But F the poor I guess

  • Ronno ( Ronno@kbin.social ) 
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    22
    ·
    3 years ago

    It’s easy to polarize with such a headline/picture. Reality is way more nuanced than this:

    Migrants are in fact being saved from shipwrecks, it is (sadly) in the news every week or so. The main problem is that these migrants don’t have communication devices with them to signal emergencies, unlike the submarine. The boat on the surface alarmed emergency services when they lost connection with the sub, starting the rescue operation. It is difficult to rescue a boat of migrants, when you don’t even know that they are in danger in the first place.

    Secondly, the harsh reality is that most migrants try to enter a country illegally. Which by definition, is a huge risk on their part. The rich people on the sub were not doing anything illegal. However, in both cases, the people in or on the boat accepted the risks involved in their endeavor.

          • … Of course it is? We have things like taxation and social safety nets that allow a society to function. Never mind the simple fact that some places are stressed for resources as it is. That’s not to say it can’t be done better, but it’s naive to think it’s “simple”. Never mind that simple doesn’t necessarily mean easy…

            • fu ( fu@libranet.de ) OP
              link
              fedilink
              arrow-up
              2
              ·
              3 years ago

              @Ronno @Banana this sounds very similar to “who will pick the cotton?” that was “just asking questions” as to why slavery should remain legal in the southern united states in the 19th century. It’s the right thing to do. One’s individual rights does not force obligations on the other. A freed market would provide.

              • Ronno ( Ronno@kbin.social ) 
                link
                fedilink
                arrow-up
                1
                ·
                3 years ago

                IMO, those are very different situations, with slavery their freedom was taken. Most of the migrants (not refugees) are free, they are simply in search for a better life. Which is understandable, don’t get me wrong. But the picture that is painted is too bright, people hop on a boat to “paradise” and are promised a life of riches. The reality is, this is not the situation they will find themselves in. Even if we were to allow them into the country, they would still live poor lives. Sure some will succeed, but most of them don’t have the foundational knowledge/skills/command of the language of the country to get a job and find a place to live.

                Meanwhile, looking at my own country The Netherlands, we see that natives are also struggling for housing. My generation is basically fucked, young families cannot buy nor rent a home to start their family in. This will impact The Netherlands for years/decades to come, it will be reflected in birth rate and future workforce. Allowing other people in the country now would be catastrophic.

                On the other hand, recently there was an article about an approach by French farmers which I like. They sourced Moroccan workers, that could work in France for a couple months (IIRC max stay was 3 months), during this time, the workers would receive fair pay. After the work permit ends, the workers have to go back to Morocco. Then they are only allowed to go back to work in France after a period of time, with a new workers permit.

                The key benefit is that workers bring the money back home, benefitting Morocco financially, and France with workforce. Most of this work by the farmers is seasonal anyway.

  • If these dumbasses have enough money to drop on a ticket aboard this sub to look at something you can see on a documentary, they should also have to foot the bill for the rescue mission. I’m sure all these rescue programs are tax funded that they dodge themselves. So, not only are they squirreling and eating up money we could all be using, but now we’re picking up the check.

    • That’s just the start my dude. Once we disregard insignificant values like human rights and personal freedom, solving the issue of other people making problematic choices becomes trivial.

      Imagine all the crime we would prevent if we just locked up anyone who earns less than say 50k euros.

  • Nobody cares that they are millionaires!
    You think the coastguard is only helping them because they are millionaires? No they are trying to help because it’s their job!

    I guess all those miners getting stuck in mines during collapses and millions of equipment was shipped over to try and save them over weeks of time was because the miners were all millionaires.

    You have a fucked up view of the world if you think only millionaires get helped in emergency situations.

    • A bunch of super wealthy dudes (including a bloke who went to space with Mr. Amazon and two members of one of Pakistan’s biggest petrochemical families) got into an obvious death trap after signing a waiver that said that there’s a decent chance that it’d kill them and now that it’s gone missing multiple governments are spending millions of dollars on an attempt to rescue them on the off chance that they’re actually still alive because the lives of the wealthy matter more than the lives of normal people.

