- magnetosphere ( @HappyMeatbag@beehaw.org ) 88•1 year ago
Some mistakes make you want the person responsible fired, but some mistakes are SO bad that you actually feel sorry for them instead. This falls into the second category.
- JakenVeina ( @JakenVeina@lemm.ee ) 66•1 year ago
That’s because a flaw like this is the result of SYSTEMATIC failure, not any one person. Who reviewed these designs? Who was responsible for usability testing? Who reviewed those plans? Was usability testing even performed?
- SokathHisEyesOpen ( @Anticorp@lemmy.ml ) 14•1 year ago
Was usability testing even performed?
If it was, it wasn’t tested with every cable type or they would have discovered this issue.
- waspentalive ( @waspentalive@kbin.social ) 16•1 year ago
Some places don’t fire unless the issue is repeated, client-facing, or willfully dangerous (like assaulting co-workers). The theory is: This is the first time this has happened - we learned from it, the engineer specifically probably learned from it. This won’t happen again.
- Ubermeisters ( @Ubermeisters@lemmy.zip ) English52•1 year ago
Is that the engineers fault? Or is that the people who are supposed to check for usability after the engineer is done designing the functional aspects? Because it’s not usually an engineer’s job to do this…
Basic product testing is the foundation of manufacturing, an error like this doesn’t get all the way through production and it still be just the engineers fault.
- Rivalarrival ( @Rivalarrival@lemmy.today ) 17•1 year ago
They probably reused a PCB from another model that used a paperclip hole reset. They duplicated the design, sent it for testing, and came back with “everything is great, but make the reset a push button before you ship it.” Engineering probably said “ok. But it will need to go back for usability testing” and sales said “fuck that, send it”
- criticon ( @criticon@lemmy.ca ) 8•1 year ago
Or another possibility, after proto and lots of testing: “we need to move test button a couple of cm to the right, away from the corner. No further tests needed”
- Ubermeisters ( @Ubermeisters@lemmy.zip ) English3•1 year ago
That seems highly plausible to me
- stealth_cookies ( @stealth_cookies@lemmy.ca ) 7•1 year ago
Yes it is the engineers fault, but even then there should have been multiple people that should have caught such an issue along the way.
- crimroy ( @crimroy@sopuli.xyz ) 6•1 year ago
Probably both, but you’re right, there’s definitely a qa problem here
- Llewellyn ( @Llewellyn@lemm.ee ) 5•1 year ago
It’s very strange engineer, if he doesn’t aware of RJ45 connector form-factors.
- Ubermeisters ( @Ubermeisters@lemmy.zip ) English4•1 year ago
Hey I’m not absolving the engineer for not doing basic interference checks but I’m saying it’s also somebody else’s job I’m sure, Cisco’s not a small company.
- Llewellyn ( @Llewellyn@lemm.ee ) 1•1 year ago
What’s the point of mentioning that it’s someone else job too?
- Ubermeisters ( @Ubermeisters@lemmy.zip ) English4•1 year ago
What’s the point of putting it all on the engineer?
- Llewellyn ( @Llewellyn@lemm.ee ) 1•1 year ago
Who’s putting it all on the engineer?
- napalminjello ( @napalminjello@kbin.social ) 3•1 year ago
It literally says “at least you’re not the Cisco design engineer…”
- Llewellyn ( @Llewellyn@lemm.ee ) 1•1 year ago
And? It showcases engineer fault, but how do it shift all blame to him?
- Nkiru Anaya ( @nkiruanaya@lemm.ee ) 22•1 year ago
/r/crappydesign
Oh wait, this isn’t the Reddit anymore.
- !crappydesign@sh.itjust.works
- !assholedesign@lemmy.ml
- !assholedesign@lemmy.world
- !crappydesign@zerobytes.monster
Did I do that right?
- AgnosticMammal ( @AgnosticMammal@pawb.social ) 8•1 year ago
Exclamation mark denotes the community, so:
!crappydesign@zerobytes.monster
The @ is the username indicator, so you’ve pinged people whose usernames are those for the instance.
- Phazei ( @Phazei@lemmy.ml ) English2•1 year ago
This is one of those double edged sword things with Lemmy, since there’s so many places a community can be, they all end up being a little smaller. There’s got to be a better solution for that. Maybe when creating a community there should be a way to automatically search a large portion of committed all at once and display it to the user.
- gatelike ( @gatelike@feddit.de ) English19•1 year ago
did they change careers after that? I would want to work on a farm and touch grass every day with my new friends, the animals.
- astral_avocado ( @astral_avocado@lemm.ee ) 5•1 year ago
Cisco and Juniper need to die as entities like 5 years ago. They’re single-handedly holding back all of networking from entering the modern era of computing.
- LargestDong ( @LargestDong@lemm.ee ) 3•1 year ago
You must not work in enterprise IT. Every lower level network engineer says this until they gain more skills and experience with them. Then they realize the full extent of features Cisco and Juniper support that others don’t
- astral_avocado ( @astral_avocado@lemm.ee ) 2•1 year ago
Surprising opinion, I was only a junior in my brief stint at networking but all my seniors shared this opinion.
- jasondj ( @jasondj@ttrpg.network ) 5•1 year ago
Was there a recall? I remember them sending out an advisory of the default behavior (and how to disable it), then changing the default behavior in software.
- dap ( @dap@lemmy.onlylans.io ) English4•1 year ago
I actually, legitimately, laughed out loud at this one 🤣