• The problem is not that this technologies are or aren’t a grift, the problem is that they are used to grift (and that the 4th power that is supposed to protect us against this isn’t doing its job).

    In that sense : every next technology will be a grift. Look at spaceX, he sold refueling booster as the next step in human space exploration evolution and finally its just another company used to mine our data. Grift

    • Dessalines ( dessalines@lemmy.ml ) 
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      9
      ·
      5 months ago

      This to me is the most exciting thing. And not just solar, but also modular nuclear power, fusion power, battery tech. The PRC is at the forefront of this green revolution.

  • SirEDCaLot ( SirEDCaLot@lemmy.today ) 
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    25
    ·
    5 months ago

    These technologies are not grifts.

    The way they are often employed is absolutely a grift.

    Blockchain is a very cool concept. Getting people to pay $1,000 for a picture of a cat and imply that it has value because it’s on a blockchain is grift.

    Ai is a cool technology. It has become a grift because the companies behind it are sucking up massive investor dollars, destroying the worldwide computing parts market, and persuading managers to axe jobs promising the AI can take their place.

    If quantum computing actually starts to work some of it will be used for grift because many current encryption schemes could potentially be cracked using quantum computers.

  • daniskarma ( daniskarma@lemmy.dbzer0.com ) 
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    23
    ·
    edit-2
    5 months ago

    I don’t see why put quantum computer in that group.

    It’s a scientific research topic. It is know what it does and what it doesn’t do. And they are not selling you it’s going to be the future.

    It’s just a developing technology which have potential to make some algorithms more efficient than binary computation.

    They don’t sell you quantum computation, they don’t tell you to invest in it. It’s just something being researched by computer scientists.

    Let’s not be that much anti-any-kind-of-progress, shall we?

    • Artificial Intelligence is also a research topic. But when snake oil merchants figured out that they could use the term to take lots of money from the hands of unsuspecting people, it became a grift. As such I believe the inclusion of quantum computing in the group is on point

    • megopie ( megopie@beehaw.org ) 
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      5 months ago

      Quantum computers are a thing, and they’re very useful for certain things…

      But business idiots in the tech world do be slapping the word “quantum” on stuff. It’s not a huge thing at the moment, but it’s probably gonna be the next insufferable hype cycle after they get tired of branding random shit as “AI enabled” because they stapled a chat bot on to it.

      Like, give it a few years, someone will be trying to tell you that a quantum computer will somehow make a vacuum robot able to do your laundry because “something something better path finding”

          • What?

            Post quantum encryption algorithms are the ones that any serious company should use right now.

            Because one of the algorithms that it’s stated to be far more efficient on a quantum computer than a binary one are number factorization, which is the bases of many public private enceyption algorithms like RSA.

            Right now it’s not possible, but listen now decrypt later means that anything encrypted now might be decrypted in not so many years by a quantum computer.

            They are not selling you a quantum computer, they are “selling” the algorithm you should be using if you don’t want your communications to be easily decrypted when a quantum computer with a higher number of stable qbits hits production.

            Those algorithms are, anyway, public and well know, like parabolic curve algorithm or lattices. You could implement them yourself, any company can do so.

    • I am not against any of the tech i listed, i think they all are neat and quite interesting to study and use.

      you have probably not been around the forums to realise why i put it there, QC discussion these days are leaning towards the it’s a grift/ it will never be viable territory. This is mostly in large part due to M$ and their claims. there is also some subtle fear mongering going on with the recent push towards quantam resistant encryption standards.

      So i am not calling QC a grift, I am calling out that whenever it becomes viable for the companies that are researching it to rent their computers to consumers, people will start calling it the next grift.

  • Nah they’re not inherently grifts; they’re pushed by grifters making money off the back of them.

    I think Lemmy users are more likely to call these grifters out for what they are, because the user base has proportionally more technically minded people who understand what the technology is. Lemmy users have to an extent self-selected themselves into the fediverse. On other social media the absolute number of technically minded people will be higher but the proportion of technically minded people is much lower, so the voices are drowned out by those who don’t understand he technology and it’s limitations. And of course the grifters target those platforms with a lot of propaganda, because ultimately it’s about selling shares and inflating share prices.

    Anyway to answer you question, CRISPR gene editing is revolutionary and will have major impact. Nuclear Fusion despite it’s slow emergence will also be revolutionary. Immunotherapy is an ongoing revolution; it’s not a quiet revolution but it’s also not getting the general focus it probably should be as AI appears to dominate the current zeitgeist.

    We are actually living through extraordinary times; AI is a part of it but AI seems to be the bit getting most of the attention because we’re in the middle of a stock bubble driven by AI speculation.

  • All technologies are grifts when controlled by the capitalist class and marketed under the logic of capitalism. Simple as that. Even the simple hammers you find at a hardware store are a side effect of some rich asshole’s money hoarding operation.

    For this reason, I do not reject the listed technologies outright. (Although I do not personally know of a non-capitalist use for Blockchain, I’m open to suggestions.) I reject the capitalists who control these technologies.

  • Capitalism is what makes them grifts. Llms could be neat. Theft at scale, environmental impact, and using it to kill little kids (anyone but jfc the kids killed wtf) is the problem. Its always the horrid companies and governments who look at any tech like “can i hurt people with this? I totally can…”

  • Jack ( JustJack23@slrpnk.net ) 
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    12
    ·
    5 months ago

    I think it is only partly dependant on the technology. Each of the listed technologies CAN have useful applications, but the current capitalist system is expecting unattainable growth so ot creates bubbles and in the bubbles there are grifters.