For some reason when I’m talking to an American from the North East and the fact that I’m mixed comes up they always say they aren’t white they’re actually native because his grandpa once mentioned something about a Cherokee ancestor.
It’s always Cherokee, no other tribe but that one. And it’s always the whitest looking person ever, straight up 6ft tall blue eyed and blond guy.
I get it, I’m mostly white too, Spanish and Slavic. But even tho I’m not mostly native American I still look native enough that people think I’m Asian.
But when your ancestry has been so diluted over the generations… You’re not native. It’s not just that you don’t look native, it’s also that you don’t even participate in the culture.
Dude you’re just a farm boy from Philadelphia you’re probably more Amish than Cherokee, if that supposed ancestor is even real at all and not just some random claim by some of your ancestors to have a “right over these lands”.
Also let’s not talk about white families using the “Cherokee ancestor” excuse to hide a black ancestor as a part to justify darker features. I’ve seen this happen as well.
In Australia, it’s the opposite. My family has a story of an Afghani ancestor that was used to hide indigenous Australian heritage.
Though maybe that’s the same, because it’s hiding black ancestry behind pretend non black ancestry…
I just discovered Native Australians are considered black. I thought they were considered a distinct race since they’re genetically not Sub-Saharan African but South Asians
Different heritage, but very much considered black. Australia has a whole racist history that marginalises indigenous Australians explicitly on their blackness…
Yeah it blew my mind when a few times I was called black in Australia when I am of Indian heritage. One even made a joke about my penis being larger!
In Britain, Asian means someone from Indian/Pakistani part of area of Asia, whereas in North America and Australia it means Chinese/Japanese parts of Asia.
Blackness/Whiteness is an interesting concept - it’s remarkably fluid, especially with changes in time and place. Race isn’t the same as ethnicity or genetics, or a direct result of it, although racists often try to claim it is - a stark example of this in Western societies like the US and Australia would be how they categorize Italian and Greek peoples, Slavic peoples, or ethnically-Jewish peoples - the idea of whether or not each of these is White has largely shifted over time, often as a group stops being the current biggest immigration demographic. The USA even had a concept of “Black Irish”, which originally meant a post-Famine Irish refugee. Human races are ultimately just social classes, not a biological concept.
Another aspect, related to this thread, is hypodescent. In some societies (it’s not a universal thing!), if a child has a Black parent and a White parent, is the child Black or White, or another label entirely? As mentioned in that article, some US states used to legally define someone as Black even if only 1 of their 16 great-great-grandparents were Black.
Its kind of an American thing to brag about having 1/16 of insert heritage here
“I’m Irish, you know.”
I see it with White middle aged Americans.
Them: Oh me I’m Irish
Me: Oh, your parents, grandparents came over?
Them: No, Great Great Great Great… Grandfather
Me: huh, OK. Have you ever been to Ireland?
Them: No, I want to one day.
My great grandmother was a Catawba, I spent a lot of time with her as a kid, and I remember her telling me about a few things. She used to make little trinkets and decorations because her grandmother taught her how, and I wish I had paid more attention because that’s so cool and I hate that her knowledge died with her.
Instead, I was very little, so the only thing I actually got from her is some memories and my resilience against the sun. I’m a fairly pale lady due to being inside a lot, but I have an uncanny ability to recover from sunburn real quick, just like my mom and her mom. My wife will burn after 2-3 hours and be in pain for days but I’ll be fine the next morning after the same amount of time in the sun. The burn will have already become a tan.
… But importantly, I have never used that to say I am not white, and it confuses the heck out of me that anyone does.
I dont even think you skin colour or genetics should have anything to do with your it. People should be identified by there personal connection with culture.
For example if white colored person was brought up in a native american tribe they should still be considered a native american.
Race has no logical basis and anyone who consideres themselves native because they have whatever% genetics is racist. Thats my take at least.
Genetics do play a role and trying to pretend otherwise is disingenuous. I am visually not white, even if I don’t have a connection to my Andean heritage my looks are still impacted by them.
If someone asks me why I look like I do what do you expect me to tell them?
Of course genetics play a role, I’m not saying racism isn’t real. But genetics shouldn’t play a role.
Why you look like you do is irrelivent. Them asking you that shows they have a flawed perspective of identity.
And this is an idealist take that is not reflective of the real world. I dont know how to talk to people or respond to a question like that in reality.
There’s a few good chapters on “self-indigenization” in Roxanne Dunbar-Ortiz - Not a nation of immigrants.
Linking to a reply I posted in this thread because it talks about a relevant aspect, which other (correct) comments haven’t named: hypodescent.
Go back far enouph we are all not native. We are all immigrants from Africa as far as I know.
Not sure why you got downvoted, they have probed microchondrial DNA and shows the timeline of emergence from africa and spreading migration paths.







