS on a Pixel with a bunch of shit changed for privacy, used to have GOS, the Pixel was the best option on Swappa! I take a lotta pics 👀. I find the GOS forums a useful resource and I hate everyone they hate so it works out dawg. Yeah, structurally bound to Google and the US chip infrastructure is bad. Get Chinese shit. I just need my FDroid shit to live, that’s what really binds me to Google’s ecosystem.

      Don’t forget to mention GrapheneOS gets to keep all their fingers and ears because the feds use their stuff. Think they can’t get into a Google device? I just don’t believe it. Peace indeed

    • LedgeDrop ( LedgeDrop@lemmy.zip ) 
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      8 months ago

      I do use a (modded) version of graphene as a daily driver and I do appreciate many of the features that it offer.

      And I totally agree that some people seem to try to turn graphene into some rigid cult (especially on the philosophy of running root and “who decides how application backup should be made? The application developer or the device/data owner”)

      That said:

      the idea that the only way I can not get assraped on the reg is to give a shitload of money to google and then use this elitist OS is something I have a gigantic problem with.

      There is actually a technical reason for this. Pixel phones are the only ones to support custom AvB keys.

      Basically, this allows you (or graphene) to create a key, which can be used to sign your custom firmware. So, you can have a locked bootloader that will only allow OS updates signed with your key.

      You can basically create your own OTA updates. It’s fantastic.

      It’s amazing and disappointing that most phone manufacturers don’t allow custom AvB keys, but it’s a reflection of how they truly don’t care about people who like to tinker.

      Now, should the lack of custom AvB keys be a barrier towards using graphene? Tbh, I don’t think so - but it does fit the graphene rigid MO of “root is bad”.

      edit : fixed link

    • DJ Putler ( mistermodal@lemmy.ml ) BannedBBannedOPB
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      4
      ·
      8 months ago

      I mean you could just go take a look at their other posts? It’s one statement about it. Maybe I could add hyperlinks to everything if I suddenly care more about that than making people mad in a kinda interesting way today. It’s unpredictable. Phone’s only fun at work. At home it becomes the bad screen.

  • krolden ( krolden@lemmy.ml ) 
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    8 months ago

    I love how strcat never posts any links to these things and just goes on these multi post rants.

    I see it as a good thing because he makes a very paranoid android.