      • ZapBeebz ( ZapBeebz@beehaw.org ) 
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        6
        ·
        3 years ago

        Or maybe it has to do more with the region in which they’re lost. The USCG is typically very good about aiding anyone within their AOR, no matter their socioeconomic class. This should be framed more as “why isn’t Europe/Greece doing their jobs” than “why are the USCG/Canada actually doing their jobs”.

    • jeebus ( jeebus@kbin.social ) 
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      6
      ·
      3 years ago

      Some rich people got put into a submersible where the glass hatch is bolted to the vehicle. The pilot then proceeds to turn on the Xbox controller to activate the vehicle. None of these rich people thought they should ask if the vehicle had and safety precautions, or perhaps a fucking steering wheel. The media has gone nuts over this story. Like “balloon boy” nuts.

  • da_g ( da_g@feddit.it ) 
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    5
    ·
    3 years ago

    I know this could be controversial, but in some countries immigration is quite a problem, there isn’t enough work for everyone and the crime just gets higher an higher plus they do it illegally, not quite the same even though I get y’all sentiment

    • there isn’t enough work for everyone

      Immigrants induce demand for goods and services just like anyone else, thus the jobs to render those goods and services.

      the crime just gets higher and higher

      Technically depends on the country but this is usually false.

      plus they do it illegally

      Law is not morality. Perhaps it shouldn’t be illegal.

      • I always hated the legal argument. No landmass was ever historically conquered /populated / taken over / whatever through “legal immigration” except by indigenous peoples of those lands. These immigrants are trying to find better lives for themselves and their families and it’s horrible that people refuse to show any empathy for their struggles or dreams

      • da_g ( da_g@feddit.it ) 
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        3 years ago

        I’m just not going to talk to someone who thinks he’s morally superior just because he will never admit he’s wrong even if he is plus you don’t know our situation

    • drolex ( drolex@sopuli.xyz ) 
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      12
      ·
      3 years ago

      It’s not controversial, it’s just wrong. Immigration never takes jobs away, it always allows to create more jobs by inflating the local economy. Miami absorbed Cuban migrants after Mariel, and went richer. It has been widely studied now: immigrants took first low paying jobs that were understaffed, it injected more money in the local economy and it allowed spouses who were not working because they were doing the low paying jobs for free (nannying for instance) to get back to high paying jobs, it injects more money… Same in Germany with Syrian intake

      • da_g ( da_g@feddit.it ) 
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        3 years ago

        It doesn’t always work out man, I live it in first person, they don’t integrate don’t work because we need every last job we have and distrust public peace

  • NotaLLM ( NotaLLM@kbin.social ) 
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    3 years ago

    The US federal government values the average citizen’s life at something like ~$12 million. This is mostly for policy like if 1,000 people a year die from something, say an unsafe ferris wheel design, a solution that would save them costing more than (1,000*12,000,000=)$12 billion would be rejected and considered not worth the economic cost. If the solution were cheaper, and cost like $500 million, then with good lobbying and a reasonable administration, it could easily become a new regulation.

    Generally speaking if 5 anybodies went down like this submersible, you’d expect at least some millions to be spent in recovery missions.


    https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2020/07/17/870483369/your-life-is-worth-10-million-according-to-the-government

    The ~$12 million figure is what the NHTSA is currently using for its purposes.

    • fu ( fu@libranet.de ) OP
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      4
      ·
      3 years ago

      average citizen’s life

      That’s the problem, we allow our governments to treat people differently based on where they happen to have been born.

  • Problem is the choices are;

    A) seeing migrants die en masse makes people feel bad and helpless and weak.

    B) Allowing people to say “stupid dumbass billionaires” makes people feel like they are better than some stupid dumbass billionaires.

    It was always going to be B. Most times the media just goes where we demand it goes. If you want to complain about why the media is so shit -blame all of us.